Show HN: 1Password Replica (Security Challenge) (github.com)

1 points by davinci123 4mo ago ↗ HN

I created a replica for 1Password which I created in minutes using Claude Code. I am not even a full-time engineer. I want security researchers to poke hole in the model and find out glaring security holes in a codebase created by an agent, not reviewed or coded bu a human.

2 comments

[ 3.0 ms ] story [ 18.7 ms ] thread

al_borland 4mo ago ↗

I’m no expert, but this all looks like theater to give the illusion that it made a password manager.

The extension unlock passes off the master password in plain text to a function in the Python backend that just returns that it’s unlocked without actually doing anything.

Am I missing something?

A password manager is the last thing that should be vibe coded.

cinntaile 4mo ago ↗

You created it in minutes, I think the appropriate next step would be to ask another LLM to try to poke holes in it. It does not seem fair to ask security professionals to waste their time on this.