Core77 is so broken for me. I can hardly load half an article before it bricks my tab on Firefox for Android. Really disappointing, it was one of my favorite feeds for boredscrolling.
Is there a fundamental reason why a "perfect mechanism" like this sounds just like a "perfect string" = midi guitar instrument = harmonic sequence of a vibrating string? Does it mean that human fingers are responsible for the remaining harmonics that we associate with the "guitar sound" on top of the "theoretical guitar tembre".
I've been learning guitar for a couple of years (being already an experienced pianist), and it was very surprising to me how many different techniques need to be mastered to play guitar. I never got to the level on piano where the precise way I hit the keys mattered (apart from soft or loud). On a guitar how precisely you hold and move your fingers makes a massive difference. Hammer-on, pull-off, bends, slides, barring and holding down multiple strings with one finger, are all different techniques. Then there's exactly where you hold the finger in relation to the fret which can really change the sound (or in my case, be completely wrong). On your right hand, there's how you pick or strum, even whether you use a plectrum, the pads of your fingers, or your nails.
- The material of the robot's "finger" makes for a very clanky sound (metal?). Actually it sounds kinda like a harpsichord
- The perfect rhythm makes for a very robotic feel
- The perfect consistency of how a string is plucked (same attack/volume at every note) also makes for a very robotic feel
The first is about harmonics, the second two not so much, but I'd expect that harmonics are the lesser of what makes it feel midi-ey. After all, some people play with metal picks or fingerpicks (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fingerpick).
10 comments
[ 1.5 ms ] story [ 30.8 ms ] threadC'est la vie.
- The material of the robot's "finger" makes for a very clanky sound (metal?). Actually it sounds kinda like a harpsichord - The perfect rhythm makes for a very robotic feel - The perfect consistency of how a string is plucked (same attack/volume at every note) also makes for a very robotic feel
The first is about harmonics, the second two not so much, but I'd expect that harmonics are the lesser of what makes it feel midi-ey. After all, some people play with metal picks or fingerpicks (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fingerpick).
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n_6JTLh5P6E
Replicate actuators across the fretboard; don't have anything sliding. No bulky box. A production version could be made more compact.