Why didn't Apple use Lightening vs. USB 3.0-C on iPhone 7?

15 points by noahmbarr ↗ HN

11 comments

[ 2.7 ms ] story [ 38.1 ms ] thread
The iPhone 7s can have it. Apple can do a massive launch, with the only difference being the charge port: now charge your MacBook and iPhone with the same charger! rapturous applause.

(I'd actually love it, I use a MacBook and a iPhone. One charger would be great).

But can they do that after pushing everyone to lightning headphones?
Probably not. Looks like will need two cables unless switch to an Android.
I use an Air and an iPhone. MagSafe on the phone would be amazing (ideally MagSafe version one though).
phones seem too light to make sense with magsafe.
I already use the same charger for my MacBook and iPhone - admittedly with two different cables (USB:USB-C, USB:Lightning; or I could use USB-C:USB-C and USB-C:Lightning if I wanted to.)
A better question is why even use lightening?

IMHO it's an anti-feature not to use USB-C on iPhone.

Given that they dropped space grey for black, one could argue that apple actually used darkening on the iPhone 7.

Thankyou thankyou.

Not saying that these are valid reasons however two that spring to mind are thickness (USB-C is fairly significantly thicker) and elegance (one could argue that Lightning is a more beautiful and slightly more pleasant to use connector).

In addition, Apple controls Lightning completely so when you buy an accessory that uses Lightning, as long as it isn't counterfeit, it has been tested by Apple and is guaranteed to work. They can't guarantee that with USB-C.

That said, it's an awkward situation. Overall I'd like USB-C on my phone however if they were going to do it, surely it would have been with the iPhone 7. It wouldn't be great if they announced it with the 7S after people had gone out and bought Lightning headphones.

Apple controls Lightning completely so when you buy an accessory that uses Lightning, as long as it isn't counterfeit, it has been tested by Apple and is guaranteed to work. They can't guarantee that with USB.
They also get royalties for every accessory sold with Lightning, I imagine.