The Google Way of Science. Google's translation of Chinese web pages invalidates Searle's Chinese Room riddle (kk.org) 4 points by ivankirigin 18y ago ↗ HN
[–] sygzzy 18y ago ↗ I always saw Searle's Chinese Room as more of an attack on the Turing Test. Here is a room that will pass the test, yet is in no way intelligent.
[–] logjam 18y ago ↗ Whoosh.That no "understanding" of Chinese takes place by Google would be Searle's point writ large.Of course, the point Searle misses is that the phenomenon of "understanding" is just symbol manipulation.
3 comments
[ 3.1 ms ] story [ 12.8 ms ] threadThat no "understanding" of Chinese takes place by Google would be Searle's point writ large.
Of course, the point Searle misses is that the phenomenon of "understanding" is just symbol manipulation.