21 comments

[ 5.2 ms ] story [ 63.1 ms ] thread
Interesting idea. Wondering A) how this is done (mturk?) and B) how this will be monetized.
Yes, mturk is the backend. Amazon links can monetize it.
If mturk is the back end, you need to tell users that a human will listen to their voicemail and look at their stuff. I assumed you had voice recognition software and clever image stuff, not random humans. The privacy issues of this are horrid; at least make it obvious what will happen.
Yes, you are right. How about a strap line across the bottom:

"Powered by Mechanical Turk: humans write these answers"

I'd put it at the top:

Email an attachment to go@mail2brain.com and a human will turn it into something useful:

Frame it as a feature :)

Email an attachment to go@mail2brain.com and a real person will turn it into something useful
Very much so! It would also stop people from emailing something then assuming it's broken when they don't get a reply a few seconds later.
Better explanation would be great, still wondering what it does - What is the common use case ?
I like the visual representation of what the service does, but the images are small. The result images are essentially your product, but they're cropped too much.
Potential application: a user with a camera phone that doesn't have support for barcode reader applications (not Android, iOS, etc) but can send an email with a photo attachment could analyze a barcode with this service. But here the lack of immediacy might be an issue...
I really really like it, but I can see this getting very expensive, very fast.
Common use cases:

transcribing voicemails from emails.

finding products for shopping without having to do the search yourself.

I understand these use cases, but I'm not sure the attachments related to these things are already in my email frequently enough for this to be useful.

My voicemail is on my cellphone or in Google voice (where it already has a humorous machine translation that might be good enough.) If I want to take a picture of a product, the closest camera is in my phone and there's already an Amazon app for that.

Perhaps you could de-emphasize the "attachment" part, which makes me think of files and serious emailing, and emphasize "send a picture" which I can do quickly from my phone. I know it's the same thing, but the different wordings send my brain in different directions.

Kitchen Towels are not the most exciting of demo images :)
Are you aware that the Amazon app for Android / iPhone already does the product lookup / barcode scanning ("by humans") for you?
"How did we do" should allow for comments. I rated a response "ok" but would have preferred to be able to explain that it was good that the source of the image was identified, but bad that the associated product was not.
Now that you have made it clear that humans will see each message get ready for a torrent of penis photos. Some times I feel bad for the mechanical turkers.
(comment deleted)
Can this scale? The problem with mturk is you can't make any QoS guarantees.