81 comments

[ 3.7 ms ] story [ 100 ms ] thread
I don't get the fuss. This is absolutely only going to be used to detect CSAM content, this year.
I'd give it a few months before they scan every photo/video you ever take for other purposes. If you were at the wrong public gathering, I don't know if they'll even bother with parallel construction.
[delayed]
Sarcasmgram detects that the comment was 99% dry humor.
I can confirm your detector if functioning as advertised.
Very appropriate use of British understated sarcasm. Philomena Cunk would approve.
Maybe they should focus on fixing their country first
But they will not. This is why the British people I know are so apathic. All their major political parties suck and have zero interest in fixing the country.
That describes pretty much all the anglo speaking countries.
> Older devices could also be covered using a mandatory software update.

Highly curious about how they'll be able to do that.

Will they force apple to release ios27 for an iPhone 4?

More likely they'll collect from phone manufacturers the IMEI of all devices which are updated, and then send police in to confiscate any device which is powered up and connects to a mobile network when not updated.
Probably a patch to the last major version available to that phone.
Kind of an aside but they finally removed the hedetary members this year (yes this year)! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/House_of_Lords_(Hereditary_Pee...

Though there's still these lads I think? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lords_Spiritual

The hereditaries were far more civil libertarian than the political appointees that now make up the whole HoL, and would have almost certainly been against this.
They were the orderlies in the mental institution that is UK politics. Now they're gone we have this kind of shit.
How do they plan on stopping creation, especially on older devices?
Or on non-UK devices. This just inflates values in the UK of such devices and contents that UK will be unable to create, let alone compete with.
"Older devices could also be covered using a mandatory software update." So your already slow device will get a forced update to now make it compliant.
Older devices become illegal, if you own one you are assumed guilty of crimes. Non-UK, devices? Don't worry, all the countries will have this soon. The one thing that all governments agree on is that they should have more power and the people should have less.
Bold move from a country that wrongfully arrested and convicted thousands of postmasters due to buggy software that determined they were stealing.
doubful this will pass in its current form, but if it somehow does: countdown until yet another parent is arrested for pictures of their own baby in their phone.
I can't help but think of the dad who was investigated by the FBI for having pictures he took to show his kid's doctor.

Are parents going to be arrested for pictures of their kids in the bathtub? Or at least are they going to be blurred?

> Are parents going to be arrested for pictures of their kids in the bathtub?

No. Because this magical new software will prevent such pictures.

We both know that if it's not built in straight away, it will be upgraded to report you without even notifying you of the fact. Exactly how the Apple csam detection system was supposed to work before apple backed off - if a picture was deemed csam your phone would automatically report you without telling you about it.
Well, it can't report you for taking a picture it prevented you taking, can it?
It can still report that it has detected CSAM on your phone, with whatever it saw on the screen attached as proof. Whether you clicked capture or not is irrelevant. Reading the proposal it sounds like not would literally look at your screen as you browse the internet and blur it "instantly". So it obviously looks at the screen in real time(how does anyone think this can actually be built and run without destroying the battery is beyond me, but I don't think these people have given it that much thought)
> Whether you clicked capture or not is irrelevant.

I thought we were talking about taking photos.

So only the first is illegal.

The proposal suggests scanning your entire screen and blurring any content before you have a chance to see it.
[delayed]
Again I don't think these people have thought this far. If you have CSAM on your phone then clearly you must be a criminal, who cares how it got there /s

The entire rationale they seem to offer is - to quote the article - "these companies make trillions of dollars, they can easily implement this".

It's like saying that since Google makes trillions of dollars they can easily land on Mars, after all money solves all problems including physics.

> Again I don't think these people have thought this far.

Agreed 100%.

> If you have CSAM on your phone then clearly you must be a criminal, who cares how it got there /s

The law cares. So it will be interesting to see how this is covered in formulation.

>>The law cares

Yes, the problem is that there were already cases where people were arrested for CP because they left their phone for repair and the tech reported them, they got swiped up from their home or work, spent months in jail waiting for trial, no one could look at the evidence because "it's CSAM", local newspapers posted that so and so were arrested for CP, they lost their jobs, and finally months later some prosecutor finally agreed to look at the evidence only to see the guy only had some pictures of his daughter in a paddling pool. Oops.

Yeah, the law cared. The law released them, maybe even apologized. But by that point your life is over, if you haven't just killed yourself over the accusation of being one of the worst people ever.

The way big tech is going, it'll report you for "attempted CSAM" and you won't even have the innocent rash picture to use in defence.
> No. Because this magical new software will prevent such pictures.

WITHOUT informing the police of exactly what you were doing down to the centimeter in the past 2 years?

Not a chance.

Oh and in case anyone thinks this is the government wanting to protect children: Let's see how child services funding is doing (you know, the people actually caring for children)

Child services funding: 20% down.

The part that actually cares for children: 70% funding lost over the last 10 years.

It has gotten so bad there isn't A SINGLE LOCAL COUNCIL that isn't giving extra funding to their child services to prevent the worst. Not one. Not a single one.

So that tells you more than enough about how much the House of Lords (or House of Commons or any other part of the UK government) cares for children, doesn't it?

Honestly, doctors need training about what they should or should not ask parents for. When my daughter was a month old her GP asked me to take photos of her diaper rash and email them in. "Uh no, not going to do that."
What's the problem with that? If you mean the channel, unencrypted email, then maybe I agree to some extent. If you mean taking pictures of children for the purpose of diagnosis I really don't follow.
Your phone and your email provider are both going to ban you if you do this.
Even without that kind of false positive, with every phone running the check on every image false positives on perfectly normal images will be extremely common.

I occasionally use the Civitai.com to generate realistic images, and due to US regulators jawboning payment processors, they've put in strict filters. I've been using it for G-rated images, but they often get false positive for much worse ratings. I generated an image of a portrait of a couple at the beech, with a man in board shorts and a fully clothed woman, and it rated it XXX. One image of fully clothed people didn't even get a rating and was automatically removed as a "terms of service violation".

UK's got a Mumsnet Government
Cool, so 800 tech illiterate senior citizens are mandating updates for _all_ legacy smartphones.
I think it's very interesting. The detection function needs to send data back to the cloud, right?

Does it need to be written into the Kernel? Or how does it work?

I think we're probably not far from the world of Watch Dogs. As for whether it will become 2077, we'll have to wait and see.

Good question. If so, we will be prevented from taking photos when offline. And will pay extra data charges when not.
There is at least one example of software that contains example CSAM that is obfuscated. It is compared to content on a device or in a cloud storage. At least one person claims to have been able to reverse the process and retrieve the originals. The question in my mind is whose kids seeded this software and what living person has now been immortalized via their likely most-traumatic experience.
> there was a “ghastly worldwide industry” of child sexual abuse material being created, and that Britain was one of the biggest consumers of it,

They're talking about anime and how UK is not making any, nor is it significant market of to be infliential to, yet nevertheless consuming it in ever larger quantity over the years, unilaterally receiving cultural influence with no leverages, not even cash flow that can be choked off. Lots of these "CSAM" stuff is inflated with imaginary kids and trafficking angles to hide that intent, but it boils down to that.

Otherwise the action taken would be to assigning more police officers or otherwise assigning more resources to support kids IRL. They're not doing that. They only want speeches suppressed.

I don't know why they don't just tax social media for it, though. CDN bandwidth for foreign user-generated contents can be measured. Maybe because they just don't like fictions at all, but that ship had sailed like, thousands of years ago.

> They're talking about anime [...]

Indeed they are. And as someone who got raided by the British police nearly three years ago - and is still currently under a police investigation - for "uploading/downloading 'illegal' anime artwork on an anime artwork website we're criminally investigating," these laws were never about protecting children.

It was always about finding a way to label people as "child abusers" and "sex offenders" with ease.

This is not about CSAM, it is about an infrastructure for large scale censorship and tracking of publishing and publishers.

Anyone talking about CSAM has missed the point entirely.

The house of lords should absolutely fuck off back to the dark ages where it belongs. Useless institution that keeps interfering with democracy(case in point - recent assisted dying bill)
Actually it's exactly because you got what you want that this is happening. The house of lords as it was would never have pushed this kind of thing. You got rid of the hereditary peers and here we are. Congratulations.
>> You got rid of the hereditary peers and here we are.

Who is this "you" in your post?

>>The house of lords as it was would never have pushed this kind of thing.

That is an astonishing statement given their previous stances on various issues. What gives you that confidence? But heridetary peers or not, house of lords doesn't belong in Britain of 2026.

This will create more attack vectors, make phones more ineffeciant, make massive piles of people innocent of wrongdoing put prosecuted and jailed for sending pics of their kids to their family and doctors, and generally increase the power of the state to surveil its citizens to an extreme degree, on par with the worst totalitarian dictatorships.

Its funny, every time I talk to a brit they seem very intelligent and reasonable but then they've been happily electing people who make their country into an extreme surveillance state, labor & conservative both. I think their accent just makes them sound smarter than they are.

With the bonus irony of doing sweet FA about child porn.
They won’t prosecute them until they oppose the state. Then bam, straight to jail.
The worst part is in the end: “We will also give the police the powers they need to keep pace with criminal use of emerging technologies in order to keep our children safe.”

Which means that not only will it blur it, it will also report it and you will be processed for a picture of your kid for the doctor or when the "fail safe" software fails.

What could possibly go wrong with a government having the ability to stop people from seeing things that they consider bad.
How many of them still have Ghislane on there speed dial? and palsy walsy pics of themselves, the prince formerly known as royal, Jeffery, and a few junior massage trainies.
The UK is running so fast towards ever increasing authoritarianism. I can't see it stopping.

They were pushing out today that they're going to add, well, what they call a ban for under 16s, which really means strong ID for everyone else, to access eBay and Vinted in case kids use the messaging functions on them.

It'll be TCP next. Then you'll need government permission to blink.

(comment deleted)
As usual, the UK seems to be driving towards 1984-style dystopia.
Interesting. The first laws in Turkey started to around 15 years ago with the only purpose of protecting children. That is how the first internet blocking started in Turkey. Now they block any negative thing about the government. But CSAM is not active in Turkey because why would it be? It is not about children but opressing political opponents.
> It will prevent many tax evasions and crimes.

Careful now, useful idiots will come out of the woodwork to cheer for it when you phrase it like that.