27 comments

[ 0.23 ms ] story [ 76.8 ms ] thread
Thinking about sword swallowers makes me really proud to be a human. We partake in such idiotic activities that life nearly never becomes boring.

After attending art school for a year, when its magic waned a bit, I lamented that there were not many totally crazy artists at the school I was at. Then someone introduced me to a graduate student who tattooed on himself using a modified sewing machine, and who was indeed also a proficient sword swallower. Life was good again.

This is the shit we're meant to do not worrying about KPIs or building ad delivery networks or whatever.
If all advertisers were fire swallowing carnival barkers people might respect them.
Meant to do? We're apes that have figured out how to build decent shelter and communicate over long distances. There's nothing we're "meant" to do.

Just be grateful you live in a time after the invention of indoors

What a boring attitude. Not everyone equates mere survival with living to the full.
I didn't interpret what they said in this way.

I have yo agree with them that it is hard to say what a species is "meant to do". We have certainly done what we have done, but who is to say that was our purpose? Beyond "successfully produce offspring at a rate to maintain the species" I think it's hard to prescribe an intended purpose.

This is HN. People will take "what we're meant to do" literally and not understand it's not to be taken in a literal evolutionary sense.
That's actually an excellent explanation, now the comment I answered to starts to make sense.
There's a lot we're meant to do. But we decide what we mean to do.
> This is the shit we're meant to do not worrying about KPIs or building ad delivery networks or whatever.

We're not "meant to do" anything, unless this is somehow -- absurdly, and seemingly unlikely -- a simulation. But I can make some suggestions as to what we should be doing.

As far as we can tell, intelligence is rare in the universe. Perhaps that intellect is smart enough to be beyond our means of detection, transcended our physical understanding. Maybe it's afraid of being seen by whatever else lurks out there. Or maybe we're not looking in the right places. Or we're just early. Or it all got wiped out. But whatever the case, intelligence in the universe appears to be exceedingly rare.

If thinking is rare and interesting and important, we should probably be doing whatever it takes to preserve it and expand it.

A lot of people quote Sagan to say we're just motes of dust in an infinite universe. It's a humbling view, but I think it dismisses just how important we are. Life on earth has existed for a third of the age of the universe, and we have no evidence of anything else anywhere at all. That's an incredibly long time to work towards where we are today. It'd be a shame if it were all to vanish. It's the longest-running experiment we know of, and the results thus far show incredible promise.

Something being "interesting" or "important" can only be judged by (somewhat) intelligent beings.

It is unlikely that the rest of the (not intelligent) universe cares anything about us.

Hence, it does not follow that we should preserve life or even intelligence.

However, I think evolution had made us into systems that frantically try to procreate. I consider that a valid enough reason to continue preserving life. But note that the reasoning is different.

Everyone wants to be a crazy artist until someone whips out the modified sewing machine to give matching tattoos.
Reading this, it seems like most people who started sword swallowing were about thirty, with some even in their teens. Again, I'm too late.
I would not be surprised if the statistics are skewed a bit due to survivorship bias. Please do report to your local statistician before you start daily practice!
Too much work. I've got a better idea: I wish that my exercise watch had a Workout option for "Sword Swallowing." Then, I can just start the workout. If my watch sees my heart rate drop to zero for an extended period of time, I would hope it will automatically end the workout so my workout statistics are not corrupted.
I don't think there is an upper limit.
> We excluded cases in which injury was related to swallowing items other than swords, such as glass, neon tubes, spear guns, or jack hammers.

Swallowing Neon tubes and jack hammers seems like a great way to give yourself some permanent damage.

It’s funny how if someone does something physically dangerous and very likely to cause permanent damage to themselves, it’s obvious to everyone it’s not a good idea. But it’s so much harder to identify when we’re doing things that might cause mental harm to ourselves. Like working 12 hour days, or isolating yourself socially, or not going outside for days at a time. All things that can cause lasting damage, but in more subtle ways. And often times people are applauded for doing these things because “that’s what it takes to be a world class founder/engineer/athlete/doctor etc”

I think the reason is because we know the mind can take a lot more punishment than the body. Some people’s minds seem to have nearly infinite capacity for punishment, where a body can perish easily from a bad infection or wound.
Working 12 hour days is not that big a deal on its own…
Could you elaborate? Your statement seems to run against common sense.
I like how at the end the PDF teases another research gem: "You're not going to give me the umbrella, are you?"
Ah the Xmas edition of the BMJ! Full of funny studies and articles treated seriously. The one about common case note abbreviations was the best one and ended up being quite influential.
> The angle of the gastro-oesophageal junction and lesser curve vary, being obtuse in the vertically oriented stomach, particularly when it is full, and more acute in the high horizontal stomach often present in thickset (sic!) individuals

I imagine the "thickset" is meant to be "thickest" instead?

It's a Britishism for stocky with an implication of fat, so probably intended as-is.