13 comments

[ 2.8 ms ] story [ 23.9 ms ] thread
It would be just as interesting to see how things have changed over the time - from the 1910s to now.
Talent is evenly distributed, opportunity is not
doesnt it also happen to star dust? they born at the same time, scattered, grow with time, then became different part of the universe.
Couldn't agree more. Growing up in a civil war certainly did not raise my chances of getting a job at a good company. Of which there are none, so it's fine.
All obviously true but for this audience you have to, sadly, address the Nazi mind view that is explicitly built to counter this.

The parents lived in the better location because they are better, purer Aryans. That's why the kid did better, because they have the good genes. They deserve their success. The poor deserve their poverty.

Zoom out to different countries and you can find top level members of the government making this argument on a daily basis. "They" are poor because they are inferior human beings and do not deserve to be treated as full human beings.

(comment deleted)
Are you asking if the world is fair? No. No, it is not.
What if Elon Musk had been born in a much poorer region/family instead?
The economic divide is very apparent here in South Africa, and it leads to perverse effects on our infrastructure.

As the country's ability to provide basic utilities falters, sufficiently wealthy households go partially or completely off grid, depriving revenue for the utilities and further exacerbating the problem.

Sure. And I'd say the culture of the country and expectations there probably play a part even between places with similar income levels.

For example, someone with a very entrepreneurial mindset is probably going to want to be born in the US, and ideally close to a city like New York or San Francisco. You can certainly make it as a founder in Europe or Asia or Australia or what not, but it's a lot easier to get the funding needed to become a household name in the former, since (at least for a while) there were companies and investors willing to throw a ton of cash at crazy ideas rather than a moderate amount at proven businesses.

Similarly, if you're particularly interested in a certain industry, you'll ideally want to be born in a country where said industry has a decent foothold. Video game developers are all over the world, but it's hard to deny your odds are probably better in that industry if you're American or Japanese.

“Will you go blind if you stare at the sun too much?”
You can see this even in the US. I know too many people stuck in places with few or no opportunities and moving up is hard because they age out or didn’t go to a big name university or work at big name companies. The bias is there
(comment deleted)