Ask HN: How much rent do you pay per month and where?

4 points by whitenoice ↗ HN
Would like to know how much my salary would be worth in that state. This site http://money.cnn.com/calculator/pf/cost-of-living/ gives absurd values unless its actually true.

I pay $2000 for 2bd 1.5bath apartment in Brookline, Boston MA

8 comments

[ 3.1 ms ] story [ 33.6 ms ] thread
10000/month in NYC (Manhattan) for mortgage + common charges for two bedroom + home office in full–service doorman building.
What do you do that makes $10K/month seem like a reasonable cost of living?
It's not effectively $10K/month because mortgage interest is tax deductible and the percentage of the cost used for the home office can be deducted as a business expense. Also, he's building equity in his investment which he'll get back when he sells the apartment. Once the mortgage is paid off, he owns the unit and all that's left of the monthly expense is maintenance charges (and real estate tax).

Also, Manhattan is currently a pretty healthy real estate market, so he's likely to make a profit when he sells the apartment. So it's hard to compare this number to a simple rent payment.

Mortgage interest is deductible to a point, it starts to phase out at certain income levels, and if you're in alternative-minimum-tax land it's diminished even more.

R/E tax is also deductible.

We “extracted” enough from sales of two previous apartments to give us close to 65% equity in our current apartment.

I don't think 10k a month is a reasonable cost of living. It's just what we pay.

Prior to buying a co–op we were paying $8900/month in rent for a 900 square foot two bedroom. Manhattan is certainly an expensive choice to live, but we both walk to work and have 2+ hours a day extra by avoiding commuting.

As for what I do: I solve catastrophically expensive technical problems for companies for a percentage of the savings. My partner works for a large I/T conglomerate. Between us we make enough that $120k/year in housing costs are manageable.

Some people might reasonably believe that living in Manhattan makes it reasonable due to the unique opportunities doing so provides in areas related to quality of life such as employment, culture, community, political franchise, etc.
You could set this up as an anonymous google spreadsheet for people to add their information to, like the salary one that went around recently
(comment deleted)