HN Explorer

9 comments

[ 1.1 ms ] story [ 21.8 ms ] thread
jrockway
IMHO, using the word "CRAP" to describe good practices seems like a bad idea. I thought the article was going to be a rant about some UIs the author didn't like... instead it was useful advice. I'm glad I clicked through, but "CRAP" didn't help that.
Jem
This person didn't invent the term CRAP to define good design; it's been around for longer than I can remember.
nuclear_eclipse
It's still a poor term for positive reinforcement...
denglish
...and makes it nearly impossible to separate the crap from the CRAP!
jrockway
Fair enough. But the people that need basic advice like this might not be aware of the term, and might not read the article as a result.
Jem
On the contrary, I think people are more likely to read it because of the "lol they said CRAP!" reaction. I guess that was why the term was 'invented', as opposed to PRAC or RAPC or another less-silly combination.

FYI this was where I first heard the acronym: http://www.amazon.co.uk/Non-Designers-Design-Book-Robin-Will...

sh1mmer
"How to make your user interface CARP on at people about what they should do."

CRAP isn't ironic, it's crap.

[deleted]
(comment deleted)
[deleted]
(comment deleted)