Ask HN: Can AI Have a Soul?

2 points by estebandalelr ↗ HN
We've all read the news, but I want opinions. IMO, yes, their brains are silicone, ours are fat, but might be similar.

6 comments

[ 2.8 ms ] story [ 23.3 ms ] thread
What attributes would you say a soul has?
I don't know what a "soul" is or even if there is such a thing but if you're asking if a computer program can have conscious experiences then my answer is no. The reason simply stated is that computations are abstract, conscious experiences are not and abstract things cannot produce non-abstract things.
What if the computer program is running on a robot that interacts with the real world?
Usually when people claim that a computer can be conscious they're claiming that consciousness is a possible property of the software that the computer is running, because that is where the non-trivial functionality is defined.

In your example if you think that the robot is conscious wouldn't it still be conscious if you replaced the "real world" with a simulation ?

Opinion: the soul is a construct created by the church to excert pressure. So no, it can not (and neither do you).
I just have a vague awareness of my surroundings based on horribly inaccurate electrochemical data and a memory-based sense of self that gets annihilated and reinitialized every night. :D