I think my son might be a bit gifted, his current school "thinks he's stupid."

2 points by _yaaq ↗ HN
The other day my son said to his nanny, “people will think I’m stupid when I do bad things.” I read this and thought to myself what a terribly sad thing to hear a child say! They know they’re doing “bad things” or not normal things but they also know that they’re smart! This also says to be that my son knows there are reasons why he does “bad things” without fully understanding why he does them. But then again, he knows he is smart! Unlike the teachers around him who think that he is stupid or even bad. The other day the SENCO told me my son is “impulsive” and I’ve never once thought that about him. He stims, yes. He has difficulty with loud noises, yes. This was is the context of “transitions.”

I don’t think my son reads the books in class because they are too easy - he reads airline magazines and train books targeted at adults. His memory is incredible (he’s practically memorized the London Underground map and I think most National Rail routes as well). I asked him the other day “do you think you’re smarter than everyone in your class?” Before I even finished the question he said, “Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.” The trouble is, he’s not good at homework! And he’s been very reluctant to learn. He says things like “I know everything” and I’m trying to encourage him not to zone out if someone starts saying something, he could possibly have ADD/ADHD also. I’m also trying to teach him the difference between being smart or intelligent and “being good at school” and getting good grades.

My son has shown a proclivity for maths. And he has a fair bit of trauma to overcome after a transfer of residence. He’s also quite tall for his age, in the top 1-2%, so I’d love to encourage him to pursue sport as well. But really, more than anything, I want for him where he is given the benefit of the doubt and feels understood. Right now, he’s supposed to have dedicated 1-to-1 support trained in working with children on the autism spectrum, but it seems he gets a wide range of support staff from quite good to clueless.

My son recently told me that at his last school, where he got his autism diagnosis during the pandemic and the school had no 1-to-1 support, a teacher (he told me by name) “locked him in jail for a whole day.” By which I assume he means they did not have the support staff and he must’ve been “misbehaving” and so they locked him in a closet or bathroom from the sound of it (I’ve not yet filed a formal complaint but at least intend to fill out something online).

The current school is much better but far from ideal. I’m quite sure I’m an adult on the spectrum, never officially diagnosed, and so seeing my son go through this is a bit heartbreaking.

It is a silly example, but I really enjoyed the movie The Accountant because of how it highlighted the fact that there are different types of intelligence. And yet I don’t think I’d want my son to be in a home away from the world, I want him to be socializing with children his own age and acclimating to society and “being normal” as much as possible (having friends, getting involved).

I know ABA Therapy is scientifically proven to help the treatment of an ASC diagnosis, and to help children achieve true independence, with 40/hours a week being recommended, but I cannot afford the ABA care in the UK (45k-120k per year) whereas, on the right insurance plan, this might be 100% covered by insurance in the USA. I’m reeling, because I feel like I’m yelling into the void trying to help my son. And I worry every day that goes by that I don’t do more for him is his future potential being further reduced.

My son is slated to be in the same school for year 3 next year, which will be good for stability and routine. But in year 4 and beyond I would love to find an environment where school staff understand neurodivergence and no one on school staff thinks that “stimming” or overexcitement =“stupid.”

4 comments

[ 3.5 ms ] story [ 16.2 ms ] thread
Stop medicalizing normal childhood behavior. “Neurodivergent” assumes some norm to diverge from, but that norm doesn’t exist except as a statistical artifact.

Seriously, we all find our children amazing and full of surprises. That happens because parents have a small (or zero) sample size of raising children, and have a hard time accepting that their child has a personality and desires and talents distinct from their own.

School offers a toxic and constricting environment. Consider homeschooling. If you can humblebrag about having a nanny you can homeschool.

“If you can humblebrag about having a nanny you can homeschool.”

Just as aside, and whilst I suspect that is not the case here, as a child growing up in the 1970s I’d call all 3 of my grandmothers (1 via divorce & remarriage) “Nanny”.

I also fully agree with your comment about the use of Neurodivergence. It does seem to be a popular word to today that parents seem to throw around to describe dumb crap like why little Timmy was suspended from school for graffiti written on the school sign.

Its ok for kids to suck in school, we need people who do the trades or work with their hands and schools are not set up to make those kids do well.

Also maybe raise your kid instead of pawning it off on a nanny and nagging about how much everything cost.

I was also one of the "gifted kids" who struggled in school. We're common enough to have our own subreddit [1].

I learn a lot better when I'm my own teacher. I tried going back to college recently and dropped out because it felt like they just weren't teaching anything. I got bored and started failing the classes because it was just too mind-numbing to continue. I started taking the exact same subjects through free online courses (MOOCs) and instantly started doing better.

Personally I think school is nothing but a factory that churns out diligent worker-drones for the capital-owning class to use as machinery.

- [1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/giftedkids/