HN Explorer

12 comments

[ 2.3 ms ] story [ 42.9 ms ] thread
a_r_8
This is from 2016. Interesting that the authors most recent post is a tool for finding when your projects are being mentioned on HN or Reddit :)
WoodenChair
This looks like a clearly written, compact, and easy-to-use neural network library. It could be useful for pedagogy, but the README should also mention (unless I missed it) for naive readers that it is pretty much completely inappropriate for production since it uses no vector instructions nor GPU computation. It will be slow compared to any more sophisticated neural network library for anything but the most trivial applications.

For a similar equivalent in Swift see my project: https://github.com/davecom/SwiftSimpleNeuralNetwork

conceptoriented
> it is pretty much completely inappropriate for production since it uses no vector instructions nor GPU computation

Many platforms do not have GPUs or special instructions, for example, at the edge.

WoodenChair
Sure, but we don't typically do sophisticated machine learning on them. The vast majority of modern CPUs have vector instructions. Even a Raspberry Pi's ARM has NEON.
fla
Not necessarily true. You might want to run ANNs on micro-controllers at the edge for many different reasons.
Qu3tzal
Excuse me if this sounds stupid but, vector instructions are assembly. I know we can use inline assembly or compile and link assembly alongside C but isn't it the compiler that is in charge of using vector instructions ?

IIRC GCC has -mmx, -sse(2|3|4) options to enable this kind of instructions.

WoodenChair
Sure, if the compiler can find optimizations by inserting vector instructions, it will. But, typically you'll want to specifically format your code using matrices/a library like BLAS to maximize performance and use as many vector instructions as possible.
plainOldText
Beautiful, properly documented code.
irundebian
With some assertions missing to assure there are no actions upon null pointers (e. g. return by failed init functions).
pixelHD
Wow! I had to implement a small 3 layer network in C for a class, and it was interesting. It was a ton of work though, but I learnt a lot.

Will go through the source code for the kicks. Thanks!

gok
If the most interesting thing you can say about your project is which language you used, you might not have aimed high enough.