Most young men live in quiet desperation, is it possible to resolve this?

18 points by dumbaccount123 ↗ HN
Same thing regarding a growing number of women too but men don't have the same support structure as women do. But this discussion isn't really about that -in a world where everything is connected and everyone's looking to solve a problem how do we solve loneliness?

There are apps like meetup but how effective are they? especially once your in your late 20s/early 30s it becomes exponentially harder on average to make lifelong bonds.

48 comments

[ 61.3 ms ] story [ 1813 ms ] thread
Why do you think women have a better support structure than men?
I don't want to get into that, I maybe labelled as something I am not. But its just personal experience and that's all I can say.
Besides the obvious, joining some group that interests you in your local area in order to meet new people, I'd also suggest checking out some discord channels where you can meet / chat / video chat with people. They really took off over the past couple of years, and there are quite a range to choose from.

https://disboard.org/ is a good index of them.

Not OP, but it might be because when you ask men and women about their social/support networks, men as a group report having a worse support network.

https://www.cnn.com/2022/11/29/health/men-friendships-wellne...

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-7488709/One-five-me...

https://medium.com/the-weekend-reader/why-dont-men-have-frie...

If you think women don't have WAY more resources than men in society, be it for their social health or otherwise, I have to question your ability to observe evidence.
What resources, for example? Genuinely curious. Social health, like access to psychologists or what?
Not GP: better/closer friends, no stigma about going to psychologists, and showing emotions is still seen as "unmanly" (which I used to great success to weed out partners early, as I tear up easily in movies and any date giving me too much shit for it I can safely discard)
"If you don't see this thing that's TOTALLY OBVIOUS to me, I don't know what to tell you." - Don't forget confirmation bias etc on your side. Different things are obvious to different people.
(comment deleted)
There are groups trying to address this for men. F3[0] is a nominally exercise-focused group for men that is setup to encourage building social bonds. https://f3nation.com/

0 - F3 stands for “Fitness, Fellowship, and Faith”. The “faith” part doesn’t specify/require any particular religion, or that attendees observe any religion at all.

I have never felt true loneliness, but as a single scoped suggestion, I've always felt in good company in my teenage years playing MMORPGs in a tight-knit guild, and now in adulthood playing TTRPGs with local groups (not that there's an age limit to MMORPGs but I haven't found one that resonates with me for a while). For an even more extroverted person in a bigger city than where I live I'd imagine improv is in the same spectrum further to the side of "having fun by goofing off".
> Same thing regarding a growing number of women too but men don't have the same support structure as women do.

I’m a woman and I honestly have no idea what you’re talking about here.

Regardless, I’ve struggled with intense social anxiety and loneliness since about 13.

The only long-term ”solutions” I’ve found that help have been: having a partner, good relationships with my family and joining a club (in my case, a football club) that has recurring sessions weekly.

Obviously, the latter is something that’s more easy to “engineer” than the first two.

So my only advice is to find or start a club or interest group that regularly meets. I’ve found that groups on Meetup often don’t have the same group if people attending. So rather search for local sports groups or community groups where you’ll meet some of the same people week after week and be able to build relationships with them over time.

I understand, apologies for offending. Its not as black and white as I made it out in the OP.

The kind of loneliness I'm referring to is were you're completely alone and you don't have a partner, when you can go two months sitting indoors and have 0 texts on your phone. Obviously this is a complex subject so theres nothing I can really expand on without stating bias.

Why are you sitting indoors?
Its not me and I'm not sitting in doors but there are people who are so alone that no one would notice their absence. Actually quite a large problem in certain parts of Asia.
Because pointlessly sitting around on my couch is nicer than pointlessly sitting around in some loud venue or outside with god awful weather.

I blame Covid personally. Before Covid there was stuff going on that could motivate me to go do stuff, but not so much the last years or two. Even going out to bars feels tedious now.

Twenty years ago we were talking about the book "Bowling Alone". This is more of the same, there's a decline in civic institutions and civic engagement. Work is totally anodyne if you even go into the office. Low status men are left-behind in the dating market because women select high status men.

Do some group fitness class, they usually have some kind of social event once and a while, so you can at least get to casually know a few people.

[flagged]
Perhaps the problem is that all secular thinking is bad, and teaching young men and women to blindly follow is always a bad idea, even with good role models. If you don't learn to think for yourself and contextualize what you see/hear, you've got pretty bad odds at being a good adult.

And that's just a problem on both sides of the aisle. It will probably continue to dominate modern politics, until improving democracy becomes more profitable than making people argue passionately.

> Perhaps the problem is that all secular thinking is bad

> and teaching young men and women to blindly follow is always a bad idea

Uh huh? Sounds like you’d have no problem with blind following as long as it aligns with your beliefs.

You're just invoking the intolerance paradox. Also, you're logic is not sound. There is no evidence that the second claim came from blindly following beliefs.
What the hell are you even trying to say.

I never once claimed that there’s evidence that “teaching young men and women to blindly follow is always a bad idea” came from blindly following beliefs. That doesn’t even make ducking sense? Are you good? You seem a bit out of it. If you’re going to reply, at least make it comprehensible. Also tolerance was not even in my mind when I wrote that so take your blind copy/paste buzzwords back to Reddit.

What are these so-called male-bashing cartoons, films, etc.? Are any of the Marvel or DC series male-bashing, for example? Avatar? James Bond? Video games like Fortnite?
[flagged]
"I refuse to provide even a single piece of evidence because it is too abundant". This is frightening mental gymnastics. This is, like, cult-level thinking. Whatever virus your brain has caught is really a dangerous thing.
Spoonfeeding services here: Peppa Pig has adult-males bashing: Daddy Pig is clueless and fat. Paw patrol: adult males are either absent (main character has no dad) or very far from the action and in need of help, or they are doofu baddy. Many other absent dads in eg. Timmy, Masha, Gabby's dollhouse, PJ Masks (also with mostly inane adult males) Bluey's dad is kind of a role model of a well-functioning nice and cool adult male, but he has to be a dog, not a human.
Let your guard down a little and check out some opinions you disagree with. The world is actually really complicated out there.
You are begging the question.[1] The question wasn't "what is the cause?" but rather "what is the solution?" which you fail to answer, as in: how can we prevent "the media" from pushing faux moral intellectualism? Note, I'm not addressing the question of whether that's the true cause or not. But, assuming it is -- what can be done about it? Is calling out "the media" on HN enough?

[1] in the older sense of the phrase; nowadays most people use it differently, but it originally meant ~"answering without really answering".

So, many [citation needed] tags to add here. Multiple per sentence. None of this is supported by any evidence whatsoever. None of this holds up to a cursory examination of modern society. Literally none of this is based on anything. But it feeds your anger. It feeds your persecution complex. It makes you feel morally justified to be an asshole. It's their fault I voted for Trump. It's their fault I listen to Andrew Tate and Jordan Peterson. It's their fault I sexually harass women. It's their fault I hate Jews. It's their fault I'm a fascist neo-Nazi. It's their fault I send death threats to the parents of school-shooting victims. Any action is justified, because of them. Evidence not necessary, because it just feels so good.
Thank you for proving my entire point.
So saying "There is no evidence for your claims" is proving your point? Any claim you make is proven true by the very fact that others strongly disagree with it? Up is down, white is black, and truth has no meaning anymore? You're already very far gone, then. This is not a healthy mental state.
Your need to mention Trump, racism, use of the term "asshole" proved exactly what I was talking about. Enjoy continuing to be wrong, I'm not going to waste any more time giving you my perspective.
Some version of this question pops up every month or so, and I personally don't get the sense that people/society views this as a collective problem, but rather a problem for individual men to figure out on their own.
[flagged]
What is this inceldom gobbledegook, come on man, this is a very unrealistic way to look at the world.
what is unrealistic about it? Maybe you should put your idea to refute mine. Just saying something is unrealistic doesn't make it so.
It's just basic biology actually: females are the selectors in the animal kingdom, and most men are not selected for. Why would females risk having pregnacy if they wouldn't have some genetical advantage in return?
Go back to /pol/, even /g/ thinks this is cringe.
I didn't know Mr. /g/ had a representative on this site. Thanks for letting me know what he thinks of my comment.
(comment deleted)
I used to do meetup and there were some groups i really enjoyed, and I did find some friends that i began spending time with outside the group. Aside from that, it seems like a lot of social activities marketed as being "for men" are based on exercising with other men and drinking alcohol with other men, which really limits people who aren't aware of less marketed activities.

I personally found a lot of enjoyment in swing and ballroom dance bc the level of exercise is less strenuous, there's more variety of people to talk to, there's generally no alcohol, and they typically have a structured intro time for beginners before an event.

I don't think this is an "external solution" thing. Some random gender-neutral ideas for becoming more interesting to others and being more interested in them:

- Read widely, both fiction and nonfiction. Become interested in and even familiar with experiences outside your own comfort zone.

- Work on empathy and tolerance. Be ready to hear and even validate things you don't fully agree with, whether it's politically or epistemologically. Learn to respect others and see them as people with full life experiences, rather than merely as potential partners or friends to enhance your life experience.

- Get life experience that is interesting. Note that this doesn't mean traveling widely or having an "interesting" job. In fact sometimes those things make you seem boring and are anyways often inaccessible. There are more accessible things to do, like volunteering with people who have different experiences than you, working on a local cause that is important to you, or learning to make art that represents your feelings.

- Make yourself go outside. The world is outside. Learn about the history of your local area and visit the important places in it.

- Pay a little bit of attention to things like hygiene, grooming, clothes. You don't have to go crazy, just shower thoroughly every day, get regular haircuts, and wear clothes that roughly match your age.

- As others have mentioned, find somewhere with a stable group of people and show up consistently.

- Get therapy, even if you think you don't need it. Most people need it.

- Avoid toxic X. Masculinity, femininity, whatever. Being lonely can make you feel like you need a rubric to follow. Don't buy it. Don't even take what I'm saying above as a rubric.

Ultimately the goal isn't to find an app that matches you with the perfect person or group of people, but to become someone who is interesting to and interested in more people overall. I empathize with the fact that people are sometimes hard to like, but almost everyone has something to recommend them if you are willing to listen, and so do you if you're willing to explore and expand yourself and share that with others.

I think these are all great suggestions for anybody, but it misses the point doesn't it? There is a reason these affect men more than women, why? And how do we fix that?
Look into men’s work / men’s groups. I’ve just started exploring this space and it isn’t perfect but I’ve found it quite helpful. There is something special going on in this space.

Some groups:

* Mankind project

* Sacred Sons

I've found friends online since the 90's; IRC first and now Discord.

There are people who I know pretty well, but still have no idea where they live and what their real name is. Couldn't pick them out of a lineup if my life depended on it.