Like Reddit, anyone can create forums, post links, text, photos, comment and vote.
Difference is that there are only forum-level profile pages. No /u/username. Only /forum1/u/username, or /forum2/u/username, etc. This design is to prevent others from easily spying you by watching what forums you have joined and what posts you have made on other forums.
Like HN, Forum menu is made of "hot","new","comments","ask".
There seem to be a common problem in many Reddit forums: Photo/video submissions are more likely to be upvoted and as a result the "hot" pages were filled with media posts. Many valuable discussions are hard to see. Thanks to HN I found a solution to solve this problem. It is to simply add a "Ask" tab on the top menu to show all discussion posts. All posts start with "Ask:" go to that tab. We didn't use "discussion" tab because we think the line between a media post and an "ask" is more clear than a "discussion".
Like Twitter, post listing is in News Feed style, showing more details when we browsing. We want to allow low-effort content, means you can post status, memes, etc, as long as they are on-topic in the forums.
Geeki is now launching beta. Any advice and suggestions will be greatly appreciated!
Ok, it may seem a good idea to mix everything and create a new product. Maybe it is. The problem is the network effect, how to overcome it? How to get people into a site without any people? Very hard.
I was never too much into Reddit. But I liked Geeki. I'd prefer to fine-tune categories and I can imagine way more programming and IT pro categories myself.
3 comments
[ 1.4 ms ] story [ 9.7 ms ] threadLike HN, Forum menu is made of "hot","new","comments","ask". There seem to be a common problem in many Reddit forums: Photo/video submissions are more likely to be upvoted and as a result the "hot" pages were filled with media posts. Many valuable discussions are hard to see. Thanks to HN I found a solution to solve this problem. It is to simply add a "Ask" tab on the top menu to show all discussion posts. All posts start with "Ask:" go to that tab. We didn't use "discussion" tab because we think the line between a media post and an "ask" is more clear than a "discussion".
Like Twitter, post listing is in News Feed style, showing more details when we browsing. We want to allow low-effort content, means you can post status, memes, etc, as long as they are on-topic in the forums.
Geeki is now launching beta. Any advice and suggestions will be greatly appreciated!
I don't like the idea, however.