15 comments

[ 1.8 ms ] story [ 53.0 ms ] thread
Serious question, how did he break 50 bones when he's confined to a wheelchair?
I guess he didn't break them all at once, just totalling 50 breaks over many years, maybe even the same bone many times.
That just makes me more confused

How do you have accidents that often if you're in a wheelchair? Once or twice I can see, but 50 bones is a lot

I know. The article doesn't say. Maybe it's part of his disease. Some people break bones easily.
Well, there was the car accident, and I'm guessing this accounts for much of it. Likely broken ribs with the infections - coughing can do that, especially if you can't move your body into a better position.

And then outside of this: It takes some practice to maneuver a wheelchair. You wind up hitting your foot and hands and things (or others can easily do this). I'm guessing there are times when things just go badly (wheel stuck in a rut) and he winds up on the ground, wheelchair over part of him. He probably has some bones that are more brittle than we'd expect because they don't regularly bear weight (legs).

And don't forget, this is over 34 years with what seems like high risk factors and some unfortunate accidents over the time - and sometimes multiple breakings at once due to the accidents.

Having control over our bodies prevents accidents, more than just about anything. If you fall out of a chair as an able-bodied person, you instinctively readjust your weight, catch yourself with your hands, land on your butt, and minimize injury. Fall out of a chair when you have no control over your body and you can break bones.

He's active, he gets around, he travels -- and he has literally has no ability to catch himself, readjust himself, move quickly to avoid danger, and he's doing it all on a device looks safer, but is far more precarious, in some ways, than two legs. I can hike up a dirt trail or navigate an icy sidewalk -- even step up onto a curb -- without worrying. Try being in a wheelchair under similar circumstances.

I imagine the major car accident he describes in the article contributed...
That only shattered his legs. A human has only 206 bones, some of them very unlikely to break. Breaking 50 of them at once would be a death sentence
Read the entire thing. I'm guessing the number is cumulative. Some were probably the broken ribs when he had pneumonia. Then the car accident etc.
A question about the insurance in regards to the accident he had.

He says "Bill had crappy insurance, paying out a maximum of $20,000 for the accident". He says the total bill was $130,000, so is he implying that he himself had to come up with the other $110,000? If that's the case, then why did Bill have insurance at all? I mean, if Bill's insurance would pay $20,000 then Bill himself would have to come up with the $110,000 right? I guess I'm missing something here...

> I mean, if Bill's insurance would pay $20,000 then Bill himself would have to come up with the $110,000 right?

I think the reasoning is that although he would be on the hook for the $110K, since Bill was a teenager who worked at Wendy's, he likely didn't have the $110K to pay. Sure he could rightfully sue Bill for the full amount, but he can't get what the kid doesn't have.

Bill's crappy insurance paid out a max of $20,000 - which seems to be the minimum legally required by law for some states. Bill had insurance so that he could drive to his job legally, without the risk of being arrested or losing his license due to lack of insurance.

Bill may or may not be liable to cover the rest of the bill - and even then, they might have to go through court. If bill is low income, which is likely true considering the fast food job and minimum liablity insurance - he might not have to pay it back very quickly. Even if they dock his pay at 25%, it'll take some time to recoup the money. By then, the hospital will have already put this into collections. Sometimes normal health insurance won't cover such things, but it is somewhat possible Medicaid would pay for it.

So, basically, Jon is screwed. The only real prize here is that if Jon's insurances covered any of his hospital bills, they are likely to take legal action themselves.

"Bill" is used as the pseudonym for the teenager that caused his car accident back in 2006. So, the teenager's insurance was covering medical expenses up to $20K only.