21 comments

[ 2.3 ms ] story [ 49.4 ms ] thread
If your OEM can be coerced into pushing a backdoor in an OTA update, maybe our software habits are to blame.

We'll always be powerless to stop top-down attacks like this until we demand real audits and accountability in the devices we own. Shaming the UK only kicks the can down the road and further highlights the danger of trusting a black box to remain secure.

As someone who lives in the UK, I hope Apple tell the government where to shove their requests, and that they don't bow down like they did in China. I would prefer a company withdraws from the UK than listens to these over reaching requests of a power hungry government.
They don’t need to. All of the photos and iMessages are stored in iCloud without e2ee (nobody has ADP turned on, and it’s blocked in the UK anyway) and Apple provides the data to the Five Eyes without a warrant.

This is already the status quo in the US. The fact that ADP is offered as an option is irrelevant.

The article states that apple removed the feature in the UK. So what are the UK government demanding access to?
What is happening in the UK really?. I see numerous clips of the desperate state of many parts of various cities. It seems the country is in a steep decline. The once mighty UK sailing the world now became an island of elitists and many more poor low class folks. Sad reality
What, so JD Vance was right ?!
Aren't the English already forced to give cops their phone passwords and face jail time if they refuse to?

Giving away Apple's encrypted cloud is just another small step into making 1984 a reality.

In France, they tried to make a law to force signals, WhatsApp, and other encrypted messaging to implement backdoors so that they could catch drug dealers.

Thankfully, it wasn't voted for, but truthfully, the average people didn't give a shit. I wish there was a way to make people learn how important privacy is to freedom and, therefore, to democracy.

I blame the education system that teaches almost nothing relevant. We even had 'citizen lessons', but it was about learning how the political institution works. We never spoke about what is freedom, what it involves, how easy it is to lose it, how hard it is to gain it.

The most important thing about this, and other similar overreach, is that there is no democratic constituency for this. It's a waste of time, almost a distraction, picking at the rationality of these constant attacks. The important thing is to find out exactly who they are doing it for.

Who asked for it? Let them speak up, and explain why they are so special that governments should and do obey them. Starmer doesn't personally care about any of this (or anything.) No Labour MP cares about any of this. Who is convincing them to override democracy to create tools that make it easier to override democracy? Force them to drop the pretense that they have come up with this themselves, and that they personally believe that it is important.

Start by finding out who the hands were who wrote the actual text. The MPs themselves, and the network of important nephews and nieces that work on their respective staffs are too stupid to write this stuff. Who are the minds that are crafting law for supposed democracies from whole cloth?

Of course they care about it in the sense that they care about maintaining law and order which forms the foundation of their power. Everyone knows the emperor has no clothes when it comes to "think of the children" bills. It's a fig leaf over their power grab. Everyone also knows that this will ultimately be used to crack down on dissidents, criminals, and other undesirables (likely immigrants as well) and that is where you'll find the democratic constituency for this overreach:

Authoritarians generally and right-wing populists in particular are the major proponents of government surveillance and control.

If they succeed, we'll probably never know.
What is a “UK user?” Someone with their App Store region set to the UK? (Meaning they have a UK payment method.)

What about US citizens living in the UK? Would they have standing to sue Apple in a US court for breach of contract?

I’m also not clear on how Advanced Data Protection could be turned off without affirmative user consent – by definition, won’t the user need to provide their secret key to decrypt their existing data? Or will the iPhone have a multi-hour update where it decrypts its entire iCloud archive on the client-side, and then reuploads it without encryption?

Everyone is so preoccupied with losing their minds every time Trump trolls the media with some new nonsense on the socials that they're ignoring the completely insane things going on in the UK right now. Like arresting people for using naughty language online.

20 years ago this would have been daily outrage on Slashdot's YRO section but I get the feeling no one cares enough anymore.

The reason this is a story again is because the reporting the last time was piss poor. The UK only agreed to drop the request for access to data for all users regardless of their nationality after pressure for the USG. They never said they were going to back down from the request for UK user data.
The UK has gone full thought control. They have also gone full immigration.

Going to be a very different place in 10 years.

Probably Farage in 3 years and back the other way.
Sorry, I'm not an Apple user, so I'm not 100% sure if this is about forcing Apple to avoid/break E2E encryption (E2E in the true sense like Proton Mail) in the UK or to give them the keys they already can obtain themselves?
(comment deleted)
For all that matters, Apple may be already sharing "encrypted" data with governments and law enforcement. It's a locked down device running closed source software, and it's impossible to know what it really does behind the user's back.
The right to privacy is one of the basic human rights. How can they even think about restricting it? Why aren't there more protests already? Once it is fully implemented, there will be no way back and no more protests will be possible.