Ask HN: What’s the fastest Linux OS for a slow computer?

15 points by DantesKite ↗ HN
Edit: For watching YouTube videos and going on social media platforms.

19 comments

[ 3.0 ms ] story [ 49.4 ms ] thread
You need to be more specific as to what you want.

The last time I looked was a few years ago, and slackware (for CLI only) and puppylinux (very, very basic GUI with a browser) were the top contenders. But puppylinux may be too basic for you, it did not support any of the standard browsers by default and likely has some compatibility issues with some sites.

I don't use it, since I like a beefy setup, but lubuntu is a lightweight Ubuntu flavor you could try:

https://lubuntu.net/

From the top of my mind, on standby, Lubuntu uses 500M of RAM, Xubuntu (XFCE) around 750M and Ubuntu (Gnome) 1G.
NetBSD or FreeBSD with UFS or Debain
I see a lot of people asking for a light distro and then they are disappointed because the performance is not what they expected.

When you use a modern browser, your lightweight distro doesn't matter anymore. The web stack is heavy, even if sites are coded with performance in mind.

Definitely this, htop shows the pain.

I repurposed an old laptop for occasional video watching, running a small debian. Firefox or chrome are huge compared to everything else.

The other factor is that high video resolution eats the machine.

youtube-dl (480px) + mpv is much nicer than streaming in a browser.

That's a good point. Maybe I'll try Mighty. Looks promising.
OS/Desktop environment does matter. It is going to be the single biggest thing that competes for resource if you only intend to use the machine for what the OP wants.

Most websites still work OK on slow machines (my travel laptop was one and it could handle 90% of the websites just fine). OS/Desktop env is often the biggest sink. That machine for example would hit 75% CPU on windows 10 just idling which didn't leave enough room for anything else. Wiped it with Ubuntu + Gnome and it went to ~25% CPU usage while idling. Switched to Ubuntu + XFCE less that 3% while idling.

The only website I had a problem with was Patreon.

I'm using Xubuntu and it seem to work well on a slow computer. There could be better options but my specific usecase was easier to implement with Ubuntu packages.
i was gonna say alpine but yeah, no youtube...
I tried MX Linux with additional driver support, but they didn't detect any usable screen resolutions.

The latest version of Lubuntu switched to using Qt, which isn't necessarily a bad thing out of context, but it's slower and uses more ram. Lubuntu 18 is probably the latest version without Qt. For more context, Qt is probably something you should use for a general application, not for an OS GUI or default OS apps.

I settled on Ubuntu Mate which is the lightest Ubuntu I am aware of, and I've generally been happy with it for last decade.

Gentoo is the fastest Linux distro and penguin, (hence the name).

It has a BSD style port system with useflags for optimizations. A very technically precise installation process, and it also boots up faster than anything I’ve seen.

Otherwise, use LFS with either Portage or Pkgsrc.

Not if you have to compile it yourself(on a slow computer).
Most linux distros would fit the bill for that.

Very often it is the desktop environment that kills resources on your machine. So if you have a slow computer make sure to pick a desktop environment that is lightweight (Gnome likely won't give you good results). XFCE would be great. I used stock Ubuntu + Xfce for years on an slow chromebook level computer for Youtube videos, social media, Netflix and so on without issues. The machine had 4Gigs of ram and a crappy dual core cpu. Go with Ubuntu + XFCE.

Try Antix. They have just released a new version. It's a so called 'live-distro' able to run from usb-stick/keychain, or in RAM if have enough. BUT you can also remaster it, and write that customized image back to your stick.

[+] https://antixlinux.com/download/

I've been too lazy to install/remaster the already downloaded image so far, because mine runs since 76 days 24/7 in RAM :-)

If you're crazy you can even integrate

[x] https://trinitydesktop.org/ and remaster that into your image, but apart from the very customizable look&feel it doesn't make that much sense. OTOH it's not that fat either, very compact, rather.

It also has convenient scripts(via menu) for populating /etc/HOSTS with adblocking lists, similar to pi-hole. That alone makes many sites much less heavy. Otherwise use alternative clients? Like nitter for twitter, and using youtube-dl(g) with mpv for videos like other posters have written? Also installing uBlock-Origin for the parts which aren't covered by hosts-based adblocking. How much RAM do you have?

The fastest I've found yet is q4os. It's snapper than LUbuntu which was my previous go-to for old laptops. https://q4os.org/