Ask HN: Is it 'normal' to struggle so hard with work?
Basically, since as long as I can remember, I've had issues motivating myself to work and focusing on a single task.
I've used everything from rewards ("If I work for X hours, I'll play a video game") and punishment ("If I don't work for X hours, I'm a complete failure") to get myself to work.
I have to come up with elaborate new schemes to get myself to focus. I've tried awarding myself "points" for doing a task, turning my work into a virtual RPG. I've tried keeping elaborate spreadsheets of my work habits. I've tried the Seinfeld method of mapping out my "win" and "fail" days.
Essentially, I come up with a new tactic to motivate myself every couple of months. If I don't do so, I find myself struggling to meet my goals and distracted.
Part of the reason for this is perhaps the nature of my work. I'm a freelancer and have been one since I graduated from college. I make a decent enough earning because I've acquired a niche set of in-demand skills. But I struggle to meet deadlines and never have enough dedication to meet any of my long-term tasks (such as building an app or starting a business).
For years, I thought this was "normal". But I'm now starting to think that maybe I just don't have a regular case of procrastination.
Does anyone else feel this way? Is work such a complicated endeavor for you as well? Am I suffering from some form of undiagnosed ADHD?
381 comments
[ 5.0 ms ] story [ 323 ms ] threadSome people can sometimes find types of work that they love so much that this doesn't happen. I have often managed to.
I think this calls for a self-diagnostic. I would definitely see a therapist and maybe a doctor to make sure there aren't any subtle undiagnosed issues holding you back. This could be mild depression, ADHD, or heck sleep apnea. Or maybe you're completely in the wrong field for yourself and a counselor could help to quickly suss that out. Or maybe you're a wild perfectionist and don't even know it. There's a million possible explanations that could be completely invisible to you but accessible to a trained 3rd party.
If you were in your early 20s I'd say... muddle through, no one starts off awesome. But by your 30s I think it's reasonable to expect more and appropriate to get proactive about getting to the bottom of this.
Do you have any tips on getting started? A blog/website, what to look for?
https://www.amazon.com/Cognitive-Behavioural-Therapy-Dummies...
Ignore the stupid series title, it's a great book.
Learned helplessness is believed to be a major driver in depression and obviously is a source of issues with motivation. It's a really interesting and treatable condition. If anyone reading this believes this may be an issue for you, you should look into a therapist that is experienced with CBT, as this can be an effective treatment for learned helplessness.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Learned_helplessness
It's worth looking into this. I know people who found a diagnosis extremely helpful - even those who chose not to avail themselves of the medications available. There's several online questionnaires that would give you an idea of the kind of questions you'd be asked if you went for a consultation. Some of the traits are quiet distinct and you'll have an immediate sense of familiarity. If you find yourself saying "Gosh, I thought that was just me" then it's probably a sign. :).
Feel free to msg me and I can pass on a bit more info.
Thanks a lot. You may have changed my life
Checking out the r/adhd subreddit was like staring into a mirror
I realised a while ago that my main issue was with nebulous tasks -- that is, the more concrete, defined, and _meetable_ a task was, the less trouble I had with it. So I started to break down large tasks, which never got started much less finished, into smaller ones, in the same way you might break a scrum-poker 20-pointer into a bunch of 3s.
You want to go from this:
- I should really write [some great app idea]
To this:
- I'll make a list of technologies that I want to use
- I'll read the docs, like a book, for the ones that are new
- I'll write a single api endpoint
- I'll flesh out the api for the rest of a feature
- I'll MVP a UI for that one feature, without any concern for design
- etc.
In my case, a combination of the size of and amount of ambiguity in a task is inversely proportional to the ability I have to both get it underway and get it finished.
You can't start the task "start a business", but you can start the task "determine the market size for x".
It's awesome to structure tasks into more and more subtasks.
[1] https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.dmfs.tasks...
Our senses of touch, smell and sound are important and inspiring.
Another aspect that is also useful has been my experience of Pomodoro technique. At a job where we were practicing Pomodoro technique, I realized I don’t struggle with concentration anymore. The minimalistic explanation of the technique is to work on a task inside 45 minute intervals; then walk away from the computer for several minutes.
I find one of the additional benefits it has is that it gives you a means of quantifying your day. Often I can't remember exactly what I've been working on but knowing that I've completed x amounts of intervals leaves me way more satisfied at the end of the day and makes me feel much more confident that I've been productive.
I find it can also reveal how long some things take to complete. Rather than thinking 'uhh I couldn't even complete that task today' it can often lead to 'wow, I worked on that task for x intervals and it still wasn't complete - I definitely underestimated that one!'
Currently my tasks are spread across emails and email drafts, Github issues, iOS reminders, Slack, my head, etc. It's a lot of work to keep track of them all.
Maybe I should just carry around a paper notebook and make that the authoritative source of tasks.
Note apps, task apps, etc. all can not handle to that considering the brain simply considers things with haptic feedback more memorable and actionable.
I also find myself reviewing my Chrome history sometimes if I have no idea all the things I had been working on all day.
I read about Getting Things Done, and I worked to track everything in one place, but I find that task tracking in two places work best for me:
1. Something like Evernote or Simplenote, for capturing notes on any device that's handy: phone, tablet, computer, etc. Being able to search really easily is crucial, to avoid duplicate topics.
2. Something like Trello for easier prioritizing and categorization. Moving around the index card analogies is much easier than moving text.
Using email as an issue tracker is an anti-pattern. It means your work to prioritize can get casually jumbled, and for me, that flow can get interrupted more easily. Ditto for Slack.
I like paper notebooks - I used one at work so I wouldn't drop any of the tasks I was juggling - but they're less portable than my phone. Before that, I had a Hipster PDA (index cards and a paper clip - http://www.43folders.com/2004/09/03/introducing-the-hipster-... ) but I had lots of notes, and searching was awkward, meaning "just write it (again) before I forget it, sort it out later," meant there was curation involved, and that using 1. above was lower-friction and just overall better.
https://tiddlywiki.com/
Use it well and it'll serve as both a todo list and your own personal instantly searchable, super fast knowledge base.
> Slicing. Take a big project, cut it into thin slices, and rearrange the slices to suit your context. I can always slice projects finer and I can always find new permutations of the slices that meet different needs.
[1] — https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/387190.Test_Driven_Devel...
https://youtu.be/jmcSzzN1gkc
At one point around 20 or 30 minutes in, he says something like, “We’re going to start easy and slow and then work harder later on.” He exhaustively writes out a large number of different combinations of possible runtimes of an algorithm. It seems quite tedious, but eventually some cool results emerge related to Sterling Numbers :)
At first, I thought it was somewhat annoying that the lecture was methodically going through so many examples. Since then, I’ve realized that methodically going through small sub-problems patiently is often the way you eventually get to a giant leap.
In cases where it is medically necessary, there is: Adderall.
http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/12/28/adderall-risks-much-mor...
Lots of tools are great for this too, I've used Tomboy, OneNote and org-mode, all of which do this very well.
Building an app or starting your own business sound like typical HN crowd goals, but do they actually apply to you?
It seems to me that you right now struggle with seeing the effects of your work, and how they relate to whatever long-term goal you may have. Because there seems to be a disconnect there, you do not feel motivated. But this will not change until you: (a) have a clear long-term goal that you actually care about, and (b) figure out how to work on tasks that help achieve the goal.
Why are you doing whatever it is you are doing?
When you find the right thing you'll know. I would do what I do now for free or if I was worth 100 Million because I love the game.
I think the truth is that I was heavily influenced by e.g. sites like HN, where it's always touted as the ultimate virtues to have these side-gigs and basically be working all the time. When I looked around though I realized that this is just not the reality for the overwhelming majority of people. Most people are happy just working their 8 hours and then _do something else_
So, my advice would be to 'stop trying so hard'
Only first had to wear them from a few years ago so the prescription isn't strong.
But yeah, do tend to flit between tasks a bit.
Read up on ADHD, and learn good "tactics" to cope with work, such as regular workouts (increases dopamine and makes you able to focus for longer periods), short term goals (just 2 hours into the future perhaps), varying your tasks and work setting often, etc. Something I have found very helpful is the Pomodoro technique.
I would encourage reading about potential afflictions but I would strongly suggest getting a second (beyond your own) opinion from a medical professional.
- get more sleep
- time off to recharge / re-motivate
- meditation / yoga / exercise
- try to stop using stimulants (includes caffeine/nicotine/sugar) or try using different stimulants (eg. arecoline)
- absolutely do not smoke marijuana, it is known to make many people lazy and demotivated
- control your environment (quiet, no phone, phone off, offline)
- clean your environment (zero clutter)
- change your environment (fresh space)
- remove all distractions (visual, audio, etc.)
- try different times of day (eg. sleep early, wake then work early AM before sunrise)
> - absolutely do not smoke marijuana, it is known to make many people lazy and demotivated
This is largely a myth whereas I can easily find citations and scientific research to back every other advice. Smoking a lot of marijuana is bad because it messes with your pleasure cycle but overall motivation is hardly effected (citations provided upon request - please do ask or look at pubmed yourself).
Also:
> - try different times of day (eg. sleep early, wake then work early AM before sunrise)
Messing with your circadian clock is dangerous (as in cardiovascular desease dangerous) and I would not recommend anyone to do this. The other advice (like sleep more) is important.
> - meditation / yoga / exercise
This a million times, meditation and exercise are great at motivating you.
This irked me too. I think it's because it's basically medical advise.
I don't want to tell people that they can't comment on the use of chemicals etc but the way they effect people varies considerably and unless you're a doctor with experience in prescribing marajuana then your advise is... hard to trust I guess.
This is regardless of popular opinion. Lots of people can be wrong at the same time.
Stick to personal anecdotes? E.g. I used to take marajuana and I found that it blurred my thoughts and made it hard for me to be motivated so to for me, stopping taking marajuana allowed me to focus a lot more.
This is the stereotype. Sure, some folks get lazy, but same for lots of drugs, including alcohol. How many potheads have you known? I've been one at different times, probably qualify, and would rather work with a pothead who is stoned all the time than a drunk. Lazy isn't due to marijuana, but rather the person smoking and to an extent, their reaction and tolerance level.
With me is the opposite. I don't clean house more or lesse, for instance, when I'm stoned constantly, but I don't mind doing it as much. I eat less. I enjoy my work more. I start enjoying going for actual walks. Now, if you are getting so stoned that you can't walk, that's gonna be an issue. But for me, at least, it isn't what you say. It might be worth trying occasionally. It might be worth cutting down. And if you just do it on weekends occasionally or smoking in the evenings after things are done, it probably isn't going to make little difference.
I am slightly more forgetful. But only slightly. I've sat here and learned stuff, like a langauge (not fluent, but can do simple jobs and speak lightly about politics with it). Not that big of a deal.
As far as the OP goes, the only thing I can suggest is quit the video games--that's an addiction the same as anything else. My programming career took off when I quit playing games and started being a man. It's like all the advice from previous generations actually works or something, weird huh? It doesn't help that everything marketed to us is one way or another designed to infantilize and distract, but you can rise above it.
Marty Lobdell - Study Less Study Smart ~60 min. Study environment commentary from 10:15 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IlU-zDU6aQ0
The "I'm a complete failure"-part resonates with me, and perhaps, it could be something as simple as being so afraid of failing, that you never even try.
I don't know if this is helpful advice at all, but it might give you an idea of what you can do to help yourself (CBT for instance).
1. Do the “Productivity” sessions in the Headspace app. I was really skeptical about guided meditation, but have found them very useful in maintaining focus. It teaches you to be aware when your mind wanders and helps you bring focus back to the task at hand. https://www.headspace.com/
2. Force yourself to break big tasks down into tiny chunks. When things seem overwhelming, it's easy to put them off.
3. Consider using an app that divides your working day into chunks that you can work on in 30-minute intervals. I use http://focuslist.co/ to set my agenda for the day early on, then work through the list.
4. Read “Deep Work” and “So Good They Can't Ignore You” by Cal Newport.
5. Reduce social media. I dropped Facebook and removed all twitter apps from my phone. This is a good guide: http://humanetech.com/take-control/
6. Exercise for 20 minutes every morning. I bought a speed rope from http://rpmtraining.com/ and now skip every morning while listening to podcasts / audiobooks.
7. Consider getting a full-time job, or a contract with one company for 20-30 hours a week. Having co-workers to compare yourself with and managers to be answerable to is a natural motivator.
If you haven't done so already - do the "Motivation" pack too - it literally teaches you how to summon motivation which is phenomenal.
I am hyperproductive when I work in a team because I want to show people who stuff is done within deadline with minimum efforts.
But when I work alone, I lose all motivation. I achieve much less. Even after starting 5 companies.
I was working (and struggling, hard, in the way you describe) on a project I was telling myself would become a startup, and even though I felt I was being realistic about the limitations, in retrospect even that was insanely optimistic. I was burning myself out.
Once I had this epiphany - triggered by going to Startup Weekend and having a ton of fun (and no motivational problems!) working on a project, I pulled the plug and eventually got a fairly regular job in a fairly normal company (in an excellent team, though).
The epiphany and pulling the plug had a huge effect. It didn't fix everything overnight, but I did get into a habit of introspection, especially when I'm facing tasks that I struggle to get motivated for. They're still hard, but I am generally able to organise things around them in such a way that they don't get me down.
Try the free course "Learning How To Learn" by Barbara Oakley on Coursera.
It teaches you how to deal with this in the procrastination section. Roughly speaking, it teaches you how to recognize and effectively counter bad habit as well as change your mind set to focus on the process, not the product. For me the process/product bit was the big revelation.
Also, it sort of teaches you that your zombie mode can be used for good, I realized that by trying to have an incredibly flexible life and not have a set routine, I was actually working against one of my best "allies", habits for simple stuff are good, the mind likes routines as it can switch off. Use it to your advantage.
It's not a magic bullet, some days still go wrong, yesterday for example I played a game all day. But the odd thing is, techniques like the podomoro technique have now started working for me with this change in mindset.
I would go through the whole course start to end, it's short and really good. I've picked up several other new ideas and habits from it that are really working for me.
EDIT: Also, I second the therapy too, that's also helped.
If you actually very busy person with limited time another good option is to pick some audio book or podcast that you can listen in between your usual routine. Once you start listening something daily it's will become easier for you to switch your brain between different activities more easily. It's could be anything from fiction to language course and some of it could even be useful for your career in case you need justification for yourself.
I have the same issues, and I think you speak out for lots of people, motivation is a very limited resource and when it's not used properly, you end up in this state.
What worked for me best is to tackle your tasks with the notion that you have limited resources in mind and that you're just human.
Some tips that you might find useful, that certainly work very well for me:
1- Declutter your workspace, clean your whole house, having small things here and there lying around affects my thought process.
2- Declutter your brain, Throw away ideas that might be nice, but are not possible to work on right now cause they'll take tons of time and money, write those ideas down somewhere for later use, if ever.
3- Declutter your life, make sure you don't have lingering problems that can be fixed now, your brain will fatigue out when you have a lot in your stack, fix that leaking toilet, talk to your spouse about the issue you've been always having with them, tell your friend you can't help them with that thing they needed, empty out as much as you can, and work on the low hanging fruits first.
4- When it comes to tasks, spend as much time as you can afford planning it ahead first, break things down into small actionable tasks that will take a few minutes or hours to resolve, avoid homogeneous tasks like "Implement backend", "Fix the known bugs", "Release next version", etc... instead, have very concrete minimal tasks like "Fix bug #21", "Create Users profile database schema", "Convert header image to SVG", etc...
5- Timebox things when planning, say you'll spend only 1 hour today working on this issue, if you can't, then take it again in the next planning and break it down further and give it an appropriate time slot
6- Getting great ideas while working is almost like thought cancer, don't start on them, write them down and continue to do what you are doing
7- Don't start new tasks before the assigned ones are actually done
8- Don't reward or punish yourself, rewards tend to make me very narrow minded, and punishment takes the fun out of things, ask yourself why you are doing what you're doing and why you have to do it, write that down and keep it as a reminder in your workspace.
9- Talk to others, let people know what you're doing, and when it's expected to be done, this keeps me at least from getting lazy as there's expectations form others to see what i've done
10- Listen to different music, I noticed that once I changed my playlist that was on repeat, I was a completely new person, play a podcast instead, or listen to radio or channels that you have no control over.
11- Kill the projects that are taking too long and deep inside you you know that you'll never manage to finish, find smaller ones that are realistic.
12- Always remember that nothing has to be perfect, it's better to have something out there, most of the time no one even notices what you think is a crisis.
13- Ask yourself everyday, is this what I want to be doing?, am I happy?, should I continue? if the answer is truly a big yes from your heart, then go on, if not, try to find other things that might be more fun for you.
Tis is what works for me, your results may vary, but what matters is that you have to be relatively happy doing what you do!, if you think you're suffering from ADHD, I would say it's best to visit a therapist, it'll clear out lots of things, don't feel bad spending money on yourself a bit, it's worth it. also if it's your kind of thing, find a mentor :) keep up the good work and never give up!
This allows you to work a certain number of rounds a day(instead of nebulous amount of productive time) and clarifies what is exactly happening instead on relying on internal psychological indicators of having done something or not.
Also, specifically for the ADHD part, the problem with wavering attention is that when one comes back, 'loading' the context again takes a lot of work. So write a note at the end of each session on what's done or maintain a simple task text file(again, it is easy to over organize here, so keep things as simple as possible).