40 comments

[ 4.7 ms ] story [ 50.9 ms ] thread
so how do you get a privately owned train car and get it to the tracks or etc?

from this page it sounds like you own it but Amtrak keeps it parked at their switching stations or something

Riding in the family rail car like it’s 1895 (and you’re a robber baron)
I've found nowhere that any price is mentioned, so I have to assume that it's one of those "if you have to ask..." sort of things.

Edit: https://www.amtrak.com/content/dam/projects/dotcom/english/p...

Slightly less than $5 a mile with a minimum of $2296. The rate to park your car is around $4000 a month. Fun thing to do if you have the money.

If you're wondering the most obvious thing:

- Cost per mile: $4.72

- Minimum charge: $2296

There are also a huge number of other fees that I can't tell if you'd need to pay in practice, e.g.:

- Additional Locomotive Fee (per loco mile): $7.54

- Amtrak Locomotive Daily Charge: $2513

- Head End Power Daily Charge: $3433

- Annual Administrative Fee: $574

https://www.amtrak.com/content/dam/projects/dotcom/english/p...

Head End Power (HEP) is the electrical power supplied from the locomotive to the passenger cars for lighting, heating, air conditioning and other amenities - essentially the "hotel load" that keeps your private car functioning while attached to the train.
The US feels more and more like a playground for rich peope. Insert ‘always has been’ meme

Affordable public transport for the peasants though? lmao no

This better than every wealthy person owning an RV. Though there is still the last mile problem. Does my personal train car have a vehicle on board (probably I’m rich in this scenario)?

Groups of wealthy people could split a train car. Private Train-car time shares?

Unless you’re transporting something like the president‘s personal limo, the beast you just rent what you need at your destination.

When you get to the “pay someone to drive the car to where you need to be so that you can use it” amounts of money things become much easier.

My wife loves the train (hates driving) and so this would be quite interesting to us. But I've heard too many Amtrak horror stories, like the one about how the train broke down about ten miles away from her destination, and they wouldn't let her get off, so she had to sit there for ten hours until they were able to fix it.
There’s an episode of Archer where Cheryl Tunt, the company secretary, does exactly this on a trip from New York to somewhere in Canada. Their agency was extraditing a Nova Scotian separatist.
China has more than 550 cities with high speed rail lines spanning over 40,000km. each with first class, toilets, and meal services.

Or...you can buy an entire rail car, hitch it to the haggard burro that is Amtrak and chug along at pony express speeds across the United States of nothingness until freight rail causes you to have to stop for 3 hours at a time as you do not have right of way.

Enjoy Batesland Nebraska at 20mph slower than the interstates posted speed limit.

who at Amtrak thought this was worth even mentioning?

> across the United States of nothingness

This is churlish to the point of complete foolishness. Amtrak has a scenic view car for a reason. There is almost no stretch of the track outside of cities that fails to be a completely beautiful and picturesque portrait of our amazing country.

If you haven't tried it then you might not know. I feel bad that you haven't had this experience personally.

> causes you to have to stop for 3 hours at a time as you do not have right of way.

It's about 15 minutes and may happen once or twice a day. The longest delay I experienced was because the locomotive had a mechanical issue. That took one hour.

> who at Amtrak thought this was worth even mentioning?

What kind of person without the relevant experience would even endeavor to offer this comment?

Amtrak almost always has right of way but loses it practically, with freight trains that ignore or are too long for the sidings
Having ridden every class of ticket in China's rail system, there is a special place in my heart for all of those experiences.

I am sure a private railcar hitched to the Haggard Amtrak Burro is a special experience, too, particularly when your party is the only party for the staff to wait on.

I agree with your point on delays caused by freight rail and Amtrak speeds in general. But I think the bit about Nebraska is too negative. People love road trips in their cars and train trips for the same reason - it’s fun looking out your window and seeing things. If you open yourself to it, there is so much to appreciate about the parts of countries that are less visited.
I saw this car on Chicago Metra's UPN line: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Car_553

I was reverse commuting at the time and wondered what the hell the car was as it looked different than all the other modern cars. I imagine in its heyday it was probably a decent party back up to the North Shore.

One of the places people with these cars visit is Yellowstone, and I've talked to a few of them at the local burger stand (closest food to the railroad siding where they "park"). Interesting people, and less pretentious than I expected for private train owners. I suppose a train is cheaper than a private plane.
Only in the US could the most collectivistic and efficient mode of transport be perverted into yet another incredibly inefficient and individualistic toy for the wealthy. I can't seem to find anything like that anywhere else.
How about airship tours? Not massively different to a train car in terms of pace, but with much more space and good line of sight for sightseeing and internet connectivity.
There is nothing more saddening than the state of America’s train situation. It’s like we’re fundamentally incapable of understanding the value of shared infrastructure.

In the rare case that a state escapes the matrix and actually realizes the benefit, we can’t get the damn thing built.

I want a packed bullet train, not a fucking slow private train car.

(comment deleted)
Characteristic of the time. Anything that benefits some fraction of the population that isn't wealthy is woke and is thus doubleplusungood. Thusly, organizations are forced to derive their revenue from catering to the small fraction of wealthy folks who derive more and more from everyone else.
How does it work if you want a steam train?
I recently took a trip from Chicago to LA and saw some folks doing just this! They had a restored Pullman sleeping car and a kitchen/bar car behind it with crystal chandeliers. Maybe the single most luxurious way to travel. Every stop people would get out and gawk at their cars.
“attached to our trains between specified locations”

What are they?

It feels like there’s some kind of Party Train opportunity here, similar to a party bus.