> we take design inspiration from websites like Hacker News, Craigslist, and McMaster Carr
I bet they'd love when2meet.[0] It's a gem for organizing, completely free and zero sign-up required. It's really inspired me to push myself to see how far I could take "no signup required" in any app I work on
> The first 99 paying users are "Founding Grugs."
For any referral you get to sign up for a paid account, we'll pay you 25% of the persons recurring revenue.
"25% of the persons recurring revenue" must be all the referrals of that referral and all the way down.
I don't like it because it introduces difficult to understand incentives that may be different than "make good product" and difficult to understand.
Maybe the most obvious wrong incentive is "make product that is easy to get your friends to start and keep using". A product like that would benefit from network effects and social contagion and no interoperation with other products, and build features correspondingly. (cf Facebook)
> We are a product from a canoe-building company. No joke. We are born out of Kamanu Composites, a local manufacturer in Hawai'i … GrugNotes is a rewrite/spin-out of a DIY ERP software started in 2008.
Cool that this was made as a ERP solution for their manufacturing business FIRST, and now that they’ve refined the idea somewhat, they are making it a white-labeled app. Following in some big footsteps! (Rails, AWS, React etc)
Ha! fairly certain I don't belong in any list with those other things, but thanks! also, what I said was a small stretch. I had one text box for weekly notes on my django app i made to collect my canoe building records and customer data. I did more or less start over from scratch with this. But yes, 1000% of my ideas are from making project websites 2000-2014, and from building canoes for 15 years.
I love the spirit of this. Caveman-level simplicity is awesome! I think I am personally too Grug of an audience for Grug Notes, though; my current note taking scheme is vim on text files in a notes folder.
Jokes aside, I’ve tried what feels like almost everything and outside of taking notes with Code this is what I’m doing. Writing it down in a notebook. Is it flawed? Yes. The time I need to learn the medium is zero however.
I also find (and have heard from others) that the act of writing things down helps you to remember them better (which somewhat obsoletes the note). It also, in my experience, forces your brain to think about them more because it has to externalize them through the slow medium of your hand. It results in surprising new thoughts being generated.
Some people I know follow the system of, if they want to remember it, they write it down. If they don’t want to have to, they type it up.
Caveman simplicity is the best! The “gardening” involved in many PKM apps is what has turned me away from them. I’ve started just throwing my stuff into a Markdown file on GitHub (so I can easily sync across devices). I’ve taken the same ethos to my website on GH pages (steph-inners.github.io) and use it to share knowledge that people commonly ask me about. It’s super easy to update, and Ctrl+F takes care of finding things later.
I do the same, but I have a few bash scripts to handle search, tags, date sorting, git commit/push/pull for sync, and a few other things. Works well for me, but I imagine that others would hate it.
Interesting. This has a lot of features that appeal to me, automatically pulling certain data types with lists of backlinks seems great.
The not local, not end-to-end encrypted parts are enough of a turn off that my wandering in the notes wilderness will continue. Good luck with your project though, I will be watching for further developments.
rad thanks. I wasn't planning any ai features, or datatypes -- but in toying with open ai it came about. I still need to add more inline methods to cast datatypes beyond people, companies, and locations. I'm working on attributes getting pulled out of notes too, so structured data is automatically created -- but not fully fleshed out yet. absolutely understand the need for local and encryption.
kind of a play, but yep I'm just an htmx fan boy. I did web dev growing up -- but haven't exactly kept up past 10 years. htmx has filled that gap for me. Also, the grug thing was a meme before htmx. I thought it was dumb, but honestly fits in every way with what I want in a note app.
maker here. well hot dam, not sure I'm ready for this. But happy to answer any questions if it stays online. Literally I'm the only daily active user right now. back story -- I was a happy roam research user, but i found it too slow for my iphone se. Been at home more with a one year old, so gotten back in to programming during naps.
Always excited to have more options in the PKM space. I have a couple questions — have you tried Obsidian.md? And what does grugnotes plan to use OpenAI for (besides as a development aid)
briefly, but not extensively. I was a roam user for almost 3 years. I actually prefer a simple website for mobile and not having an app. I really dislike tags, and the look of brackets. in fact note taking in general lol. Preference is to type minimal notes, minimal configuration, minimal 'gardening'. The complexity and plugins people get into for note taking seems over the top for me.
Gpt-3 for automatic entity extraction/tagging. Embeddings and Pinecone for similarity searches.
A few more additional thoughts while anyone is looking:
I hope to get a fake demo dataset made soon. It doesn't seem all that useful when you login with nothing there. Similarity search is pretty meaningless until you have things in there. And it's cool to get a sense of how notes can build over time to something useful. As a personal crm, I'm not sure what would be easier.
Also need to make a more detailed video describing use cases, and explaining what the basic data models are.
The last day or so I've been working on more structured data extraction -- as I have more fun doing that than trying to fix a few regex issues on the front end.
fyi, I deployed a bug last night that broke the calendar. Fixed and deployed right now.
Very cool! Love the no-bullshit and concrete, to-the-point explanations. As one who tried a lot of TFT/SB apps, and built them too - I really appreciate the value of simple and focused ones.
Sadly I won't use Grug as offline/onprem is a must for me, but you really set a new benchmark of what a MVP should look like.
Looks like a cool app that could be very useful. Interesting work.
Suggestion:
Record a new demo video with what I am going to call "normal" contrast white background and light elements theme. Your demo is super low contrast and very dark. Hard to watch.
Take cues from the way UI colors work on computers as shipped to the average person. Nobody ships their OS with super dark low contrast everywhere. Just suggesting, if you intend to actually go to market, you might just turn off your average user.
Noted. And not first time hearing that. I’ll add some more contrast customization and a light mode. Demo video was like, how do I explain this to my friends starter video. not ready for hn spotlight.
That 4chan meme picture doesn't make it look very trustworthy to be honest. Especially because the site asks for my data right after that. I'm sure I'm not going to give someone who likes 4chan memes my data.
Yeah, that’s my one hesitation. But proceeding until I come up with something better or have time to polish. Trying to be brutally honest with wall of text on what it is and isn’t. My normal business has always tried to present as having it together. With this, putting up every update I make each night is kinda freeing.
Its.. a.. note taking app? Im not trying to convince you to use it, especially if security of your notes is a concern, but the data being asked of you is pretty much the bare minimum required to provide the described service. Its just weird to take exception to the rare service that authentically obeys a least access model
Move along then friend, it’s a wide internet with plenty of spaces more curated to your tastes. Reddit has lots of subs where 4chan-inspired humor is off limits, I can suggest them if you like. I’m sure when OP chose that name and logo he was worried about wet blankets coming to ruin the fun, well here one is.
If you’re the type to be offended by innocuous 4chan memes, you probably weren’t the target audience to begin with.
Personally, seeing a familiar, endearing meme like that actually brought me some comfort that the author was someone who was also raised online, not a bootcamp grad looking to cash in on a trend.
I think it's a good brand for a note-taking app. Many note-taking apps pitch themselves as the next evolution in your thinking, a tool that will unlock a new level of intellectual productivity. Their meme brand would be galaxy brain. Frankly, a lot of them are terrible because of their galaxy brain attitude, because by overpromising they convince you to invest a lot of time that would be better spent on something with more direct upside. The grug meme tells you that they're trying to buck that trend.
I'm not a big notetaker, so truthfully I probably won't try your app. But out of curiosity I watched your youtube video demo, and I have to say, I really like how the website looks. Simple, pleasant colors (for me anyways, but not sure how that works with accessibility), and easy to find things on the screen.
Lol. No, he vacations in my town and bought a house like 100 yards from a studio I used to rent. I'm confident he'll buy some canoes from me at some point.
I'm not a big note taker at all either. I had a crazy covid, needed to manage a big project and 90 people over a few months. And found roam research invaluable in that process. More recently I got tired of the spinner on mobile so made this. Day to day, I use it to manage myself -- jotting down a few todo items daily. And as a personal crm, ie notes from phone calls and meetings. Basically a homepage to tell myself what to do.
appreciate kind words on the design (a process of tweaking tailwind classes til I'm not grumpy about it). at some point will get to more customization as others have mentioned things being hard to read.
Epic, thanks. Tweet at me or email keizo at grugnotes.com any questions, feedback or thoughts. There are lots of problems, many I’m aware of. But you already pointed out a good one I didn’t know! Will investigate.
Noted. I try to keep the actual notes a little higher contrast. I don’t want any interface hence the low contrast on those things. But obviously what I like not for everyone and I’ll will add more options!
I'd love something with more workflow centred around pruning and reorganizing notes. Often I'm just dumping lots of info into notes which end up not being so useful in the long-run since the signal-noise ratio is too low.
I just really appreciate the candid GTD attitude you guys have.
Having just spent 2 weeks migrating from Notion to Obsidian, investing dozens of hours obsessing over various features that save me <5 minutes/day, your “marketing” style clicks with me.
While I’m not a prospective user (my workflows now require local storage and I’m too pot committed to return to the harmonious simplicity) I’d be keen to play with Grug, break some stuff, and maybe send you referrals when you’re ready.
Any plans to integrate something like Whisper for dictation/transcription?
I don’t plan a whole lot, but whisper looks fun and all other open ai stuff has been smooth to integrate. So sure, that’s a plan! In the mean time, I’ve used apple dictation when driving a couple times.
If the Evernote sale has the dire consequences everyone expects it to, then the note-taking space is wide open. After ten years with Evernote, I migrated to Notion a few months ago and am heading towards another migration unless Notion starts to feel better to me soon. There are a lot of note-taking apps, but no gold standard yet.
Someday someone will produce a polished app with quick search, sync, and navigation, and all the popular features implemented in a way that imposes zero cognitive overhead if you don't use them. Most of the apps seem to be competing to figure out a unique killer feature or a unique experience to distinguish themselves from the pack, but I think the biggest winner will be the one that is just quietly better, a little bit smoother and quicker, that looks like it has no features at all except the ones you need.
That's an incredibly high bar for design and implementation, but somebody is going to hit it eventually. Who knows, maybe it will be Grug Notes!
I have setup Joplin a few weeks ago and I really enjoy using it. AFAIK it is not as powerful as something like Notion or Obsidian, but it just works. And is already miles better than using loose txt files, like I was before.
I'll have to give Joplin another try. Last time I tried it (probably more than a year ago) the sync interval was fixed, and the fastest option was five minutes, which didn't work for the use case of making a note on my laptop, tossing my laptop in my bag, walking out the door, and having the note available on my phone.
The shortest sync interval is still 5 minutes. But I have developed the habit of CTRL+S'ing after each important change. Which is coincidentally the sync shortcut key within Joplin. So for me that isn't really an issue.
But to be fair, I was looking for a 'real-time' webbased app, like Notion. But I wanted it to be self-hosted, use Markdown for formatting, (a little) polished and easy to setup and maintain. And while Joplin isn't perfect, or even fits all of my criteria, it was a close second. Even if it has it's drawbacks.
Wow, thanks for the encouragement! I currently load all notes ever created on the one page. At some point that might not scale, but for now Ctrl f must be fastest search right?? Haha.
105 comments
[ 4.9 ms ] story [ 129 ms ] threadI bet they'd love when2meet.[0] It's a gem for organizing, completely free and zero sign-up required. It's really inspired me to push myself to see how far I could take "no signup required" in any app I work on
[0] https://www.when2meet.com/
> The first 99 paying users are "Founding Grugs." For any referral you get to sign up for a paid account, we'll pay you 25% of the persons recurring revenue.
Oh it's a pyramid scheme
Feels like a shallow growth-hack.
"25% of the persons recurring revenue" must be all the referrals of that referral and all the way down.
I don't like it because it introduces difficult to understand incentives that may be different than "make good product" and difficult to understand.
Maybe the most obvious wrong incentive is "make product that is easy to get your friends to start and keep using". A product like that would benefit from network effects and social contagion and no interoperation with other products, and build features correspondingly. (cf Facebook)
Cool that this was made as a ERP solution for their manufacturing business FIRST, and now that they’ve refined the idea somewhat, they are making it a white-labeled app. Following in some big footsteps! (Rails, AWS, React etc)
note always “on-hand” when need. hehe
Some people I know follow the system of, if they want to remember it, they write it down. If they don’t want to have to, they type it up.
The not local, not end-to-end encrypted parts are enough of a turn off that my wandering in the notes wilderness will continue. Good luck with your project though, I will be watching for further developments.
What else is the act of taking notes for?
Not sure if the riff lands though (same author?)
Edit: “with HTMX (big fans and of grugbraindev -- no relation)” apparently unrelated.
Gpt-3 for automatic entity extraction/tagging. Embeddings and Pinecone for similarity searches.
A few more additional thoughts while anyone is looking:
I hope to get a fake demo dataset made soon. It doesn't seem all that useful when you login with nothing there. Similarity search is pretty meaningless until you have things in there. And it's cool to get a sense of how notes can build over time to something useful. As a personal crm, I'm not sure what would be easier.
Also need to make a more detailed video describing use cases, and explaining what the basic data models are.
The last day or so I've been working on more structured data extraction -- as I have more fun doing that than trying to fix a few regex issues on the front end.
fyi, I deployed a bug last night that broke the calendar. Fixed and deployed right now.
Thanks anyone for looking!
Really inspiring. Let it bloom, and keep it up!
Suggestion:
Record a new demo video with what I am going to call "normal" contrast white background and light elements theme. Your demo is super low contrast and very dark. Hard to watch.
Take cues from the way UI colors work on computers as shipped to the average person. Nobody ships their OS with super dark low contrast everywhere. Just suggesting, if you intend to actually go to market, you might just turn off your average user.
Your concern feels overblown given that.
If you’re the type to be offended by innocuous 4chan memes, you probably weren’t the target audience to begin with.
Personally, seeing a familiar, endearing meme like that actually brought me some comfort that the author was someone who was also raised online, not a bootcamp grad looking to cash in on a trend.
"But you didn't, did you?" --Damien Hirst
Nice!
Oh, and did Barack Obama really call you?
I'm not a big note taker at all either. I had a crazy covid, needed to manage a big project and 90 people over a few months. And found roam research invaluable in that process. More recently I got tired of the spinner on mobile so made this. Day to day, I use it to manage myself -- jotting down a few todo items daily. And as a personal crm, ie notes from phone calls and meetings. Basically a homepage to tell myself what to do.
appreciate kind words on the design (a process of tweaking tailwind classes til I'm not grumpy about it). at some point will get to more customization as others have mentioned things being hard to read.
Note to OP: the sign up process completely brakes the iOS password save thingy :)
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Having just spent 2 weeks migrating from Notion to Obsidian, investing dozens of hours obsessing over various features that save me <5 minutes/day, your “marketing” style clicks with me.
While I’m not a prospective user (my workflows now require local storage and I’m too pot committed to return to the harmonious simplicity) I’d be keen to play with Grug, break some stuff, and maybe send you referrals when you’re ready.
Any plans to integrate something like Whisper for dictation/transcription?
I don’t plan a whole lot, but whisper looks fun and all other open ai stuff has been smooth to integrate. So sure, that’s a plan! In the mean time, I’ve used apple dictation when driving a couple times.
Someday someone will produce a polished app with quick search, sync, and navigation, and all the popular features implemented in a way that imposes zero cognitive overhead if you don't use them. Most of the apps seem to be competing to figure out a unique killer feature or a unique experience to distinguish themselves from the pack, but I think the biggest winner will be the one that is just quietly better, a little bit smoother and quicker, that looks like it has no features at all except the ones you need.
That's an incredibly high bar for design and implementation, but somebody is going to hit it eventually. Who knows, maybe it will be Grug Notes!
But to be fair, I was looking for a 'real-time' webbased app, like Notion. But I wanted it to be self-hosted, use Markdown for formatting, (a little) polished and easy to setup and maintain. And while Joplin isn't perfect, or even fits all of my criteria, it was a close second. Even if it has it's drawbacks.