14 comments

[ 6.2 ms ] story [ 47.9 ms ] thread
Sabine Hossenfelder's video on this: https://youtu.be/mxWJJl44UEQ
In my perception Sabine’s quality degraded over the last year or so.

Maybe it’s also the topics she covers. I’m not sure why she is getting into fantasies of AGI for example.

I liked the skeptical version of her better.

So where and how does a jump from nice symmetric reversible equations to turbulent irreversibility happen?
I've been puzzling about this as well. The best answer I have (as an interested maths geek, not a physicist, caveat lector) is that it sneaks in under the assumption of "molecular chaos", i.e. that interactions of particles are statistically independent of any of their prior interactions. That basically defines an arrow of time right from the get-go, since "prior" is just a choice of direction. It also means that the underlying dynamics is not strictly speaking Newtonian any more (statistically, anyway).
Strictly speaking, naturally on its own, it doesn't. Detailed equations remain reversible. Even for very big N, typical isolated classical mechanical systems are reversible. However, typical initial conditions imply transitions to equilibrium, or very long stay in it. The reversed process (ending in Poincare return) will happen eventually, but the time is so incredibly long, it can't be verified.
This has been known for a long time: the irreversibility comes from the assumption that the velocities of particles colliding are uncorrelated, or equivalently, that particles loose the "memory" of their complete trajectory between one collision and another. It's called the molecular chaos hypothesis.

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molecular_chaos

Can someone explain what's groundbreaking about this? Maybe it's not done so very rigorously, but pretty much every plasma physics textbook will contain a derivation of Boltzmann equation, including some form of collisional operator, starting from Liouville's theorem[1] and then derive a system of fluid equations [2] by computing the moments of Boltzmann equation.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liouville%27s_theorem_(Hamilto...

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBGKY_hierarchy