18 comments

[ 3.6 ms ] story [ 66.8 ms ] thread
Paywalled
And it's not even a new idea.
Can confirm deliberately posting paywalled articles is not a new idea. People have been doing it for decades!
No, the idea that ancient paintings were designed to look animated by firelight is not a new idea.
The cave firelight is fascinating in the film "Cave of Forgotten Dreams" by Werner Herzog, where he documents the art of the Chauvet caves of Southern France.

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1664894/

This theory has been around for decades and keeps getting "rediscovered" every few years. I think this newly published finding is additional evidence but it's not a major new discovery.
> That thought would be interesting enough to chew over, but the researchers have gone one hypothesis further: that the fire was more than mere illumination and its flickerings acted to provide a primitive animation to the plaquettes’ carvings.

I just checked, and LED lighting wasn't invented until much later than 15,000 years ago. So, whether they benefited from the primitive animation or not, I am confident they would have displayed their art by firelight anyway.

Or sunlight...
The plaquettes are small and portable, so they may have done both. But if they're enjoying the animation effect of a fire, it's probably dark.
(comment deleted)