I had submitted this a week ago without the "Show HN" tag, out of ignorance of this section being available. So apologies for the double post.
I like tinkering in the kitchen, and I've had this tumbling around in my head for a while. So I decided to bang it out a couple weekends ago. It's simply a recipe manager for people enjoy creating new recipes, and want some type of revision history during the process.
I like it. Something you could add that would be great for bakers would be the ability to convert common ingredients between volume and weight. King Arthur Flour's website has the option for their recipes, and it's very useful since you don't have to dig for a recipe with the weights, which are better for baking anyways.
Humidity/environment affects the amount of water used in baking quite a bit, so revision history would be useful for bakers already.
Hey! Thanks for the feedback, and I'll definitely add it to my list for review. You're the first to specifically request something regarding baking, and it's something I've not thought about. Have to think of an elegant way of doing conversions in the GUI, without making too much clutter, but I agree, helpful feature.
Do you have this up on Github?
It's really cool project with a ton of potential.
I'd be curious about your tech stack.
I really like the look of the UI.
I think maybe having sort of like a simple user profile like Github has, with a pic and some basic info would be good to. Along with the ability to make some recipes public and view other users.
No GitHub available, and thank you for the praise. As far as tech is concerned, NodeJS + VueJS + RethinkDB. I have a lot planned, but alas this is a one man operation, so I'll be releasing new features as quickly as possible. Certainly there is a lot to be desired regarding a more social aspect of it, but I wanted to nail down at least the core idea first. My initial intent of this was more of a private recipe manager, but I can see the appeal, as I've enabled simple "publishing" so far, which puts the most recent recipe revision on the front page. More to come for sure!
Hey thanks again Nick! Really just starting to get the ball rolling with this project. The feedback has been overall positive, so the biggest tasks right now are getting users happy with some needed features, and spreading the word. I'll update this post if I have plans to open it up.
I've considered the visualization of diffs, but I really, really don't want this too complex to the average cook. As far as "forking" is concerned, you CAN copy their recipe right now. There will be an indicator that says the "original recipe", with a link to the OG recipe.(I just haven't published the template yet.) The copy works, and it will be a completely new recipe associated with your profile. A simplistic visual tree of it's origins to where it ended up is a good thought though.
I understand your concern regarding the social networks, but user security is paramount to me. Especially when this is a one man crew. Dealing with local accounts is just another avenue of anguish, I don't want to deal with right now. The big guys have already invested millions in making their services bullet proof. Possibly in the future with tokens based on email alone, I'm just anti passwords. Is there another auth method you'd consider? I can certainly add just about anything that supports oAuth.
- This is a top priority, hopefully I'll have something (albeit crude) sorted for the weekend.
- I'm on the fence with pictures of food at the moment. I really want this focused on being a recipe manager for creators, without the clutter of being an Instagram of food. Not just another recipe "dump" to get lost in the mix. People focus on uploading filtered pics of everything, and it loses the spirit of creation. I will be adding more utilities to search for ingredients, and social aspects. But the pictures may be off in the far distance. I'll see how feedback comes in regarding it.
- Yes agreed, lots of little quality of life stuff to be done. I'm working on it :)
It'd be nice to have the recipe title in the URL. For example, if [1] was something like [2] (or something) it'd be helpful when looking at the URL for a recipe.
Agreed, it's in the roadmap! Initially I wanted to make the URL's as short as possible , for sharing purposes, but I can see this would be much more beneficial. Thanks for your feedback :)
Much simpler than that, simply regex the route to ignore past the recipe ID. Everything after is just descriptive text. This allows both as you suggested. I'm adding this tonight along with some other updates.
19 comments
[ 2.8 ms ] story [ 40.4 ms ] threadI like tinkering in the kitchen, and I've had this tumbling around in my head for a while. So I decided to bang it out a couple weekends ago. It's simply a recipe manager for people enjoy creating new recipes, and want some type of revision history during the process.
Feedback definitely welcome.
Humidity/environment affects the amount of water used in baking quite a bit, so revision history would be useful for bakers already.
I really like the look of the UI.
I think maybe having sort of like a simple user profile like Github has, with a pic and some basic info would be good to. Along with the ability to make some recipes public and view other users.
No GitHub available, and thank you for the praise. As far as tech is concerned, NodeJS + VueJS + RethinkDB. I have a lot planned, but alas this is a one man operation, so I'll be releasing new features as quickly as possible. Certainly there is a lot to be desired regarding a more social aspect of it, but I wanted to nail down at least the core idea first. My initial intent of this was more of a private recipe manager, but I can see the appeal, as I've enabled simple "publishing" so far, which puts the most recent recipe revision on the front page. More to come for sure!
My only complaint and not wanting to sound like a grumpy old fart, but you want me to login with none of the things I would ever want to login with.
I understand your concern regarding the social networks, but user security is paramount to me. Especially when this is a one man crew. Dealing with local accounts is just another avenue of anguish, I don't want to deal with right now. The big guys have already invested millions in making their services bullet proof. Possibly in the future with tokens based on email alone, I'm just anti passwords. Is there another auth method you'd consider? I can certainly add just about anything that supports oAuth.
Thanks for the feedback!
- a button to convert to SI units, please
- add picture, as it's hard to choose recipe without one if you don't have a specific recipe in mind (a.k.a "what to do for dinner tonight?")
- a very minor notice, but add blank space on the bottom of recipes, so you can scroll the last paragraph higher for better readability.
- This is a top priority, hopefully I'll have something (albeit crude) sorted for the weekend.
- I'm on the fence with pictures of food at the moment. I really want this focused on being a recipe manager for creators, without the clutter of being an Instagram of food. Not just another recipe "dump" to get lost in the mix. People focus on uploading filtered pics of everything, and it loses the spirit of creation. I will be adding more utilities to search for ingredients, and social aspects. But the pictures may be off in the far distance. I'll see how feedback comes in regarding it.
- Yes agreed, lots of little quality of life stuff to be done. I'm working on it :)
[1] http://imadefood.com/recipe/NkgHYiLPl [2] http://imadefood.com/recipe/NkgHYiLPl/herbs-and-gin