HN Explorer

53 comments

[ 4.1 ms ] story [ 119 ms ] thread
biofox
I typed all of this out, and I'm still stuck in Vi. Please send help. /s
recursive
Usually, I just restart my computer. So far, it's worked every time.
proaralyst
I love that vi lost this part of the propaganda battle versus Emacs, when Emacs has the unintuitive ^C^X exit sequence. Maybe it also had a file menu?
mouse_
And I did not speak out, for I was a nano user.
IggleSniggle
Now that everyone uses VSCode, who is left to speak for you?
ok_dad
I still use nano! The nice part about it is that it shows the command keys at the bottom. I forget what it is to exit, but I don’t need to remember!
IggleSniggle
As it should be. I miss Windows 95 for stuff like this
rdlw
Nano is very supportive, any time I find myself using it it knows that what I need most is to "Exit" and "Get Help"
[deleted]
(comment deleted)
nequo
^X^C, but yes, Emacs also has a menu by default so you can click your way out of it.
btdmaster
I was a bit confused when you mentioned this, but then I realised the actual sequence is ^X^C. It's because ctrl-X is a sort of metacharacter, and ctrl-C is used for the standard INT signal you know from other programs.

And to be fair, GTK emacs has File->Quit as well (which helpfully reminds you you could use C-x C-c instead!).

lencastre
I have a print of these commands stuck on a pinboard near me. For the 1 or 0 times per year I need to edit some config file on a machine where vi is the only sensible option.
adtac
>vi is the only sensible option

Of course, that's a tautology.

What? It's flamewardnesday.

pavlov
A rite of passage in the pre-Google time: your computer suddenly enters this unfamiliar editor and you have no idea what to do.

(People who love getting hazed and being in cults are then converted into vim users, I guess.)

idontwantthis
Did this used to be real? It’s just :q, or escape first if you aren’t in normal mode. Is this going over my head?
xanderlewis
:q! if you’ve changed something since the last write.
bauble
ZZ if you're musically inclined.
IggleSniggle
ZZ and then afterwards `top` just to make sure you really quit
dfabulich
Most users who struggle with this don't know that vim has modes, and often have found themselves forced into vim accidentally, e.g. having automatically launched vim by running "git commit."

In order to quit vim, you have to understand the difference between normal mode and insert mode, and you have to understand the difference between :q and :q!.

If you :q when you wanted to :q!, you're going to get this useless error message:

    E37: No write since last change (add ! to override)
But if you don't know about :q!, "(add ! to override)" means nothing. Override what? How do I "add !"??

And since you're a total novice, it's likely that you don't even know that you haven't saved your changes to disk yet, so it's not clear to you that "No write since last change" is calling you to :w before :q.

And if you try to explain all that, the user gets pouty. "I just want to quit vim! Why do I have to learn all of this stuff just to stop using it?!?"

treve
Also cq if you want to exit with an exit code, which is useful if Vim was launched to write a Git commit message.
gweinberg
Bad advice. Just :q not :q!

Let it give you the warning and then hit :q! if you're really sure.

Also, it's probably better to tell new vi users to write and exit with :w it works just as well and is more consistent.

red_trumpet
:w only writes, doesn't exit. :wq writes and exits, or :x
silisili
I use :wq always when saving and exiting so I can see and remember exactly what's happening, despite shortcuts existing.

And :q when just exiting as you mentioned for exactly this reason. Tell me I'm quitting without saving so I can decide what to do next.

mstudio
What's wrong with using :q ?
Smaug123
To a novice it appears not to work if you've hit Ctrl+S in your terminal to suspend output, for example. Ctrl+Q to release your terminal, Ctrl+C to return control to Vi if something else has it, Esc to get into normal mode if you're not already there.
mstudio
Thanks for clarifying. I understand this is a bit different, but if folks are using vim, the best resource (in my opinion) for novices is vimtutor. Just type "vimtutor" in the console. It uses an interactive tutorial to explain the basics of editing, saving, moving around — plus the various modes.
[deleted]
(comment deleted)
parentheses
I read this post in a sarcastic voice. Better that way.
tambourine_man
The real question is why would anyone want to leave Vim.

If, by any chance, you've entered it accidentally, acknowledge the fortuitous twist of fate you've just witnessed and enjoy the enlightenment that is soon to follow.

recursive
Perhaps because you want to edit some text?
tambourine_man
Then you came to the right place and “recursive” is the best possible user name for such reply.
stevenAthompson
I used vi once. In fact I still am, because I can't exit.
[deleted]
(comment deleted)
zogrodea
I was hoping this would be about someone who was stuck in/addicted to Vi and wanted to use another editor.
troymc
"Did you try turning your computer off and then back on again?"
not_your_vase
I have found a new "how-to-quit-it" challenge for myself in the past weeks.

I use minicom to communicate with some devices via serial-over-USB - I also tend to suspend my machine while there is still an active connection. When I unsuspend my machine, often my serial connection changes address - and minicom complains that it can't communicate anymore. And here comes the challenge: `ctrl-a q` supposed to quit, but not in this state - it stays unresponsive to all combos I try. I literally smash all keys on my keyboard, and then `ctrl-a q` start working again for some reason.

Maybe `ctrl-smash-everything-78-times` is an easter egg... oh well, I guess I will figure it out one day.

TonyTrapp
My personal "how-to-quit-it" challenge was Windows 8. I tried to approach it from the perspective of someone who has previously used Windows but is not a power user knowing shortcuts like Alt + F4 or Ctrl + Alt + Del. In the first Windows 8 versions, it was not obvious at all how to turn off the computer. The classic start menu was gone. The start menu button had no context menu, as far as I can remember. There was no obvious button in the "new" full-screen start menu. I tried quite a few places, I think in the end it took me close to ten minutes to figure out that I had to click on the user profile picture in the new start menu to reach the shutdown option, or something like that. It really was all but obvious. In later updates they improved it a bit.
noman-land
This happens to me with screen. I end up spamming Ctrl-C and Ctrl-D until something positive happens.
omoikane
I am not sure why the advice starts with "ctrl+q". In insert mode, "ctrl+q" followed by "ctrl+c" will cause the literal ctrl+c character to be inserted, and ":q!" after that won't have the desired effect. Similarly for search mode.

A better suggestion is probably to just hit Esc repeatedly to try to get back to normal mode, and exit via ZZ (save) or ZQ (don't save).

javier_e06
The page reminds me the git revert last commit panic search. Get me out this ultra efficient editor!
gwbas1c
OMG this page was hilarious. What's funnier is that I don't think the author was trying to be funny, I think the author was trying to seed Google searches.

Anyway, sometimes Git is misconfigured and dumps me into vi. (I use Windows.) When this happens, I just open Task Manager and kill the process. Otherwise, I have no need to learn vi, nor do I think vi is a useful skill to learn.

chasil
The variants of the vi editor are found in a vast array of POSIX systems, and knowledge of it is invaluable for these platforms.

There is a well-known tutor file that will teach the basic use of vi. On the RedHat 9 family, this is the manual page:

  $ rpm -ql vim-common | grep tutor | grep man/man1
  /usr/share/man/man1/gvimtutor.1.gz
  /usr/share/man/man1/vimtutor.1.gz
Loading Oracle Linux 9 into the WSL subsystem on Windows will bring in this RPM.

  C:\Users\bofh\>wsl.exe -l -o
  The following is a list of valid distributions that can be installed.
  The default distribution is denoted by '*'.
  Install using 'wsl --install -d <Distro>'.

    NAME                                   FRIENDLY NAME
  * Ubuntu                                 Ubuntu
    Debian                                 Debian GNU/Linux
    kali-linux                             Kali Linux Rolling
    Ubuntu-18.04                           Ubuntu 18.04 LTS
    Ubuntu-20.04                           Ubuntu 20.04 LTS
    Ubuntu-22.04                           Ubuntu 22.04 LTS
    OracleLinux_7_9                        Oracle Linux 7.9
    OracleLinux_8_7                        Oracle Linux 8.7
    OracleLinux_9_1                        Oracle Linux 9.1
    openSUSE-Leap-15.5                     openSUSE Leap 15.5
    SUSE-Linux-Enterprise-Server-15-SP4    SUSE Linux Enterprise Server 15 SP4
    SUSE-Linux-Enterprise-15-SP5           SUSE Linux Enterprise 15 SP5
    openSUSE-Tumbleweed                    openSUSE Tumbleweed
quickslowdown
Since we're here talking about Vim, hope everyone doesn't mind me asking this question!

This is specifically about neovim, but I've run into the same issue with regular Vim too. I want to install and use packages like NERDTree and maybe an LSP. I do not want to have to install Node for these plugins. If I want to add plugins to neovim, is it pretty much a given I also have to maintain a Node install?

karmakaze
I end up stuck forgetting how to get out of nano more than vi(m).

Someone should make a safe "get out of any editor" sequence. Kind of like those universal remotes that send all the codes for each button.