Tell HN: Covid Boosters – An Anecdata Study

7 points by fny ↗ HN
My partner (27 White F) and I (31 White M) engaged in an experiment. We both received the vaccine at the exact same time in 2021. However, she proceeded to get her boosters including the latest while I did not. We are both healthy young adults with normal BMI. We took the same supplements: daily vitamin, fish oil. We ate the same food. We shared the same space.

Note there are known discrepancies between males and females[0], so treat this anecdata as anecdata.

Recently, my brother--who was vaccinated and had COVID (delta) once before but no booster--visited while he was floridly positive. By floridly positive, I mean he was able to trigger a rapid test.

After 3 days of exposure, both my partner and I developed COVID that was only detectable by PCR.

On day 4, I developed a high fever (102), soar throat, cough, congestion. I was then shedding enough virus to trigger a rapid test. My brothers symptoms resolved, he no longer triggered a rapid test. My partner did not have any symptoms or trigger a rapid test. I took an Advil.

On day 5, my fever continued although more mildly, soar throat, cough, congestion continued. I was still able to trigger a raid test. My partner complained of a scratchy throat but did not trigger a rapid test.

On day 6, I no longer had a fever only a mild sore throat and congestion. I was able to trigger a rapid test. My partner did not have any symptoms or trigger a rapid test.

It's day 7, my symptoms have resolved and I was no longer able to trigger a rapid test. My partner? You guessed it: nada.

Note, my partner continued to cohabit with me through this period as if nothing was different. We shared the same bed, we shared the same cups, she give me kisses--you know everything you're absolutely not supposed to do when you're with someone who has COVID, but she never shed enough virus to trigger a rapid test and never developed symptoms of note.

Conclusion: Boosters appear to reduce or even eliminate COVID symptoms. Boosters also appear to reduce virus shedding as evidenced by the rapid test results.

Disclaimer: There's apparently some risk that the virus mutates in one person and reinfects the other. So maybe don't try this at home?

[0]: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7381128/

4 comments

[ 3.4 ms ] story [ 16.2 ms ] thread
@fny - Clarification request: Are you saying your partner had the most recent BA.5 booster?
Flagged, because anecdotes are interesting, but they are not data.

Sometimes people share houses, time, and fluids, and one might get sick, the other not. Similarly one might get sick, then recover, and the other might die.

COVID is a topic that brings out lots of emotion, from all sides "Listen to the science", "Released from a lab", "fake news".

Sometimes it helps to hear life experience from a fellow human, devoid of anything institutional. I hope this is robust enough to be valuable. I do have a journal.

I honestly had my own doubts. This experience clarified it for me. Do what you will with the information.