Much of this is anachronistic half-baked justification are prototypical examples of orientalism.
- Pick some modern thing you dislike, pick some ancient thing that is generally positive.
- Imply, "wink-wink", at the notion that one thing is a causal influence on the other.
- Mix up and destroy any interest in the heritage.
You see this when it comes to English writing with every freaking country in Asia. Frankly it gets really annoying. A prototypical example is by the way systems of exploitative labor exported after WWII from US/Europe/Russia to various Tiger economies suddenly become "Confucian" simply because the writer in his post-modern reverie believes she has stumbled upon gold. Calling it "feudal" would be just too boring apparently.
There is no mass understanding/respect for either Confucius or Indic religious in Asia today. Nor is there real state patronage for the growth either of these; often there is outright opposition from the state because these traditions stand in way of "modernization". In fact, it is the culture and arts of the West that hold undue influence over many nations (and K-pop reflects this very very distinctly).
Please do us all a favor and stop writing about societies you can't be bothered to understand.
> Oh god, not this again. [...] every freaking country [...] really annoying [...] societies you can't be bothered to understand.
Would you please not rant like this on HN? If you know more than others, that's great, but then please explain it in a way we can learn from. Venting spoils conversation.
So the Koreans might have to do the same things to the little girls in their pop videos, using Photoshop, as the Italians did to the little boys in their Renaissance art, using paint.
Before those underpants were painted on, the bare bums of Michaelangelo's cherubs were clearly going to cause the collapse of European civilisation. David's dick is an ongoing threat to our way of life today. All of those hints were inspired by the resurgence of the classical and Christian traditions in Europe (I'm serious about that bit).
And we wouldn't want any of that to happen to Asia, would we?
5 comments
[ 3.3 ms ] story [ 23.1 ms ] threadMuch of this is anachronistic half-baked justification are prototypical examples of orientalism.
- Pick some modern thing you dislike, pick some ancient thing that is generally positive.
- Imply, "wink-wink", at the notion that one thing is a causal influence on the other.
- Mix up and destroy any interest in the heritage.
You see this when it comes to English writing with every freaking country in Asia. Frankly it gets really annoying. A prototypical example is by the way systems of exploitative labor exported after WWII from US/Europe/Russia to various Tiger economies suddenly become "Confucian" simply because the writer in his post-modern reverie believes she has stumbled upon gold. Calling it "feudal" would be just too boring apparently.
There is no mass understanding/respect for either Confucius or Indic religious in Asia today. Nor is there real state patronage for the growth either of these; often there is outright opposition from the state because these traditions stand in way of "modernization". In fact, it is the culture and arts of the West that hold undue influence over many nations (and K-pop reflects this very very distinctly).
Please do us all a favor and stop writing about societies you can't be bothered to understand.
Would you please not rant like this on HN? If you know more than others, that's great, but then please explain it in a way we can learn from. Venting spoils conversation.
Before those underpants were painted on, the bare bums of Michaelangelo's cherubs were clearly going to cause the collapse of European civilisation. David's dick is an ongoing threat to our way of life today. All of those hints were inspired by the resurgence of the classical and Christian traditions in Europe (I'm serious about that bit).
And we wouldn't want any of that to happen to Asia, would we?