So rather than solving the problem (Millions without access to appropriate schooling) we cover it up.
Let alone what they need is NOT computers, it's phones (And more importantly TV and Radio access)
I know a lot of these places can't afford the electricity to run the machines, was this sorted? (And if it has solar, generator or intermittent, then low wattage devices with UPS are needed)
Everyone keeps pointing out electricity but first off, not all of Ghana is suffering from a power shortage. Secondly, even if they can have it on one hour a day it's better than what came before.
>Secondly, even if they can have it on one hour a day it's better than what came before.
Not it's not. I've seem this mentality and it's very destructive.
Things need too be done properly else they make things worse.
Computers cost a lot to run, electricity costs, they need people who know the pedagogy, they need people to repair them after a teacher puts in a lot of work getting lessons plans ready.
Life isn't a movie. They won't have amazing teachers and amazing students who band together to just get stuff working.
Even with this amazing teacher, will the admin allow him to teacher computers all day to all the other classes? Probably not. This is not how schools are structured. He'll have other responsibilities. And possibly more important ones at that.
The ""Hole in the Wall Computer" was a failure. We need to learn from these mistakes and move forward. (It's a clicked 50 year old mistake so I'm not sure how though)
[Edit] And if they do have electricity like you say then why - "He does have a computer at home, "but the battery is too weak to send it to school," he says."
It is a nice story but perhaps overstating the problem a little: "Showing his class how to use a PC posed a fundamental problem as the school’s only computer and his own personal laptop were both broken." https://news.microsoft.com/apac/2018/03/15/teacher-who-used-...
Stories like this totally make sense to me. Dreams are the most fearful force in our lives. A teacher needs to transfer inspirations to their students just as much as knowledge and experience. Experience can be gained by exposure, but inspirations can totally exist without much exposure. As a student, when you don't have inspirations then the lack of (or the existence thereof) practical exposure sucks, but many things were dreamed about for a long time before becoming a reality.
I didn't know what an actual computer was until I was 11. I am a millennial, only 30 now, but I was one of those people who only knew about the magical computers through my dad's stories and books. In the first 10 years of my life, I grew up poor as a church mouse in a rural area in Vietnam. To tell you how bad it was, I'm a male and only barely over 5ft and 100lbs now. My dad, who was a college lecturer, told us about him learning English and how to use MS-DOS on his 1.2MB floppy disk in the early 1990s -- it was mind-blowing to my 6-year-old brain. Everything you need is in this small package. If you want to delete something, just press a key instead of scratching it! If you want to issue any command, give it all it wants to know and press Enter!
I just had the first blip of making an impact by shipping a free software product that many people find useful which I first shared here. I am quite convinced that people don't just use that software because it is useful and functional to them. Compared to a $300 commercial product that has everything working correctly my free software project that uses $100 worth of hardware is a piece of buggy brahmin shit. People tried it because it gets them inspired. Shortly after I announced, it set up pictures of people trying and making awesome setups on the homepage. I also made a subreddit to share stories and ask questions, and a personal blog telling why and how I'm making progress and what I was really thinking when I made those decisions. I am still very much a real person that has opinions, dreams, and ideals. I haven't turned into an intelligent PR speech machine that says the empty words. That is something a company that sells those products can't deliver compared to a hipster dude living in a hole like me can. I am living in a dream as much as the adopters of my software.
I used to see a quote on a professor's office door when I was an undergrad that said: "People may not remember exactly what you did, or what you said, but they will always remember how you made them feel." I tried to keep that quote in mind whenever I have the opportunity to teach or bring something to someone.
Funny because the blackboard doesn't mention MS Word anywhere as far as I can tell, it mentions "Features of a word processing window" and it doesn't specifically look like MS Word either. This also makes me wonder what happened to the one Laptop per Child project [0], their G+ site was not posted on since November 2016. Is it really Microsoft Word that is going to be used by these students? Or will it be LibreOffice or Google Docs?
16 comments
[ 3.0 ms ] story [ 46.2 ms ] threadLet alone what they need is NOT computers, it's phones (And more importantly TV and Radio access)
I know a lot of these places can't afford the electricity to run the machines, was this sorted? (And if it has solar, generator or intermittent, then low wattage devices with UPS are needed)
Not it's not. I've seem this mentality and it's very destructive.
Things need too be done properly else they make things worse.
Computers cost a lot to run, electricity costs, they need people who know the pedagogy, they need people to repair them after a teacher puts in a lot of work getting lessons plans ready.
Life isn't a movie. They won't have amazing teachers and amazing students who band together to just get stuff working.
Even with this amazing teacher, will the admin allow him to teacher computers all day to all the other classes? Probably not. This is not how schools are structured. He'll have other responsibilities. And possibly more important ones at that.
The ""Hole in the Wall Computer" was a failure. We need to learn from these mistakes and move forward. (It's a clicked 50 year old mistake so I'm not sure how though)
[Edit] And if they do have electricity like you say then why - "He does have a computer at home, "but the battery is too weak to send it to school," he says."
My friends who live in Ghana go days without being able to access the Internet. It's actually a big problem.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16610469
This is a nice story, but doesn't having a computer teachers in communities that can't afford computers seem like a waste of resources?
I didn't know what an actual computer was until I was 11. I am a millennial, only 30 now, but I was one of those people who only knew about the magical computers through my dad's stories and books. In the first 10 years of my life, I grew up poor as a church mouse in a rural area in Vietnam. To tell you how bad it was, I'm a male and only barely over 5ft and 100lbs now. My dad, who was a college lecturer, told us about him learning English and how to use MS-DOS on his 1.2MB floppy disk in the early 1990s -- it was mind-blowing to my 6-year-old brain. Everything you need is in this small package. If you want to delete something, just press a key instead of scratching it! If you want to issue any command, give it all it wants to know and press Enter!
I just had the first blip of making an impact by shipping a free software product that many people find useful which I first shared here. I am quite convinced that people don't just use that software because it is useful and functional to them. Compared to a $300 commercial product that has everything working correctly my free software project that uses $100 worth of hardware is a piece of buggy brahmin shit. People tried it because it gets them inspired. Shortly after I announced, it set up pictures of people trying and making awesome setups on the homepage. I also made a subreddit to share stories and ask questions, and a personal blog telling why and how I'm making progress and what I was really thinking when I made those decisions. I am still very much a real person that has opinions, dreams, and ideals. I haven't turned into an intelligent PR speech machine that says the empty words. That is something a company that sells those products can't deliver compared to a hipster dude living in a hole like me can. I am living in a dream as much as the adopters of my software.
I used to see a quote on a professor's office door when I was an undergrad that said: "People may not remember exactly what you did, or what you said, but they will always remember how you made them feel." I tried to keep that quote in mind whenever I have the opportunity to teach or bring something to someone.
[0] http://one.laptop.org/