50 comments

[ 2.7 ms ] story [ 45.4 ms ] thread
Is this poor timing or coat tail riding?
How are "constantly rearranging" instruments an essential?

Some designers don't get it. Too much ego. Those are the one's who would have failed to finish a cathedral over several generations within the same style (re-read chapter 4 of "The Mythical Man-Month" to understand).

It's a distraction. And a pure driver's car avoids any distraction.

I see this in software too - designers have to constantly justify their own employment by redesigning things that work perfectly well and literally no one has ever complained about. But if you're on the payroll to design, you have to design.
Its also a profession thst is secretly beloved by management because unlike product, they never miss a deadline.
Well, they call it a pure "driver's car" but it's really too fussy to be that. A Miata or Elise/Exige would be what I'd put that label on.
> How are "constantly rearranging" instruments an essential?

Kids those days. They _need_ to come with something "new". Fixing bugs is hard. They just "rearange" it. They took the idea from SW development. Everybody (Google, Mozilla, Microsoft, Gnome) is doing it so it must be good.

Porsche. “Aluminum key”

Tesla roadster. “Drives upside down, flies, does flips, 0-60 in 0.81s”

"Noticeably different from the very first moment: the aluminium key offers a glimpse of what is to come. Even before the engine starts, a connection to the car is formed, transforming anticipation into something tangible."

I would fire the marketing team.

Is this a Jony Ive collab? Sure seems there are a lot of similarities to the Ferrari Luce.
Interesting. It kinda does have a tiny bit of semblance inside, but not as nearly refined.

Thing is Ive didn't design exterior tho, but getting all the flak for it. Meanwhile interior of Luce is first Ferrari that doesn't look like a joke.

I see a lot of Claudeisms/AI slop in the copy text on that page. Really disappointed from that page, agreed, fire the marketing team.
Advertising the fact that the key is from some other metal is... weird.

Who gives a fuck? Never have i used a key and thought "wow, I wish the metal was different, that would noticeably change my experience".

People are still using metal keys to open and start cars?
Porsche. "You can buy me as promised in a timeframe i told you"

Tesla roadster. "Hold my key, i might actually get delivered in 2-5 years after waiting for 10"

(comment deleted)
one of them is real product, the other just some promo skeleton made for promo, which they dont actually properly show
Different target audience.

I'd rather have an aluminum key.

The Aluminium key is a bit silly.

But I'd much rather have a premium car from a manufacturer with premium car standards. Have you seen the panel gaps on Teslas? They're like fancy Ladas!

Aren't we still waiting for the previous tesla roadster to be released?
"Height-adjustable gear lever", lol.

Zero info about the engine on the page - or is it electric? The page doesn't really say.

For a sports car, that sort of info is kinda important?

The marketing page says it's mid-engined. Maybe it's one of these newer hybrids not designed for range for but performance boost especially a low RPMs where the gas engine last immediate torque.
In a video, a Porsche official said they haven't decided on the engine yet.
It’s mostly a marketing exercise and Germans are notoriously bad from an Anglo perspective.

From the opposite side Tesla’s presentation was way “yee-ahh” and tacky from the perspective of other publics

Looks nice but the presentation of the website is terrible.Looks like they are try-harding.Not happy with the copy at all.But the lines of of the car are nice to see.Please Porsche keep it together.
> Looks nice but the presentation of the website is terrible.Looks like ... all.But the ... see.Please ... together.

Please add spaces after periods. The presentation is terrible.

The car is beautiful except for that visible fan, it gives AC unit vibes.
>what does the sports car of tomorrow really need?

1000HP of EV power, definitely not a V8

Most car enthusiasts are against EV sport cars.
Peak performance alone will not imbue something with a soul, and adding (or adding additional) computers frequently seems to overlap with something becoming more soulless.

An SSD is faster, but a hard drive ticking away is a language its own, and an amorphous white-by-default Tesla Plaid may be one of the fastest cars on any road, but odds are the only feeling it evokes is "This is faster than any reasonable person needs, and likely more than is safe for any standard American motorist to be able to just go out and buy"

> car enthusiasts

That's why they suck

Why not both? What makes EVs meaningful is when you get to the point of pushing green electricity to the grid and have the bulk of the utilitarian traffic consume it. Electrifying supercars for the sake of it has no measurable impact in the grand scheme of things.
Just having more HP doesn't translate to a better car on a race track. There is much more to the performance just pure power-to-weight distribution. There is a reason to enjoy a humble Mazda MX-5 over Tesla 3 performance
Landing page design is really bad. For a bit, I was not sure if I had landed on a generic WordPress blog.
At this point I'd save the money for a stick of DRAM you might need.
So is this an EV or an ICE car? The rev counter makes me think ICE?
It's ICE, they talk about mid engine configuration
LLMsplaining in every second paragraph…
ohh come on man you should "focus on what matters" (:
I really liked the interior of this model. Glad it looks analog and not the stupid 100% displays you can get in a car today.
Huh, everything is digital apart from the needle arm of the rev counter?
"Focus on what matters." :/ I guess they replaced their copywriter with AI.
How did they even manage this timing seriously.
What is the point of revealing a car, but then giving zero technical specs?