6 comments

[ 2.3 ms ] story [ 28.1 ms ] thread
I built https://github.com/k0nserv/plid with Pgrx and had a great time. I did have to scale back some of the magic (dropping derive PostgresType etc), but even so the support pgrx provides is excellent. I also talked to the maintainers a bit in discord and they were super helpful.

The one downside of custom extensions is that you aren’t, AFAIK, able to use them with many hosted Postgres installs, notably AWS RDS.

Supabase is an interesting middle ground here — it runs on managed Postgres but gives you access to a curated set of extensions (pg_cron, pgvector, unaccent, PostGIS etc.) without needing to build your own. We used unaccent + GIN indexes for fuzzy city search and it worked well. Still not the same as arbitrary custom extensions, but covers a lot of practical use cases that RDS won't touch.
The maintainers for this project are pretty nice all around. Very knowledgeable and as helpful as anyone could ask.
PlanetScale's internal extensions -- Insights, Traffic Control, and pg_strict -- are all built in pgrx.

Number of memory unsafety and race conditions I've had to debug in production in a year of use: zero.

pgrx is fantastic.