Ask HN: How can I prepare for hard economic times?
With massive drops in productivity and increases in government spending the economy was hurting. Now with Russia attacking Ukraine oil prices are going to hurt the economy more.
I'm worrying about the future for me and my young family.
Do you have any advice for someone with dependents during this time?
339 comments
[ 2.8 ms ] story [ 271 ms ] threadLike others have said, that’s aside from the point. You are more likely to lose than gain by timing the market. That’s what the GP is getting at.
Or in 2018 when a trade war between china and US was just around the corner?
Or in 2016 when Brexit was the fall of the EU and Trump just got elected?
There's always something, and it's never clear that that something is going to actually be the real deal.
If tensions rise we could see China and the west getting less friendly. I live in the bottom of the Pacific and we rely heavily on Chinese trade.
They only thing that really counts in the end is that you, personally, have enough revenue to cover your expenditures. If not, increase the former and decrease the latter until you do. You may need to adjust your expectations too.
Looking at one of the best biotech hedge funds, YoY% is -5% (March 2021-March 2022).
These don't qualify as a major gain in my book.
The gains materialize when the end of the world that everyone expected yesterday eventually fails to materialize.
It's precisely when no one (i.e mainstream media) is expecting, things go south. E.g 2008
However, ppl predicting crash will be right eventually because boom-bust happens in cycles. We just don't know when. Even a broken clock shows the right time twice a day.
"just trust me bro"
pretty good chance i wont do any of this.
If the crash is "naturally" deflationary, the central banks have now shown a commitment to sustaining inflationary policy to keep inflation at target.
But in the case of a "naturally" inflationary recession (stagflation), central banks will be hesitant to ramp up deflationary policy, because regaining employment levels will be a higher priority, and deflationary policy tends to hurt employment.
Make sure to have a small cash reserve so that you can manage for a while even if something devastating happens. Make sure to have a small stockpile of food at home so that you can make those money last longer. As a bonus, this will also count as basic prepping, and you'll be able to handle things like being snowed in for a week without too much problems (assuming you live where such a thing is possible).
Also cut down on non-mortage debt if possible, and make sure things like streaming subscriptions can be cancelled at a minute's notice; If you end up losing part or a lot of your income then you don't want to be stuck paying for things you don't really need (Spotify, Netflix etc).
I'm not looking to invest, I just want to make sure I provide food and shelter for my wife and child.
Good idea to have a plan to rapidly reduce spending. I think I'll see what I can cut now. There are things I host that can be cancelled. No more VPS to host a personal email server I hardly use.
With Covid-lockdown and remote jobs, you can drastically cut your expense if you can move out of the city.
I'm aware of the work it takes to live off the land. I don't have the skill or fitness to do so but still dream of trying that one day.
- housing: pick in a flat to keep your energy costs low (neighbors heat one another), and make sure you can walk to a park or a river. Fight to make your city more walkable and bikeable, and support your local businesses. Make sure to live close to people you like or to build new relationship (can't beat cities for that!). I love my neighbors and we regularly organize meetings to ensure every one is happy (that was so awesome during lockdowns, I never felt better surrounded). Being in a city means you stay close to people you like (so important during harsh times) and have more transportation options. I can walk anywhere: doctors, police, markets, train station, etc. Note that my French grand-parents always said that WWII was much easier for townspeople (the bigger the city, the better) and given their experience, I fully trust them when planning for harsh times.
- transportation: I spend ~€10 per month for my transportation needs (I own a cheap, light bike to go to work and move around). I take the subway/train sometime (when I'm too tired to bike) but it's much cheaper than all other options.
- food: I'm a member of a coop i.e we partnered with a local, organic farmer to commit to deliver all his production directly to us, for the whole year and at a fixed cost (around ~€15/week for a big basket of vegetables). I opted to get other produces from the coop, from other farmers/artisans: bread (1.5 kg/week), flours, oils, fruits (apples, pears, oranges, pomelos, kakis, berries…), café, etc. No distribution and overhead cost (we run everything ourselves, and do the distributions once a week). The inflation is very limited inflation (almost zero logistics costs, little impact of market prices) and at least one year of visibility and cash. This helped me become vegetarian: the food is so good, cheap and more sustainable. Coops let you have the benefits of the the city and the countryside, and you can't better help farmers (we work together to ensure they invest in the long term, protect their health, use as little fertilizers and pesticides as possible…).
Ask HN: What tips do you have for weathering a recession? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15798401 - Nov 2017 (104 comments)
Ask HN: How are you preparing yourself for a recession? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22527383 - Mar 2020 (148 comments)
But that's me / selfish, imagine being Ukranian and having to leave the country. I hope they saw it coming and prepared accordingly.
Also in Europe there are Forex brokers that offer contracts (CFDs) on commodities, but there are a lot of scammy firms in this area, and the spreads charged are usually hefty.
(according to wikipedia in US CFDs are banned)
Because that's easy to do for everyone?
Is it? I don’t think it is. Why do you think it is?
https://ukpersonal.finance/flowchart/
The essence is to have a budget. Understand exactly how much you spend and where you spend it. Once that's done, you can work out where (if anywhere) you can save money. It might be as simple as cutting out Netflix, or as complicated as refinancing all your debt.
You can't just "pay everything off", and so the above chart prioritizes things which have highest interest, as pay down aggressively first.
How would you scale down your expenses (if at all?) if your real income decreased by 10 %? What about 50 %? How long could you survive if you end up with no income? What consumption can you reduce, and what can you cut out entirely? When will you start cutting some things out? How much longer will that make any savings last?
Similarly, how would you scale up the household income if your expenses increased? At what rate can you withdraw from any savings?
A secondary benefit of this exercise is that it lets you find the pain points and see if you can do something now to limit their consequences later. (Is there e.g. preventative maintenance you can do on a car or your teeth that would avoid a more expensive breakdown later?)
----
In contrast to many others, I don't place such a high value on having an exact day-to-day budget. Generally, both expenses and income follow a fairly statistically stable pattern, i.e. it averages out.
You do want to know what the averages are, of course, but you don't need to meticulously track daily expenses and income to learn that -- it's enough to go back in history and sample, say, every sixth day. Much less work for basically all the same benefits.
See Question D on https://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/ukraine/.
Also, USD has actually gotten stronger in the last month, and the sanctions were mostly on EUR anyway.
The consequence of this is to prioritise a long mortgage over total repayments and to not necessarily pay off as much as possible, even keeping money back for day to day spending, assuming that's budgeted properly. Obviously there is a trade off; the smaller you can get your mortgage the more flexibility you have around adjusting repayments to help with living costs.
The long term view of inflation also suggests it might be better to hold more debt to ease things now. Though obviously that depends on how your wages might change in the longer run.
Gold is already jumped so that is too late. Crypto seems correlated with stocks.
I’m counting on a large gap between salary and expenses to save my ass
Instead of eliminating an asset completely, come up with an estimate of its value to the economy in the future, relative to the other assets (do this to cash also). Then, target your portfolio to match that distribution.
While gold jumped, it doesn't mean it's over. And while crypto has been correlated with stocks, it still has some non-correlated part, introducing diversification, and you certainly don't need leverage to target a desired volatility.
Other items to consider:
* fertilizer (food prices going up means fertilizer will do the same; but it has doubled in the past year)
* farmland REIT
* office REIT (if you think the economy comes back to the office)
* Ukrainian stocks ("buy when there's blood on the streets" also means "invest when the country most needs it")
Keep in mind buying stocks in a public company doesn't directly "support" it; buying stuff from them, or buying their bonds, does. This is basically the issue with ESG index funds.
They might need to buy food or flee using the money, and by bidding up the stock prices you help them (even if just a bit).
Preparing for hard economic times will involve having enough of a buffer to survive the loss of a job, and to have a stable job.
Now might not be the best time to work in a startup that sells discretionary goods/services.
If you've got a solid job in an industry not too vulnerable to supply chain shocks or high interest rates you should weather the next downturn, as long as your expenditure is under control.
Most people have a job in bad times. The real problem is your wages won't keep pace with inflation so you have to be careful.
Pay off debts now. Get an emergency cash fund going. Max out your retirement savings (so you can afford to save nothing if needed).
Last, but most important: you don't know what is coming. Enjoy life as best you can now.
If you expect inflation to keep increasing, then one of the financially smart things to do would be to take as much debt as possible and purchase hard assets with the debt (such as land or commodities).
For me personally, I wouldn't follow this advise because I don't like the psychological burden of being indebted. I just wanted to highlight how higher inflation expectations disrupts traditional saving advice. It nullifies the idea of hoarding lots of cash.
I don't know why they don't constantly predict deflationary spirals instead, which are even worse, but it's probably childhood memories of the 70s.
If you know for sure inflation will be through the roof, but you will keep your job: then taking on more debt at a fixed low rate now, and investing in something that grows is the right thing. However this is risky. I can tell you what investments would have worked in the past, but it isn't hard to find historical advice that turned out bad. As such I would never recommend taking on more debt to invest even though the math seems to work. Though not paying off the house and instead investing in something else might be good advice.
Note that when those who retire early are surveyed most paid off the house early. Even though they know the math says index funds are a better investment, the peace of mind from not having dept is something they all say is important. In short the best financial advice isn't always the advice that works in practice. YMMV
I dont believe we will see a crash.
Stocks might go sideways for quit a while.
But companies will keep chugging along and employ people.
Companies which will do well, are companies, telling people the world will end...
Nasdaq-100 is down 21.33% in 7 weeks. According to wikipedia a stock market crash is a decline "of over 10% in a stock market index over a period of several days".
DAX declined even sharper (-16.5% in 12 days; -24% from recent highs).
Just as a heads up: this is similar to the 1990's where Iraq invaded Kuwait. The Dow Jones Industrial Average dropped 18% in three months, from 2,911.63 on July 3 to 2,381.99 on October 16,1990. This recession lasted approximately 8 months. This recession is listed as a "stock market crash" on wikipedia. [1]
IMO when something loses 1/5th of its value in such a short time it could be considered a crash.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Stock_market_crashes "Early 1990s recession"
Today we can update any index you might be interested in, in a few milliseconds. (I'm sure there are high frequency traders reading this who can give more accurate timings)
That way, you will be more easily able to provide your family with food. Especially if both you and wife can do the farm work.
And perhaps, with the farm at some point you might be able to live without needing to work much.
Some inspiration can be found here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T15gXm6ha_I
A big polytunnel in the garden might make sense as a time-consuming hobby with practical benefits (though I still think it would be more expensive than just getting groceries), but not a farm.
In mine (UK) one the biggest outgoing costs is energy, mainly heating. There are various government schemes to help people with recent bills and ways of reducing energy consumption.
I haven't checked the statistics but here in Portugal at least for me the biggest outgoing costs are rents (by a large margin), followed by food. Gas prices and car maintenance costs are also high, whereas public transport is roughly on a par with monthly energy costs.
Are people in the UK all heating their homes with electricity?
Mortgage/rent, highly variable depending on where you live, house big enough etc and if a mortgage, how many years are you able to spread it over.
Most UK homes are heated by gas. My recent bill went up 50% to £1500/y. Is expected to increase by 50% again this year.
Gas is also one of the main sources of electricity generation here.
Energy has by far outstripped inflation here over the past year.
Gas heating is common in the UK but a) it's being phased out for eco reasons b) gas has increased in price as well
Also be ready to evacuate from the city when time will come. Move early, roads will be stuck very quickly. Keep your car tanks full, keep few cans of gasoline as well.
It is a mistake, gold is the only safe bet
Btw it is estimated that the last time gold was declared illegal, only about 5% of gold owners gave it up.
I mean it's happened to Russian oligarchs, but those were investments that they didn't even live in. It's happened to Palestinians, who live under an apartheid regime. But other than that, I can't recall anything like that happening. WW2 Europe maybe, for specific demographics.
Actually, have you tried figuring out WHFIT taxes on $GLD? I ended up invested in it once and had no clue how you do it.
It might help if things don’t go too pear shaped, but this kind of event (a foreign invasion by a military with no regards for civilians) is basically game over regardless of your situation. The best outcome is you survive and rebuild.
Despite the madness the only thing I learn about looting from Ukraine is:
- civilian would-be looters still getting punished
- Russian soldiers are looting
i.e. when your rations expired you get desperate and since the Russian army is armed and know they are an utter disgrace anyway this happens.
It’s been 20 days. I’d refrain from being overly optimistic just now. More likely than a full civilisation collapse is a return to feudal tribalism as in Afghanistan and Lybia, which is not very good either.
https://dig-for-victory.org.uk/
What is your threat model?
Is it losing your savings to inflation? Having it taken away by a corrupt government?
Is it an invasion of the Russians?
Is it losing your job? Or the downfall of society to the point where nobody needs a programmer anymore?
Prepare for failure of government/war? Go be a "prepper" - Ie. have a few months worth of food and water stored. (not that hard in tins/pasta/rice). Get small solar panels for phone charging and a gas/wood camping stove. Download wikipedia.
In both cases, prepare to move countries. Often it's better to just leave than try to survive in subpar conditions. Beware that millions of others may be trying to do the same, and lots of governments don't like millions of refugees. Get yourself a passport for another country and you'll be far more likely to be let in.