21 comments

[ 1.8 ms ] story [ 41.8 ms ] thread
It's pretty cool to see competition from SpaceX ramping up. I didn't know that OneWeb already has 652 satellites in operation.
I haven't seen a cookie dialog that toxic in a while...
That's a pretty damn editorialized title[0] given that Tusass signed an extended deal with their original provider. To me the chosen title implies that Tusass had chosen Starlink and then decided to stop using them. Starlink did submit a tender offer, but losing to an established competitor isn't super newsworthy.

0: No shade thrown at the submitter, as this is the title used by the site.

Is the read-between-the-lines part here that Elon / SpaceX is too aligned with the USA government and their aspirations to take over Greenland to be trusted with their comms infra?
> Tusass had also been in talks with Starlink, owned by Elon Musk, but chose to continue working with Eutelsat.

"Ditches" sounds like they were already using Starlink, but abandoned it in favor of Eutelsat's system. The text clarifies that they only decided to (continue to) use Eutelsat, and Starlink was just another option considered.

> Binzer said it was not about which company was better, but about trust and long-term cooperation.

Well, who can blame them? After Trump repeatedly expressed "interest" in owning Greenland (fortunately he seems to have moved on to other pet projects in the meantime), and with Musk being one of Trump's closest allies, it would be a bit naive to trust Starlink...

The modern news website: 15 sentences, 6 Shutterstock photos, 35 ads
Why does there need to be a 'state solution' when there is an affordable retail solution that individuals/families/groups can just purchase themselves?

Answer: Because of corruption! It's illegal to use Starlink in Greenland, and Tusass holds a concessioned monopoly over “telecommunications services in, to and from Greenland” and the underlying infrastructure! https://www.aqutsisut.gl/en/tele/satellite-regulation

Tusass was in talks with Starlink to basically provide Starlink service but via the Tusass monopoly, basically making Tusass a no-value-added reseller of Starlink at massively inflated prices (subsidized of course, basically being paid by the Danish government to do nothing besides cash checks while Starlink does everything else). This is so obviously corrupt that it's better for them to use a worse, more expensive service that doesn't make Tusass completely pointless.

I see many of you focusing on the misuse of "ditches" while you should focus on the use of the word "trust" by those who signed the contract. Pretty sure it will not be the last time we see this kind of reasoning.
Starlink is run by a company based in a country which has threatened to invade Greenland, with a CEO who is aligned with the leadership of that country.
How did we get to a time when clicking back in the browser makes a website show a bunch of cancer inducing apps including a picture of Putin? I didn't even read the article after being greeted by an unremovable ad, trying to escape this dystopic nightmare by going back.
The new CEO of Eutelsat, Jean-François Fallacher, was previously the CEO of Orange France, the country’s incumbent telco, a much bigger company. He is a member of France’s senior civil service and this shows how seriously France and the EU are taking the strategic and sovereignty risks of depending on US-controlled infrastructure. Greenland, of course, is even more concerned due to Trump’s threats.
Obviously, it's hard to see under the current circumstances ( US belligerence and Musk's willingness to use his companies for political ends ) - how the decision would go any other way.

The interesting question is to what extent this is symptomatic of a wider pattern where governments and companies around the world are making such decisions for similar reasons.

LEO satellite communications constellations like OneWeb and Starlink seem like they could make a big difference in what kinds of operations you could carry out in places like northern Greenland or central Australia.
This is actually good news in that Greenland decided that the USA isn't the number #1 option right now. The EU really needs to become a better alternative than the USA, so allowing superrich billionaires to hold the rest of the world hostage (aka Starlink) should be an objective by the EU to put a permanent end to. Outsourcing security onto the USA under Trump also was never going to work - he works for Putin, we all know that.
Eutelsat maintains nominal facilities in Madeira (Portugal) and Luxembourg, primarily to optimize tax obligations away from France; can it still be accurately described as a French company?
If we apply that criteria, then it's completeley useless to name an international company's country.
I mean, you could say the same of any multinational.