HN Explorer

25 comments

[ 5.8 ms ] story [ 64.1 ms ] thread
Synaesthesia
The big news is that the carriers forced it onto almost all smartphones (Android, Blackberry, iPhone). The blame needs to be pinned on them.
fpgeek
I'm curious about which carriers.

Are we just talking about US carriers or carriers worldwide? I'd think "Carrier IQ" wouldn't fly under stricter European privacy laws (even if it is OK in the US, which some people say is an open question). Is that right?

Synaesthesia
Absolutely. That was the very question I thought of as I posted that. I have a suspicion it's US carriers.
shareme
in fact its probably the same exact carrier whose parent was given the right to spy on amercians for the us government after laws were broken..
Achshar
Well I live in India and i will look for CareerIQ in my bro's galaxy. The handsets here are contract free and GSM.
[deleted]
(comment deleted)
[dead] untog
How does that work with the iPhone, I wonder? Android phones have custom firmwares for each carrier, but I thought that everyone downloaded the same update package in iTunes. Am I wrong?
WestCoastJustin
I have a Samsung GalaxyS running Android on Rogers (rogers.com) up in Canada and there is no CarrierIQ installed. Maybe we need to create a spreadsheet so we can track which phones / providers have this installed.
nodata
CarrierIQ - does this mean that contract-free phones don't have it installed?
w1ntermute
Of course not. If you bought the phone through a carrier that has CarrierIQ normally installed, then why would they make an exception for the 0.1% of customers who bought a smartphone off-contract?

So no, the name has nothing to do with it.

nodata
Who said anything about buying through a carrier?
cbs
You kind of implied it when you said contract-free instead of not from a carrier.

At least here in the States, the majority of contract free and prepaid phones for sale are associated with a particular carrier.

nodata
I avoided saying "unlocked" because it would imply it was locked at some point. What should I call them?
bobbles
In Australia the retailers generally call it a 'handset only' purchase
AkThhhpppt
The convention I've seen is "SIM-free."
moomin
I'd hope Google knew how to track users efficiently without third-party help.
mstepniowski
"We're still wondering why Google would reject Carrier IQ from its flagship devices but allow phones with the software to pass the various Android compatibility tests required to license its apps like Gmail, Google Maps, and Android Market."
drcube
Google doesn't include Bing in its flagship devices. That doesn't mean somebody can't install it later if they want to.
[dead] nobody314159265
That's not the point - the point is that apps on Android are sandboxed so that Angry Birds can't read call premium phone lines or extract your calling history.

Google approved builds which included a rootkit that could do all these things

hamoid
Looking at the latest Wikileaks release (http://wikileaks.org/the-spyfiles.html) it makes me think that this Carrier IQ thing, if it is used for getting to our personal data, is just a pixel in the complete picture.