7 comments

[ 5.4 ms ] story [ 32.3 ms ] thread
So what if I got more social benefits before? I suppose I can deny the nomination, but how is it supposed to work in general?

If I got no social benefits before it's all golden. If I get the bare minimum anyways, yay for less bureaucracy and allowing me to take a small job without loosing money by falling out of the social benefits.

But what if I got more? There will be some good reason for me to get more, like illness or handicap, higher income before loosing a job (it's a little strange, but makes sense so people don't loose their house by failing to pay off the loan on it), children, student that needs to pay rent in the city and university etc...

If they get the same it's just a decay of the social state.

> Finland is about to launch an experiment in which a randomly selected group of 2,000–3,000 citizens already on unemployment benefits will begin to receive a monthly basic income of 560 euros (approx. $600). That basic income will replace their existing benefits. The amount is the same as the current guaranteed minimum level of Finnish social security support. The pilot study, running for two years in 2017-2018, aims to assess whether basic income can help reduce poverty, social exclusion, and bureaucracy, while increasing the employment rate.
Hmmm. Wasn't the idea that basic income would be for everyone? Not just the unemployed.
I've been reading about these kind of experiments for years now and they all do the same mistake: it's not basic income if it has a deadline.

Almost nobody will leave his job / stop looking for one / risk a complete career change if that income is not guaranteed for life.

Plus there's always the risk that the government can take your income away from you for any reason.

It's almost like taking away a child's allowance...

Will that ever be the case? You can never be sure that some sort of revolution will come in the future. Or another political party will be voted in and change the situation.
I thought many countries had already basic income for people not working? In France we have RSA what would be the difference here?