HN Explorer

12 comments

[ 2.5 ms ] story [ 39.6 ms ] thread
o11c
(If the author is reading this: bad formatting for fin: and acknumdiff: )

Once again a discussion that covers RST injection attacks fails to consider the one case I actually saw in the wild ...

My observation involved long-lived (much longer than typical for HTTP) TCP connections with low-but-nonzero traffic (there was an application-layer heartbeat). For at least some US residential IPs (some with effectively static allocation) connected to a datacenter, they would reliably get RST injected (to the client only, not the server) after being connected long enough (usually a couple hours, but not any obvious pattern).

patrakov
Is the server on OVH? This is a known "feature" of their DoS protection that cannot be turned off.
supriyo-biswas
In my very populous country, the largest ISP will inject resets if it's over IPv4 and idle for more than 10 seconds :)

These things are unfortunately rather common. This is also why I run SSH with a 5 second heartbeat duration, for example.

accrual
Maybe a fun idea - run an application on both sides of a remote TCP connection that records but doesn't respond to TCP RST packets. Then see how many times you get "reset".
geocar
You can just drop RST packets.

    iptables -I INPUT -p tcp --tcp-flags ALL RST,ACK -j DROP
    iptables -I INPUT -p tcp --tcp-flags ALL RST -j DROP
o11c
That looks like exactly what I did, but it was a pain trying to get random users to do run code as root.
[deleted]
(comment deleted)
pornel
They've given out a bot identification signal. Now botters are going to deliberately cancel 6% of their TCP connections ;)