48 comments

[ 2.6 ms ] story [ 66.1 ms ] thread
I used peltier coolers on K6 processors 1M computer years ago. They worked great and lasted about as long as the PCs did.

Not long after I bought mine, they disappeared from cooler offerings. I've wondered what became of the tech.

Did they solve the inefficiency problem of peltiers?
> In the Bespoke AI Hybrid Refrigerator Samsung launched in 2024, the compressor operates under normal conditions such as routine storage and retrieval, while the Peltier device activates alongside the compressor during high-load situations — like when storing large amounts of groceries or placing hot food inside — thereby enhancing both cooling performance and energy efficiency

I'd choose a fridge with a larger compressor.

AI has literally nothing to do with this. Why do they feel the need to sprinkle the phrase everywhere? AI inverter/compressor? Come on, have some sense of shame, please.
Actually AI has a lot to do with material design. I can't do a proper explanation, so please bear with this information dump:

- We don't have a strong physical theory for solid state physics. Quantum stuff doesn't scale well from 1 atom to a mole of atoms, because 10^23 goes into the exponent of number of energy levels in the system, and then we also have to model interaction of those levels.

- Physical properties of materials depend on their crystal structure, unevenness of that structure, spectrum of size of crystals, temperature, pressure, fields they're exposed to and current position of stars in the sky. Even the "wrong" solid state physics equations we have are highly non-linear.

- State-of-the-art effects are usually achieved with combinations of such materials.

- Exact parameters of the process used to put those materials together radically change the behavior of the system. Put that nanolayer with a different sort of vapor deposition or at different pressure, and the thing will stop working. Ever wondered why we don't produce all the neodymium magnets at N55 grade? Because even precise description of the process is not enough.

- AI doesn't care about the exact physics, but is sometimes very good at navigating in the large parameter space.

- Google have recently made AI that predicted thousands of novel material structures. They found more materials than were found by all human research over the whole humankind history.

I wouldn't expect AI to explain what's going on in solid-state physics anytime soon, but exploring crystal structures, doping, and process parameters automatically might actually get us new materials a couple hundred years faster.

Maybe it’s hooked in to ChatGPT

“You are a refrigerator, examine this photo of the temperature reading and decide (y/n) if the compressor should turn on”

The head of the board of a company I work with, who uses ChatGPT to get information on how to prune his plants and barely knows how to use Windows Explorer, decided that the whole company needs to go full AI. Everything has to be AI, and everyone has to learn AI. I thought that HN has been overdoing it with AI articles recently, but parts of the outside world seem to be much, much worse.
I thought Peltiers can't lower the temperature by more than 40 degrees F, in practice less than that. This is not cold enough for a refrigerator on a warm day.
But why? Cooling has been a solved problem for literally over a century. No Peltier cooler will ever even come close to normal refrigerant-based coolers in efficiency, both in cost and power consumed.
Are you implying that "normal refrigerant-based coolers" are somehow always the most appropriate solution for any cooling task?
What I want is a silent refrigerator, will this bring that? pray
My wine fridge uses Peltier and is super quiet. It's the perfect application for this because wine doesn't need to be as cold as a normal fridge, and noise is a consideration.

It's not completely silent though, there's a small PC-like fan but it's way less loud than a compressor.

They already exist! Well, small ones.

A hotel I was staying at had a small bar fridge that used a Peltier. I only know because it stopped working so I checked it and realized it was only a Peltier plus a heat exchanged (a cyclopropane loop).

I presume a full size fridge is outside of reach at this point.

Peltier modules have no moving parts, so they're inherently silent
Simplest solution would be to have a compressor that is only active e.g. during the day (when the user is not at home).
I worked on a scientific instrument a while ago, it had a Peltier heater on it to raise the sample to 60c from whatever residual environment temp was (approx. 20c in a lab). It was pretty amazing to see my old overclocking cooling solution come back around and be used in my professional career some 20+ years later
For those worried about tiny COPs from these gizmos, trawling through the actual paper -- as well as the PR from JHU APL -- in this HN post [1] shows claims of COPs of ~15 for Delta Ts of 1.3°C.

A compressor based cooler gets a COP of about 4 in the real world. I'm pretty sure this is an apples to oranges comparison to an expert (I am not one of those) but a factor of 3+ increase in COP is fairly noteworthy -- if it holds up.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44424087

COP of peltier elements can be large only when the temperature difference is small, such as the measly 1.3 degrees you quoted. When do you want to cool something by only 1.3°C compared to the surrounding temperature?
(comment deleted)
The most impressive thing about this article is that they somehow managed to shoehorn AI in a fridge.
AI compressor.

It's full on clown world.

Killed an AMD K6 with my diy peltier cooler when I was 14 good times.
A lot of people consider them gimmicks but the newer gen neck “air conditioners” do actually cool the air and exhaust the hot air so the peltier works. Would love to see it improved for more cooling capacity (and more airflow).
The Johns Hopkins press release is much better

https://www.jhuapl.edu/news/news-releases/250521-apl-thermoe...

Oh nifty. These can also be used to generate electricity from body heat. Or presumably any waste heat.
can this be applied to create devices that maintain a temperature range? ie more than x AND less than y? that’s often needed for medications…
Definitely worse article

I don't understand how they could quote him saying: “This thin-film technology has the potential to grow from powering small-scale refrigeration systems to supporting large building HVAC applications, similar to the way lithium-ion batteries have been scaled to power devices as small as mobile phones and as large as electric vehicles,”

Then the entire article foregoes comparing their peltier device to traditional compressor based heat pumps.

(comment deleted)
being colorblind, specifically deuteranomaly, it worked, but i do not see the blue green, i see the weird off green i normally do and then basically brown. i would imagine complete red-green would actually impact it
Sounds like they’re using much thinner and thus more efficient bonding on each end of the Peltier device?

75% gains off that seems impressive. Must be something really fancy - thinking of a heat sink just using better therm paste barely moves the needle

> Bespoke AI Hybrid Refrigerator

Come the fuck on.

Seriously. When I see this kind of absurdity, I think of Humpty Dumpty in Through The Looking Glass:

> 'When _I_ use a word,' Humpty Dumpty said in rather a scornful tone, 'it means just what I choose it to mean--neither more nor less.'

> 'The question is,' said Alice, 'whether you CAN make words mean so many different things.'

> 'The question is,' said Humpty Dumpty, 'which is to be master-- that's all.'

> Alice was too much puzzled to say anything, so after a minute Humpty Dumpty began again. 'They've a temper, some of them-- particularly verbs, they're the proudest--adjectives you can do anything with, but not verbs--however, _I_ can manage the whole lot of them! Impenetrability! That's what _I_ say!'

> 'Would you tell me, please,' said Alice 'what that means?'

> 'Now you talk like a reasonable child,' said Humpty Dumpty, looking very much pleased. 'I meant by "impenetrability" that we've had enough of that subject, and it would be just as well if you'd mention what you mean to do next, as I suppose you don't mean to stop here all the rest of your life.'

> 'That's a great deal to make one word mean,' Alice said in a thoughtful tone.

I wonder if this will eventually lead to battery temperature conditioning on cell phones and laptops similar to electric cars.
I wish they had gone into detail about what makes this device different from Peltier coolers that are available today. You can already get mini fridges that use them, but they're not very good - the total amount of cooling you can get from them is not enough to maintain the temperatures that a regular refrigerator does.
This article uses the term AI 5 times to talk about basic microcontroller sensor readings.
So PID controllers are AI now? Cool!
Can peltier devices stack?
So this is basically a one-way heat transfer film?

Can it be made multi-layer?

And can two plys be glued back to back so both are trying to transfer heat from center outwards and act as an insulator?