Voluntary, perhaps with a kick back for testing? Then maybe. Though I myself would not sign up for such until the regulations are in place governing privacy and such; even to the point of determining who is chipped and who is not.
At this moment, I am not quite sure how I feel about living in a world where we are chipped. Maybe it is a generational thing
If this kind of thing became mandatory I think I'd legitimately consider ending it, however as an optional (so long as it stays this way) thing it's kinda cool I guess.
I did have a question about the type of chips available, but I was too late for the last post about this.
Perhaps someone with more knowledge could enlighten me?
This isn't new tech - RFID is an extremely common and well vetted implementation for physical security. This only replaces the fobs you have to carry with you (usually key fob or credit card sized fob) with a microscopic one under your skin. Every single office I've ever worked at (5) use RFID keys for facility access.
Some RFID implementations are vulnerable to cloning and other attacks (brute force, IIRC). There isn't any information about the implementation given here other than "RFID" and some implementations are much more secure than others.
There's attack demonstrations on some RFID access implementations on YouTube - some more viable than others.
A key fob (a current implementation) is a better than a ring. You probably already have to have your keys to leave the house (lock door, start car) so it's not another thing to remember. Key fobs are a single standard size and keyfobs don't get tight when you get pregnant or fat. Key fobs aren't uncomfortable, don't give you allergic retractions, and aren't a potential safety hazard like rings are for many "hands on" jobs, and also don't impact hand hygiene.
The benefits of an implant are you, can't forget your implant, you can't lose it, it can't be stolen, and you can't give it to someone else. You also (probably?) can't break an implant.
I remember back when I was a kid it was often talked about in certain circles that the mark of the beast that is discussed in the Book of Revalations of the Bible would be a microchip planted in the back of your palm.
The Book talks about how those who fail to get the mark will be outcast and unable to function in society. So it was said (in these circles) that it is likely these chips will be used as a kind of credid card, and without one you will not be able to conduct any financial transactions such as buy food etc..
Governments and societies have been trying to give their citizens identification since long before John was writing. It's been the Last Days since about AD 0096.
I remember also that Social Security cards are the start of the Mark of the Beast as well. This is why we don't have photographs on our most common form of federal identification.
It's actually illegal in several states, including Wisconsin, for employers to require employees to get microchip implants. The motivation for these laws is exactly the scenario you've described.
" He causes all, both small and great, rich and poor, free and slave, to receive a mark on their right hand or on their foreheads, and that no one may buy or sell except one who has the mark or the name of the beast, or the number of his name."
I'm surprised with the generally conservative Christian population in WI that more people aren't actively against this in their community.
The quotation "You keep using that word, I do not think it means what you think it means"?
"Conservative" in the political spectrum doesn't mean conservative in all areas, like eating habits or personal finance. It just means they prefer government to maintain the traditions, values, and customs that were in place before. My turn for a quote:
"When I use a word ... it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.
When discussing politics or law, you have to be aware of the context of words. They don't always abide by their definition in the vernacular.
I don't think the vast majority Christians even worry about microchips anymore. It was a silly fear from the beginning that only caught on because of how novel and marvelous computers in general were and now that transistors have become more mundane, so have the old notions that piggybacked primarily on such novelties.
Hmm. I wouldn't be too quick to dismiss people's concerns about being microchipped--Christians or otherwise. We may hear more rumblings if this is implemented at scale.
So when you switch jobs you have to get surgery to get the device removed? I guess people will have to never switch jobs then. Sounds like a way to keep people from quitting a bad employer.
Switching jobs would incur a slight penalty of 1) removing chip, b) re-programming chip, c) leaving chip. I think this is something a lot of people would like to avoid.
My guess is that there would be no need to remove or reprogram. I assume the chip simply presents a unique identifier and nothing more. The old company could just remove access based on the identifier and in a similar way, the new company could grant access using the existing chip.
It's a couple minute procedure likened to removing a splinter. Also, you don't really have to get it removed if you don't want to, it can be inactivated without your involvement.
Yeah, I think these would be useful, but not as a single chip in your finger. You'd want a more distributed solution; a memory chip holding your key somewhere like your shoulder, a crypto chip to generate the nonce in a knee, some nodes to emit EMI along the transdermal conduits to prevent eavesdropping and to act as decoys, that sort of thing.
That way, the transmitter could be in your finger, but it would be useless on its own. They would need to dismember you to get at the full solution, which would also be fragile to keep intact if anyone tried to remove while maintaining its functionality. Individual parts could also have failsafes to fry the whole system if exposed to atmosphere.
And at that point, unlike chopping off a hand, it'd be so much easier for a criminal to pull a gun on their mark and walk them to an ATM.
Come to think of it, a bodywide transdermal net would be pretty cool, if you included junctions for adding arbitrary modules to a common pin footprint. It would probably be difficult to install, but I dunno... people have put some crazy things in their skin, like a phone-sized single-board computer.
I have to admit I find it pretty amusing this is news. About a dozen friends and I have had these for 4+ years, voluntarily.
I no longer carry any traditional metal keys and have modified my front door, vehicles, etc to open via my implants. Friends even upgraded 2 vending machines at our hackerspace to work with them.
In addition to access, I use one to store master encrypted backups of files I might need access to in a pinch and the other I tell everyone contains a vcard with my contact info, but really it just auto-launches rickroll on their phone when they tap it. The tags are all r/w and I can update them as I like from my smartphone.
In a couple weeks I am getting a temperature sensor installed under my arm designed for animals. While temperature is not a super exciting sensor, it paves the way for more complicated ones in the future and I can see how it holds up over time.
My next after that is an HID ATA5577 tag that I can use to clone the HID door cards of most offices.
Once beta units begin to be produced I plan on getting a Vivokey installed which covers the typical use cases of a Yubikey and will allow me to do 2FA, ssh, password management, and cryptocurrency transactions from my body as well.
FSF better get on this sooner rather than later. I don't know how many of us would really have so much to complain about if these chips were truly, 100% under our own control.
39 comments
[ 3.1 ms ] story [ 115 ms ] threadThe most active discussion is from this post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14836390
At this moment, I am not quite sure how I feel about living in a world where we are chipped. Maybe it is a generational thing
I did have a question about the type of chips available, but I was too late for the last post about this.
Perhaps someone with more knowledge could enlighten me?
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14842144
I had an RFID credit card years ago, but that turned out to be really insecure[1], and the issuer discontinued the program.
The contact-based chips in modern cards are not the same. At all.
I wonder what would happen if some miscreant super-glued a few dozen RFID chips to the reader, or to a location close to the reader?
[1] http://hackaday.com/2013/11/03/rfid-reader-snoops-cards-from...
I sort of default to expecting implementation flaws and eventual cloning.
Some RFID implementations are vulnerable to cloning and other attacks (brute force, IIRC). There isn't any information about the implementation given here other than "RFID" and some implementations are much more secure than others.
There's attack demonstrations on some RFID access implementations on YouTube - some more viable than others.
The benefits of an implant are you, can't forget your implant, you can't lose it, it can't be stolen, and you can't give it to someone else. You also (probably?) can't break an implant.
The Book talks about how those who fail to get the mark will be outcast and unable to function in society. So it was said (in these circles) that it is likely these chips will be used as a kind of credid card, and without one you will not be able to conduct any financial transactions such as buy food etc..
It is the start of the end times!
I remember also that Social Security cards are the start of the Mark of the Beast as well. This is why we don't have photographs on our most common form of federal identification.
I'm surprised with the generally conservative Christian population in WI that more people aren't actively against this in their community.
Fat people with lots of credit card debt are not conservative. If they claim to be, there's a Princess Bride quotation that should be recited to them.
I have lived in MN/WI and continue to spend time in both so I know of which I speak.
"Conservative" in the political spectrum doesn't mean conservative in all areas, like eating habits or personal finance. It just means they prefer government to maintain the traditions, values, and customs that were in place before. My turn for a quote:
"When I use a word ... it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.
When discussing politics or law, you have to be aware of the context of words. They don't always abide by their definition in the vernacular.
> Like everything in life, it could happen.
> But, says Mr Danna, at least it is all in one place, making it easier to cancel all those cards.
Are they implying you might get your hand chopped off but at least it's easy to cancel your credit card?
That way, the transmitter could be in your finger, but it would be useless on its own. They would need to dismember you to get at the full solution, which would also be fragile to keep intact if anyone tried to remove while maintaining its functionality. Individual parts could also have failsafes to fry the whole system if exposed to atmosphere.
And at that point, unlike chopping off a hand, it'd be so much easier for a criminal to pull a gun on their mark and walk them to an ATM.
Come to think of it, a bodywide transdermal net would be pretty cool, if you included junctions for adding arbitrary modules to a common pin footprint. It would probably be difficult to install, but I dunno... people have put some crazy things in their skin, like a phone-sized single-board computer.
Great, so thieves that are already amoral enough to chop off your hand will have to kill you instead! Progress!
It will be literally like "we own you now!".
The chip may get fried, but that's not my main concern. Does it attempt to move through your body? Will it succeed at doing that?
I no longer carry any traditional metal keys and have modified my front door, vehicles, etc to open via my implants. Friends even upgraded 2 vending machines at our hackerspace to work with them.
In addition to access, I use one to store master encrypted backups of files I might need access to in a pinch and the other I tell everyone contains a vcard with my contact info, but really it just auto-launches rickroll on their phone when they tap it. The tags are all r/w and I can update them as I like from my smartphone.
In a couple weeks I am getting a temperature sensor installed under my arm designed for animals. While temperature is not a super exciting sensor, it paves the way for more complicated ones in the future and I can see how it holds up over time.
My next after that is an HID ATA5577 tag that I can use to clone the HID door cards of most offices.
Once beta units begin to be produced I plan on getting a Vivokey installed which covers the typical use cases of a Yubikey and will allow me to do 2FA, ssh, password management, and cryptocurrency transactions from my body as well.
An integrated temperature sensor sounds awesome, especially for a hypochondriac like me.