Seemed as though by "Love this." you meant to endorse the sentiment. Were you saying you love the fact that a user made the sentiment? If so, why?
Also, as I have never been on FB, I was genuinely curious as to how they implement private messaging. rwolf's comment (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2751654) in this thread is a little bit enlightening, but not completely.
He was being tongue in cheek, or sarcastic. Private messages in FB are basically like emails. You have a private inbox that you can decide (based on your privacy controls) if/who can send private messages to you. This inbox is in a "Messages" section which isn't connected to your wall or profile in any way.
I do think that G+ is going to have some very tricky issues to navigate ahead in terms of integrating with other services. Private messaging is a decently amusing one (I wouldn't be surprised if some thin layer on top of email is introduced for that), but what about something like Facebook Events? They're a very compelling, very sticky, bit of engineering. Google Calendar has the functionality required, but it's not presented in the right way for this use case. but do you want to go that far? How much of GCal gets pulled in to the G+ interface? How much of the GCal underpinnings do you expose? All/Some/None?
Google has all the engineering bits and bobs in place for pretty much every Facebook feature, but it's unclear whether the vision is of G+ as a bit of glue between services, or whether it's the veneer on top of all the services. It's also not clear which would be best for users in the long-run.
It seems that, for G+, this is just the beginning, and I do not envy the G+ team :)
DISCLAIMER: I'm a Google Intern, but have no dealings with any teams here, nor do I know anything about future features.
Not only that, but you can make a post that has only one recipient. Private messaging is a special case of "I can send this post to specific recipients." Facebook's private messages exist as a separate thing in part because of how hard it is to control the audience of your Facebook posts.
yeah, I actually prefer this for the use case of "I have a stupid link to share with one or two people, then we might have a few back and forth comments, each only a sentence or two long."
I think it's a nicer forum for that than even threaded email clients, but at least one friend thought it was weird to be doing it in g+ rather than email, so we'll see.
Except there's no good 'record' of private posts you've received. If someone sent me something a week ago that I want to refer to, it's a bitch to find it again. This is why I'd rather see some gmail integration, essentially Facebook messages backed by your real gmail account, but with a simpler, prettier frontend integrated into G+ when you just want to fire off quick messages without context switching out of G+.
Yes, but since sites like Hacker News have been dutifully advertising Google+ non-stop since it came out, Google can release non-news and have it covered like it's news.
Yes, I think you're right. Google just needs to integrate it better with gmail, possibly add a mail icon on the users' page and when clicked the user can be taken into the gmail interface.
* filtering options for the main stream - at the very least be able to choose circles to include/exclude
* a "muted" stream (then I'll quickly mute the 90+% of the stream I find of little interest - but can still access or unmute if I want to)
* Something similar to facebook groups. I know this can be done elsewhere (Facebook Groups, Ning, reddit, etc.) but Google+ has the potential to integrate small groups into my daily workflow. More importantly, there are many people I know only because of a specific interest - and I'd like to only interact with them on that specific interest.
All 3 of these specific suggestions are under the same umbrella: reduce noise while engaging in more meaningful conversation and information sharing on topics I care about.
I would love to be able to flag a post as public but also only make it appear in specific circles streams.
My Google+ followers are mostly migrated from Twitter and they are mostly technical users with a lot of JS background.
This means I don't want to spam them with "funny" pictures or one-off comments about strange stuff, maybe even local to where I live. I DO want to post that stuff to my coworkers though as they are at least moderately interested and posting it to Google+ is less annoying than email for all of us.
I can already limit these posts to the "Coworkers" circle, but that means that the post is now not public any more. People looking at my profile don't see it. I can't link it directly and when a recipient decides to reshare, they get a (otherwise well-meaning) warning, even though the post is totally non-private - I just didn't want to spam my JS followers with that.
This is a shame because with Google+, I finally found an outlet where I can post stuff for the various groups of people without spamming others.
27 comments
[ 3.0 ms ] story [ 65.1 ms ] threadLove this. There is a private messaging option (it's email) but people are trying to replicate Facebook with a Google logo on it.
Will that help or hinder it's growth?
So... that's at least three private messaging options. You're proposing another one? How does Facebook do it, exactly?
Also, as I have never been on FB, I was genuinely curious as to how they implement private messaging. rwolf's comment (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2751654) in this thread is a little bit enlightening, but not completely.
Google has all the engineering bits and bobs in place for pretty much every Facebook feature, but it's unclear whether the vision is of G+ as a bit of glue between services, or whether it's the veneer on top of all the services. It's also not clear which would be best for users in the long-run.
It seems that, for G+, this is just the beginning, and I do not envy the G+ team :)
DISCLAIMER: I'm a Google Intern, but have no dealings with any teams here, nor do I know anything about future features.
I certainly do. Seems like an amazing opportunity to do really cool stuff!
I'd love to work with them too, but I think maybe when things have calmed down a bit :)
I think it's a nicer forum for that than even threaded email clients, but at least one friend thought it was weird to be doing it in g+ rather than email, so we'll see.
* Integration with Google Reader.
* Group chat (why is Huddle a mobile-only function?).
* Photo/screen-sharing (like the youtube sharing) in Hangouts.
* More granular control (I'd like to see my stream minus the Following Circle, since that's all the people I actually know or have met IRL).
* Finer control over UI (I'd like to be able to see my Following Circle with the comments collapsed by default, so it's easier to scan for content).
* "Places" (blog post: http://blog.byjoemoon.com/post/7072771434/a-new-metaphor-for...)
Just off the top of my head.
Isn't that a bit of non-news?
Isn't that what email is for?
* filtering options for the main stream - at the very least be able to choose circles to include/exclude
* a "muted" stream (then I'll quickly mute the 90+% of the stream I find of little interest - but can still access or unmute if I want to)
* Something similar to facebook groups. I know this can be done elsewhere (Facebook Groups, Ning, reddit, etc.) but Google+ has the potential to integrate small groups into my daily workflow. More importantly, there are many people I know only because of a specific interest - and I'd like to only interact with them on that specific interest.
All 3 of these specific suggestions are under the same umbrella: reduce noise while engaging in more meaningful conversation and information sharing on topics I care about.
My Google+ followers are mostly migrated from Twitter and they are mostly technical users with a lot of JS background.
This means I don't want to spam them with "funny" pictures or one-off comments about strange stuff, maybe even local to where I live. I DO want to post that stuff to my coworkers though as they are at least moderately interested and posting it to Google+ is less annoying than email for all of us.
I can already limit these posts to the "Coworkers" circle, but that means that the post is now not public any more. People looking at my profile don't see it. I can't link it directly and when a recipient decides to reshare, they get a (otherwise well-meaning) warning, even though the post is totally non-private - I just didn't want to spam my JS followers with that.
This is a shame because with Google+, I finally found an outlet where I can post stuff for the various groups of people without spamming others.
This would be pretty mega. Covers A LOT of bases.