Ask HN: Books you read in 2023 and recommend for 2024?

268 points by vanschelven ↗ HN
The year is coming to an end. Time to look back and reflect. What are the books you've read in 2023? Which books made you change your mind or you simply enjoyed? And which books would you recommend to others for 2024?

237 comments

[ 3.0 ms ] story [ 241 ms ] thread
Deadly Times: The 1910 Bombing of the Los Angeles Times and America's Forgotten Decade of Terror, Lew Irwin

River of the Gods: Genius, Courage, and Betrayal in the Search for the Source of the Nile, Candice Millard

The Fleet That Had To Die, Richard Hough

Trapped Under the Sea: One Engineering Marvel, Five Men, and a Disaster Ten Miles Into the Darkness, Neil Swidey

Why We Sleep: Unlocking the Power of Sleep and Dreams by Matthew Walker

All the Light We Cannot See by Anthony Doerr

The Three-Body Problem

Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow by Gabrielle Zevin

Atlas Shrugged by Ayn Rand

> Atlas Shrugged by Ayn Rand

I'd recommend leaving that one in the bathroom in case you run out of toilet paper.

I wish this book wasn't as massive as it is. I'd like to read to see why it's so polarizing, I'm just not that interested lol
It's actually not that long if you skip over the monologues.
It's so polarising because it creates poorly defined ideologues that don't exist in reality. It's a giant straw man. And what is left is held together with bits of sticky tape and string. It's just bad.

In Rand's world, Musk (on a bad day) would be your god, your boss and your parent figure. I can see how it'd go down well with the rabid "I am the centre of the universe and all shall yield" types that seem to fall out of the American academic system into servitude friendly startups that are promoted on here like they are a good thing.

Like I said, toilet paper. Put it next to Mein Kampf and Ready Player Two. Both are as morally and literarily offensive in the same way.

I remember my literature teacher describing it as a romantic fantasy and that helped quite a bit.

It’s not meant to be realistic as it’s Rand’s belief system. It’s like complaining that Plato’s Cave isn’t realistic or something.

It’s nowhere near Mein Kampf and it’s a bit offensive to equate this with Hitler (or Ready Player Two).

It’s funny because people pooping on Ayn Rand is such a cliche. I know it’s not a perfect signal but I’ve never encountered a smart person knee-jerk reacting to any mention of Rand.

Also, this is poor advice as this book is so big and the paper so thin it is absolutely horrible as toilet paper.

You are going to catch a lot of downvotes for Atlas Shrugged unless it is added with irony. It is truly a bad book written by a rather horrible person with dubious morals. I strongly recommend anyone who has progressed beyond their angsty sophomore year of college to give it a pass; just go read Anthem to get a feel for Rand's poorly justified bullshit (and to observe a nice example of 'literature' that can do no better than straw man antagonists) and save yourself several hundred pages of reading.
I somehow took a completely different perspective on objectivism away from this book than most people seem to have, so I’m glad I read it instead of skipping it because of its reputation. It convinced me to start a scholarship at my small town high school.
Atlas shrugged is the kind of book, when read early in life could sweep you under the feet in an influential way and when you revisit it later in life, you know all the bullshit selfish philosophy it contains. When I was dating, one checklist I had was to ask the person's opinion on Atlas Shrugged and hoped it was negative. The story always has dysfuncional family, which is far from reality. The selfishness depicted in Ayn Rand books are just not real.
Paul Murray's The Bee Sting - very engrossing novel about a family in post-crash Ireland.
- Ballou, Brendan. Plunder: Private Equity's Plan to Pillage America.

- Smil, Vaclav. How the World Really Works: The Science Behind How We Got Here and Where We're Going.

- Doucleff, Michaeleen. Hunt, Gather, Parent: What Ancient Cultures Can Teach Us About the Lost Art of Raising Happy, Helpful Little Humans.

Smil's recent "Invention and Innovation" is well worth reading, too. Anything by Smil, really, is excellent food for thought and deeply informative.
Are there any Smil books that are suitable for children?
I mostly read fantasy, but had some personal favorites this year:

The Blacktongue Theif - Christopher Buehlman

Kings of the Wyld * Bloody Rose - Nicholas Eames

Farseer Trilogy - Hobin Hobb

Hey I read all those books this year as well, all great books.

I'd add the Malazan Book of the Fallen series by Steven Erickson to that list, if you like a grittier dark fantasy.

Word of warning: only read Malazan if you have 400+ hours burning a hole in your lifespan. Those books are good, but they are _long_
I saw a lot of recommendations for that series and ordered the first book, but I wasn't able to get through it. There's something about it that makes it very boring to read rather than enjoyable.

Something similar happens with Tad Williams.

I am only on book three, but part of my issue is how much seemingly deus ex machina occurs. The world is alien, deep, and unknowable. At any moment, some previously unidentified entity can twist events on their head.

Big baddie about to destroy town? When all hope is lost, a powerful, benevolent force sprouts from the ground to end the threat.

Science fiction gets “one thing”. People are the same, but now you can backup your conscience onto a chip. How does humanity adapt?

Erickson gets 1000 things that will be revealed the moment you think you know where the plot is headed.

All that being said, it is interesting, layered, and a wild ride.

deus ex machina was a complaint of mine as well, but as you get further into the story you realize how it's actual gods/ascendants/people causing the things that happened. some of those things were put in place thousands of years in the past. he does have several magic systems in the series, but they all have rules and they're followed.
> Something similar happens with Tad Williams.

I totally get where you're coming from here. I adore Erikson, and I enjoy Williams but I sometimes need to force myself to keep reading his works (and then really enjoy them when I do).

However, Bobby Dollar (his shorter trilogy) is exceptionally fun. It's much tighter and funnier, well worth reading maybe especially if you've bounced off his other works.

Farseer Trilogy should really come with a disclaimer to not read if you're depressed or going through a difficult time. The author is very skilled, but that series was analogous to being kicked repeatedly in the balls, given how much the main character goes through.
My brother has coined the term Depression Olympics between this and The Stormlight Archives for what the characters go through and Farseer makes Stormlight look like childsplay
There's like five trilogies in the same world, well worth reading the whole thing. The first is probably the worst in terms of what the characters go through, but the really nice part is how later books build on what happened here.
Psychology of Money, Morgan Housel

Let Your Life Speak, Parker Palmer

The Beginning of Infinity, David Deutsch

A Philosophy of Software Design, John Ousterhout

You might already be aware, but Morgan Housel has recently released a new book titled "Same as Ever: A Guide to What Never Changes."
Chip War by Chris Miller. This is a well researched book on the chip war between the US and China

Why We Sleep by Matthew Walker. I loved this book because I learned so many new things about sleep. It also made me more disciplined about my sleeping habits.

Kilo by Toby Muse. The book is about cocaine trade in Colombia. It is eye-opening and generated intense negative emotions at times.

Tracers in the Dark by Andy Greenberg. I love to read about cybersecurity, hackers, etc. so this book was an amazing read.

I read many more books which I loved but keeping this list short. Many of these books were mentioned in the comments on HN!

Edit: fixed the spelling of Colombia

> Kilo by Toby Muse. The book is about cocaine trade in Columbia

You mean Colombia?

Haha yes, Colombia. That's an embarrassing mistake!
It's a common mistake, especially here in British "Columbia". They're the English and Spanish spelling of the same thing (a reference to the New World).
Read all of those but wanted to chime in that when I was in college the rise of TR inspired me to get my life in order. Not that he was an ideal but it was a lens to see a life that was focused and what he could tackle. Stellar writing.
What he was able to accomplish from a young age was totally inspiring.
The Future is Degrowth: A Guide to a World Beyond Capitalism

Novelist as a Vocation by Murakami

The Milky Way: An Autobiography of Our Galaxy by Moiya McTier

> The Milky Way: An Autobiography of Our Galaxy by Moiya McTier

I started to read that but honestly had to stop on page 2, perhaps the earliest I've ever given up on a book. My initial impression was that it was written for children?

The Brothers Karamazov, FM Dostevsky

Political Religions, Eric Voegelin

The Warden, Anthony Trollope

The Mystery of the Grail, Julius Evola

Vita Nostra because it has an interesting magic system. Piranesi because it also has a weird magic system.

I didn't read it this past year, but the first one that came to mind was Tigana. That book was rather weird for me, because the process of reading it wasn't very enjoyable, but after finishing I loved it.

If anyone has suggestions for fantasy or sci-fi books with weird or non-standard magic systems I'd love to hear em. I've already read most of the big names like Sanderson.

i don't know what is a weird or non-standard magic system (because i don't read much fantasy), but if you like science fiction with magic then i can recommend

Glynn Stewart: Starship's Mage series

Islington’s trilogy that starts with “The Shadow of What was Lost” is very much in Sandersen’s style and does its own thing.
I second the Licanius trilogy! His new series (Hierarchy) is also great!
Outlive: The Science & Art of Longevity - Peter Attia
Some of the books I've read this year that I'd recommend:

The Divine Comedy by Dante - It is hard to underestimate how much it has influenced our culture.

A Distant Mirror - The history of the 14th century, but engaging like a novel.

Name of the Rose - Mystery novel set in Medieval times.

On Lisp by Paul Graham - http://www.paulgraham.com/onlisp.html

Seasoned Schemer - Kind of an interactive book that teaches computer science concepts in an interactive paper based way. Probably best to start with the Little Schemer first.

Curious -- people love those Little Schemer books. I've read SICP back in the day and loved that. I'd be interested in more of your impressions about LS/SS, if you care to share.
SICP is a textbook. The Little Schemer is a tutorial. You sit down with a pen, paper, and the book. Then you cover the answer column in the book, read the question / prompt and try to write an answer on your paper. You compare your results with the books suggested answer and work your way through it question by question.

So it is kind of a way of create a Socratic dialog with a book. I found it to be a great way to engage with the material in a way that promotes understanding in a hands on way, but without putting a computer in the way. When you are writing your answers you have to be more intentional than just, "well lets see if this works."

I randomly stumbled on the Proxima & Ultima duology by Stephen Baxter and they shot up to the top echelon of my favorite books list. Near-future sci-fi, interstellar travel, alternate histories, alien cultures, non-human cognition. Just wonderful stuff to randomly pick off the library shelf because they had a cool sounding name. I actually read the 2nd book first by accident, and thought it worked pretty well in retrospect.

I also liked Eon by Greg Bear (RIP), for actually quite similar reasons.

The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, by Edward Gibbon

edit: lol downvotes?

They hate us because they ain’t us
Been looking for a book on roman empire, thank you for the recommendation.
Surely the moment calls for something closer to: Cur suffragia malores dejiciuntur?
Legends and Lattes is probably my favorite book i've read this year

Set in the DnD universe a adventure retires and sets up a coffee shop in a large city. Except no one knows what coffee is, and her past follows her there.

This is a quick read at around 200 pages, so if you read massive fantasy tomes like I do you'll knock this one out really quickly. Where it shines though is its world building and the sense of community you get from the characters as you make your way through the story. I've been recommending it to my friends and they have all loved it just as much as I did.

Love this book. It's not set in any of the D&D universes as far as I'm aware, though it is very clearly influenced by the fantasy trappings of D&D
If you liked legends and lattes, check out the Cradle series by will wight. Travis Baldtree narrates the audiobooks!
Loved it as well. Big fan of coffee from the gnomes!
The first pages have drawn me in -- thanks! And likewise, if and as it doubtless holds up to further reading, I'll be recommending it to some friends who will rather enjoy it. :-)
End Times: Elites, Counter-Elites, and the Path of Political Disintegration by Peter Turchin. Instead of just bemoaning the current state of politics, Turchin uses a data-informed comparison to previous, similar cycles to see where we're headed.

What if? 2 by Randall Munroe. The physics, biology, and chemistry textbook we should have had in high school.

Different: Gender Through the Eyes of a Primatologist by Frans de Waal. Primatologist with half a century of experience analyzes current gender identity debates from the viewpoint of someone who knows about more than one primate species (not just humans).

"Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow" by Gabrielle Zevin, fantastic writing, touching and insightful

"Tess of the d'Urbervilles" by Thomas Hardy. I'm huge Hardy fan but hadn't read his masterpiece until this year

Halftime: Moving from Success... (this makes sense if you around 40 or over 40)(I read it a few years back and then again this year as a self-follow-up)

Thou Shall Prosper: Ten Commandments for Making Money (it's NOT about making money - I found it more useful on "adding value" more than "making money - it changed my perspective on 'how to work, how to operate, how to see things, how to see/seek/grab opportunities' but ultimately how to add value - _and_ get paid handsomely for it)(ok it is about making money, but as a result, not as a driver) (if you ignore the "too much Judaism" bits, it is a great book)(I read it a few years back and then again this year as a self-follow-up)

If you are a parent, Meg Meeker's - Strong Fathers, Strong Daughters - Strong Mothers, Strong Sons (if you ignore the "too much Christianity" bits, these are great books) I found them to be super useful manuals/cheatsheets to building strong loving and trusting relationships with my kid(s). I used it with/for my daughter and our relationship moved from a cold father-daughter-we-don't-understand-each-other to a thriving friendly loving respecting listening relationship where she ASKS to actually spend time with me. I cannot recommend it enough to any parent that asks me for books(again.. ignoring the "too much Christianity" bits)

(Disclaimer: I don't want to proselytize anyone to either/or/both Judaism, Christianity or any other religion.)(it's just that I found the Prosper and Strong books so useful..)

- Everyday Utopia by Kristen Ghodsee

- The Persuaders by Anand Giridharadas

- No Bosses by Michael Albert

Everyday Utopia was certainly a beautiful read, it is ultimately a book about hope and how we should be experimenting more in our world. The Persuaders had some really good insights into contemporary political persuasion tactics. No Bosses is very provocative in its argument for a change in the fundemantal division of labor in our age.

Also I would recommend the "Monk & Robot" series by Becky Chambers. It takes place in a solar-punk style world that is more character driven and less conflict driven.

How Will You Measure Your Life by Clayton Christensen

https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/13425570-how-will-you-me...

I always feel uneasy with the notion of work-life balance. At the same time I always want more time and attention with my family. Family is part of life, work is part of life, everything you do is part of life. Why the two often appear to be opposing each other? The book offers much counsel on family, parenting and profession. Many of the business examples appeared in the book Innovation Dilemma and a talk at google https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=rHdS_4GsKmg

I'm only halfway through it, but The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich by William Shirer. Absolutely fascinating insight into the political machinations of Nazi Germany.
I re-read the 10 doorstopper long "Malazan Book of the Fallen" high fantasy series by Steven Erikson and enjoyed it just as much as I did originally, slightly over a decade ago. Still my favorite series of all time. This took up a pretty big chunk of the year, so most other books were rather light urban fantasy novels.

But one other mini-series stood out (potentially going to be a trilogy, but both #1 & #2 can stand alone).

Teixcalaan #1 & #2, "A Memory Called Empire" and "A Desolation Called Peace" by Arkady Martine for being very different feeling sci-fi books that are not your typical western-centric fare. Highlights are the language, and that the story feels both very small and contained, and also all-encompassing, at the same time.

A good reminder that I need to finish my Malazan readthrough! The universe is incredibly deep, the characters are incredibly rich, but I do wish Erikson would let us get a little bit comfier in the shoes of each character for longer stretches of time. I sailed through House of Chains so quickly because I didn't have perspective whiplash, but I find it difficult to keep all of the characters in my head during some sections -- battles in particular are a real challenge for me in the Malazan series.

Highly recommend the series, but a warning: if you find yourself bouncing off book one, don't bother with the rest of the series. I find that the later books are slightly better written and slightly better structured, but the core writing style issues are still there (notably, perspective whiplash and a magic system that is so complex that it sometimes feels like deux ex machina).

I read Malazan for the first time this year after putting it off for decades. Loved it and will likely read it again
I reread it every 2 years or so. There's so much in there that you see new things every time.
I've got the whole Malazan series sitting in a box ready to read... alas, I'm pretty bushed by the time I have a moment to read and I'm sharing those precious moments before sleep with D&D prep too. I think I'll be saving it for some future date.
Yeah, it’s certainly a time investment. Back when I originally read it, I was still in university, I remember lying in bed, reading, and my alarm went off telling me to get up …
+1 for the Teixcalaan series
> Teixcalaan #1 & #2, "A Memory Called Empire" and "A Desolation Called Peace" by Arkady Martine for being very different feeling sci-fi books that are not your typical western-centric fare. Highlights are the language, and that the story feels both very small and contained, and also all-encompassing, at the same time.

These were marvellous, well worth reading for any fans of Malazan/other fantasy or sci-fi.

I loved Teixcalaan #1, and I really need to read the second one. Thanks for the reminder!
Differently Morphous by Yahtzee Croshaw. It's cute detective novel set in a fantasy version of modern-day London. It includes a ministry of magic (legally distinct from Harry Potter), Lovecraftian cosmic horror, a hive mind of slime monsters seeking asylum in England, and an outstanding cast of wacky characters. A very light and cosy read, highly recommended.