22 comments

[ 3.6 ms ] story [ 48.2 ms ] thread
The ICANN policy of removing TLDs just because a country no longer exists makes no practical sense and only serves to break the internet.
Is there a practical way to enumerate all the registered internet domains? EG by asking DNS servers for all the domains they know about, and repeating over all DNS servers they know about?

EDIT: apparently, "asking DNS servers for all the domains they know about" is not something you can really do anymore for security reasons. Guess that idea won't fly lol

certificate transparency logs will give you a lot of that data.
Damn ethnic nationalism... in the end it was just profit for local psychos dealing with their own ethnics like sheeple.

If Yugoslavia got a political transition as it happened in Spain to a social-democracy, (and yet the Spanish constitution states that all goods belong to the state in case of general intereset, such as a great catastrophe), they would evolve together and wars would have been a thing of the past.

As an anecdote, read about the creation of the Warajevo ZX emulator, a cross-ethnic colaboration from several Yugo people to get spare PC parts and books while avoiding snipers.

BTW: a country not existing is not an excuse. The Catalan language stretch over Spain, Andorra (the official language) and a bit of France and Italy. Ditto with the Basque language (and .eus domain).

.Yu could be reused for content written in Serbo-Croatian language. Ah, yes, the Cyrillic script, but today that task would be trivial, and I'm pretty sure that due to the exposure to the Latin scripts the Serbians can read Croatian texts perfectly fine.

Both scripts have been taught in the early years of elementary school in Serbia for the past 80 years.
It's interesting that while .yu was killed off, .su (Soviet Union) still exists and you can buy them today.
And there is now a whole issue over .io that might disappear in the near future and take thousands of SaaS and AI companies with it.
The fall of Yugoslavia was a horrible tragedy and a stark example of the horrors of nationalism.

Neighbors, brothers, friends, who spoke the same language and occupied the same cultural space, suddenly reduced to their narcissism of small differences and committing horrible atrocities in the name of a tribe.

And for what? For the chance of living in a dysfunctional rump state with nowhere near the relevance of what they used to have.

The fall of Yugoslavia was a tragedy in a sense, but on the other hand maybe it should have never existed as a single state in the first place. It was always an artificial construct with the central government barely holding the country together, sort of like Iraq. People can mourn the loss but it was doomed from the start.
If Yugoslavia had survived it'd have the relevance of maybe a combined Bulgaria and Romania today.

Slovenia and Croatia were the most developed parts of it and would be burdened by fiscal transfers to undeveloped regions of Bosnia Macedonia and Kosovo. I'd argue Croats and Slovenians enjoy a higher quality of living with a government that can focus on the needs of its own citizens.

You don't need political relevance or even resources to develop a great country. Look at Denmark as an example.

Bulgaria almost joined but negotiations broke through at the last moment and then Georgi Dimitrov passed away, killing the momentum.
I agree that it was a tragedy, but the cultural and religious tensions have existed in the Balkans for centuries. Tito's strong leadership, charisma, "bratstvo i jedinstvo", etc., managed to keep it together, often by sheer force that suppressed nationalism. After he died, all it took for it to fall apart was a group of small-minded political pawns that filled the vacuum and infected the masses with their narrative, along with external influence from all sides that wanted their own piece of the pie.

Today each country might not be as relevant as Yugoslavia once was, but there's relative peace in the region, and the countries that are part of the EU today are significantly better off in many ways than they were before. It's a miracle that the Yugoslav experiment lasted as long as it did, so perhaps we should accept that the only way southern slavs can coexist is in independent states.

Pozdrav!

Slovenia and Croatia are members of the European Union- I would say that is pretty relevant.
Yugoslavia was a great thing that europe lost, and perhaps it shouldn't have. The EU membership and shengen area might make a big impact in the region though.
For kicks and giggles and because my wife was born in Yugoslavia I bought Yugoslavia.org a few years ago. Would like to do something meaningful with it.
I'd be interested in buying it from you.
I don't remember which HN thread I've heard this joke originally from, but...

People in Montenegro: it's not .yu, it's .me

You're right, ICANN should archive the namespace as it-is without removing the TLD from the root server and registry. Similar to an wayback archive version for domain names.

On the other hand .su (soviet union) is still in use.

It is very unfortunate ICANN still hasn't address this issue yet. Although not yet, .io is in a similar situation with even larger domains active but the territory is changing hands from britain to mauritius.

World is connected by Internet, it needs to be preserved even after geo politics and borders change.

.cs RIP too...