11 comments

[ 0.23 ms ] story [ 33.6 ms ] thread
> When the internet came about, the initial vision for retail was that you would have these avatars that would go to a shelf for a sweater and then walk over to the cash register and buy it. It was just stupid and didn’t make any sense.

That does sound like a very dot-com bubble idea. Wonder if Metaverse is also a bubble indicator.

WebWorld / ActiveWorld 3.0!
I was working for Steve Kirsch at Infoseek during this time, and I remember, too, laughing at the people who thought this was the way people would shop. And all the hype about VRML at the Web conferences at this time!

I pointed out to some of the starry-eyed believers that people have been shopping happily from catalogs for 100+ years, and that would translate well to the web. No 3D required. And we were a _search_ company! You would think someone would have posited that _searching_ may be a better model than _browsing_ for some things.

Sure, the ability to spin something to get a 360 view (in a 2D browser) of something once you've seen it on a 2D page has some utility, but 4 orthogonal views handle that well enough too.

I can't imagine I'd ever don a pair of 3D glasses to buy another pair of Levis.

also it's basically impossible to see if jeans fit. Not even in real life.
I have no idea how the metaverse will turn out, but this reminds me of a classic 1998 article, 2D is Better Than 3D https://www.nngroup.com/articles/2d-is-better-than-3d/
To be fair, he acknowledges 3D can be good for video games / 3D CAD, he’s just saying that 3D is superfluous for most information-processing tasks.
Indeed where are all those Second Life users after its hype bubble faded away?
So... When is this nonsensical „Second Life FB Edition“ that makes zero sense coming out?

Why announce something… some time in the future?

Rebranding the company already happened.

Perhaps the rebranding was timed to take some political pressure off $FB. Or perhaps it is "Cortez burning the ships" to focus the efforts of the entire company so there is no going back.