48 comments

[ 2.4 ms ] story [ 51.7 ms ] thread
So we've really just settled on Vibe as the verb for AI then?
Isn't this project the one Microsoft published but then soon after pulled it for security/safety reasons? What has changed since then?
Seems quite heavy for a STT model, Parakeet and Whisper are much smaller and perform great for quick dictation and transcription of longer files. I guess that's due to additional accuracy and speaker diarisation?

The TTS example clip in the repo of 'spontaneous singing' is creepy as fuck

This is not a new model. Also, it hallucinates a lot. Also, it's very heavy and slow in inference. It's also bad in multilingual.

Edit: I'm talking purely about speech to text (STT). Not sure about the other things this can do.

You have selected Microsoft Sam as the computer's default voice.
I the past month or so, I added 2 models to my app Whisper Memos (https://whispermemos.com):

- Cohere Transcribe (self hosted)

- Grok Speech To Text (they provide an API, only $0.10/hr!)

They are both excellent. I'm not sure about this one. Would you like to see it in a consumer speech to text app?

For me its giving me very poor results
What’s the current state of the art, for each of training locally and in the cloud, for learning my voice?
Interesting to see "vibe" enshrined by the likes of Microsoft as an AI product word.
Maybe Microsoft’s real strength was never making the best model, it was knowing you don’t need to, as long as you own the platform everyone builds on.
Holy moly, a Microsoft AI product that isn't named Copilot!
I took a look into local options for ASR and diarization some months ago, I missed that VibeVoice now has this feature.

My conclusions back then (which only came from a shallow research on the topic and 0 real experience mind you) was that Whisper + Pyannote was the "stable" approach.

Have the VibeVoice, Voxtral, Qwen or the Nemo solutions caught up in segmentation and speaker recognition?

Microsoft is famous for choosing terrible names but how could they be this terrible.
Microsoft has historically made poor choices in product naming, but this has to be a new low.
(comment deleted)
Still waiting for the open weights model that conclusively beats the multi-year old Whisper in accuracy, features, and performance.
I've been using VibeVoice's ASR (speech to text) model quite intensively for the past month and have found it to be a lot more reliable and out-of-the box functional then Whisper, parakeet and other models. The fact that is has diarization built into to the model is a huge win in my book. Without that you have to run a different model just for that which adds significantly to the overall processing time vs VibeVoice which gives you reliably great results. Big fan.
It would have been better if they provided not just weights, but also some frontend where it is usable as is.