Ask HN: Review this "single input login" implementation

1 points by Breefield ↗ HN
Here's how I saw it: http://recurseapp.com/single-login Based off: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1824878

After implementing it, I have to say – the thing has a lot of holes, it doesn't work quite as well as I'd like, and most of all, it's incredibly unintuitive.

I didn't fancy up there error state at all because I don't tell my users if it was their email or password which was wrong, simply that the combination was incorrect.

It might work in the header of a website if you don't want to direct your users away from the current page and you don't have the vertical space to show a stacked login form. But I'm going to keep sending my users to http://recurseapp.com/login

2 comments

[ 4.4 ms ] story [ 13.5 ms ] thread