14 comments

[ 4.0 ms ] story [ 46.9 ms ] thread
What am I missing, what is the significance of this post? I did learn that it was code named "Project Banana".
That KDE are making their own first party distribution to showcase KDE, as well as making the DE.
When you appear to be copying another KDE project (Neon), it would be helpful to explain why.
> Prior art

> KDE neon, KDE's first version of a self-made OS. KDE neon fulfills the "distributed by KDE" requirement, but fails on the reliability angle due to the Ubuntu LTS base that ironically becomes unstable because it needs to be tinkered with to get Plasma to build on it, breaking the LTS promise

From the bottom of the linked page:

"Prior art: KDE neon, KDE's first version of a self-made OS. KDE neon fulfills the "distributed by KDE" requirement, but fails on the reliability angle due to the Ubuntu LTS base that ironically becomes unstable because it needs to be tinkered with to get Plasma to build on it, breaking the LTS promise."

(comment deleted)
I wish them luck.

My experience with KDE is limited to the early 200Xs, when it was one of the desktop options that came with Red Hat Linux. "This is great, everything works together, Konqueror is so much better than every other web browser" I recall thinking. It seemed like they had it all figured out already and I didn't understand why everything kept being reinvented, badly, for Gnome or whatever.

> Base OS is Arch-based

Considering they're aiming for reliability I would've liked if they'd built on a truly reliable atomic distro base.

https://getaurora.dev has been so damn good, but despite being a Plasma distro it still packs a lot of GTK apps from Bazzite for basic functionality.

Arch was likely chosen because arch-based SteamOS has already pulled it off (immutable system including KDE).

Lets them waste less effort reinventing the wheel.

Is Aurora more stable than Fedora Kinoite?
The Aurora image includes some necessities. The Aurora NVIDIA image includes drivers and should just work. You can theoretically also rebase to another version, such as Bazzite, with a different desktop environment.
You know, I am way past the submit date on this, but I just discovered KDE Connect today. I'm using it to share stuff between iOS and my non-KDE desktop, and I had to plug it. It's wonderful!

That is all!