Ask HN: Why all major news sites set so many cookies?

12 points by croh ↗ HN

10 comments

[ 2.4 ms ] story [ 34.0 ms ] thread
There's no profit in news; there's profit in selling information of users. More cookies equals more tracking which gathers more info to sell.
If you see cookie count, it is horrible. Don't know how much information is being collected by them. And nobody bothers to talk about them.
> There's no profit in news

Subscriptions and ad space bring the money.

> there's profit in selling information of users.

Where did you read this? What news organizations are actively selling user information?

If you are serving targeted ads, you are selling user information.

Full stop.

Ads. It's hard to make money in online news, so lots of sites feel the need to plaster ads all over the page. Every ad is going to bring along its own trackers to gather information on users but also to make sure the site is meeting guaranteed minimums for viewability.

Analytics. At a minimum, there's going to be Google Analytics but there might be some in-house tracking tool or some kind of audience statistics package too.

Paywalls need to make sure you haven't met the limit.

A/B tests on headlines, content, and even styling mean remembering which test group you fall into.

Exactly this. I work for one such large multinational news corporation, and its all about ads and analytics.

On the analytics front, we are measuring and reporting on pages and articles at a number of levels, from audience metrics around demographics, device type, time-of-day, time-on-page, scrolling behaviour, etc to the actual articles themselves, the section/category, even the individual journalist. We have real-time reporting and statistics on the 'performance' of any article, journalist, section, etc.

Tracking and measuring user behaviour is largely performed using a number of cookies.

Instead of all these cookies, tracking, etc, have they considered forming some kind of "Netflix for text"? I don't want to pay for a subscription for several different content producers where I only want some of the content from each, but I'd be willing to pay some flat amount or even variable amount where content producers get paid based on popularity of content, and the platform can enforce accuracy of the content.
1) Block 3rd Party Cookies

2) Add each news site to your browser's javascript blacklist

Money I guess. I'd be interested in seeing a blog post analyzing how all this stuff gets used. For instance looking at https://www.theguardian.com/uk I can see hundreds of cookies against their site and loads of associated advertisers. Most of the items are a load of hashes and ids etc so how does all this stuff get used in reality and what are they actually storing - is it just a journey of clicks on that page etc?