Tbh I'm not entirely sure I'd trust a partial plane body to have the mechanical strength for the job. In flight the pressure is pushing out not in, and I assume that's what the thing is designed for.
Though the thing is only barely buried so I suppose it doesn't actually have much external pressure to deal with.
He is pouring concrete re-enforcement around it. Biggest issue is during the pour which he seems to have planned in stages to not put too much pressure on it.
Few minutes in and he is mixing concrete: Too much water in this concrete mix. Wrong kind of sand as well... Luckily he seems to have had a professional mix the concrete for the walls, etc.
Ideally, tank your hole with a membrane and pump. Only a noob garden-plane-in-hole owner would crane it in without one! Bit late now.
On the up-side, it looks like it's going into a concrete clad hole so may have a cavity not be buried in soil. It won't be permeable like basement walls that suck water out of the ground. I guess it's aluminium/titanium so won't be red dust by spring but can still corrode in some fashion depending on ph/oxygen. Could there be steel in things like fasteners?
Oh, and it's a tube... no idea how they've sealed the ends.
You can see the rebar in the photos so that checks out, and I would think without it a plane wouldn't be designed to withstand force from above like you would need to be able to bury it safely. If I buried something like this in my yard it would need to be able to withstand a utility truck driving over it at least once in a blue moon.
Which is why these installs usually involve all sorts of external waterproofing, concrete encasement, galvanic/cathodic protections & sacrificial anodes, drainage systems, and interior climate control. They don't just bury the expensive fuselage and call it a day.
I wouldn't call it common. It is a time consuming hobby at best. However I expect a lot of people spend time daydreaming about their future bunker that they never build and I would expect a plane to come up with something to bury quite often. Many of those are enough of engineers to figure out details like this.
Even this is the first time someone actually does it.
No, but the aluminum in the fuselage requires all these mitigations and it’s a well known problem. Without them, galvanic corrosion weakens both the aluminum and the concrete.
The video says the guys wants to put the hull under a 3 inch fiber-reinforced concrete vault, which would be supported by the plane. The guy's word: "I'm hoping the plane can take that sort of weight". Then another thicker layer of concrete this time reinforced with mesh.
I for sure the guy hires good engineers to do the actual calculation and the whole "I don't know what I'm doing" is just for the show.
I do think it's I-don't-know-what-I'm-doing. I fast-forwarded through a lot of it but there's no DPC under anything, no bitumen-coating on the outside of the concrete to waterproof it, a token attempt at drainage with some pea gravel at the bottom and then they just push the excavated soil up against the concrete. That place is going to be so damp, and even worse after heavy rain. And that's just the start of the cowboying...
Concrete is not very water proof on its own. It's also quite hard to prevent cracks from forming, even with reinforcement.
There is a lot you could do, like neoprene barriers on the skin of the fuselage, sacrificial anodes, spray sealant on the poured concrete. But at that point, you might as well not even have the fuselage and just build a regular, ol' concrete bunker.
Concrete is used as a moisture barrier inside walls if it is specifically built for that purpose. Without it, soil moisture damages the walls. Yet concrete is still electrically conductive and can cause galvanic corrosion, although not as bad as direct contact with soil.
It depends on how it is built and whether the constructors are aware of the problem.
I guess, to be fair, £4000 he spent on the fuselage is a lot less than he'd spend on building the arch and other scaffolding to just build a concrete bunker from scratch.
I don't know his local costs, but in many countries, scaffolding is rented because it is reusable, so I doubt that it would cost so much.
And he already built most of the concrete structure without it, as it is mostly needed only for the roof.
It's also not true that such a structure necessarily requires it. You can build concrete beams to support the roof and fill in the spaces without it. Using scaffolding is optional, not mandatory.
It is a bit risky, but UK planning permission seems to be mostly (though not entirely) about impact on the neighbours, and something underground is not visible and unlikely to have much impact. Also, it is a rural area with no close neighbours.
It's less risky than the "right" way that the boot lickers will tell you to do it.
If you, a private individual not some megacorp with infinite money for concessions, show up in front of a permitting authority asking to do anything that isn't the most cookie cutter bog standard thing you're gonna get told (in plausibly deniable government speak of course) to fuck off a million different ways, they'll slow roll you, they'll force you to jump through expensive hoops hoping you'll quit, etc, etc.
Since this isn't some slimeball slumlord deal and is a "honest man doing reasonable, if odd, honest man things" just going for it and getting permission after the fact is absolutely the right way to do it.
It's a million times easier for the permitting authority to say "well we don't have any rules this fits into but clearly what you've built here is fine" after you've done it, there are no unbounded questions and it's clearly fine than to give you permission in advance.
> When asked why he had lifted a section of a former plane into the ground in his back garden, Dave Billings shrugged his shoulders and said: "Why not?"
57 comments
[ 6.1 ms ] story [ 132 ms ] threadhttps://youtube.com/shorts/nqXgbLjW1ho?si=PmwapHh23zYmIXuh
Though the thing is only barely buried so I suppose it doesn't actually have much external pressure to deal with.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ixh0KIackIk
On the up-side, it looks like it's going into a concrete clad hole so may have a cavity not be buried in soil. It won't be permeable like basement walls that suck water out of the ground. I guess it's aluminium/titanium so won't be red dust by spring but can still corrode in some fashion depending on ph/oxygen. Could there be steel in things like fasteners?
Oh, and it's a tube... no idea how they've sealed the ends.
Even this is the first time someone actually does it.
I for sure the guy hires good engineers to do the actual calculation and the whole "I don't know what I'm doing" is just for the show.
There is a lot you could do, like neoprene barriers on the skin of the fuselage, sacrificial anodes, spray sealant on the poured concrete. But at that point, you might as well not even have the fuselage and just build a regular, ol' concrete bunker.
It depends on how it is built and whether the constructors are aware of the problem.
And he already built most of the concrete structure without it, as it is mostly needed only for the roof.
It's also not true that such a structure necessarily requires it. You can build concrete beams to support the roof and fill in the spaces without it. Using scaffolding is optional, not mandatory.
This is the best feedback he could get to be sure it will run well you YT.
Isn't that a bit risky? Is the idea that his YouTube popularity will mean the council won't say no?
Also, Bmibaby, what a blast from the past
If you, a private individual not some megacorp with infinite money for concessions, show up in front of a permitting authority asking to do anything that isn't the most cookie cutter bog standard thing you're gonna get told (in plausibly deniable government speak of course) to fuck off a million different ways, they'll slow roll you, they'll force you to jump through expensive hoops hoping you'll quit, etc, etc.
Since this isn't some slimeball slumlord deal and is a "honest man doing reasonable, if odd, honest man things" just going for it and getting permission after the fact is absolutely the right way to do it.
It's a million times easier for the permitting authority to say "well we don't have any rules this fits into but clearly what you've built here is fine" after you've done it, there are no unbounded questions and it's clearly fine than to give you permission in advance.
(It's much cheaper to just build a parking garage-type structure or use precast covers, but concrete pipes can give you that hobbit-hole you need.)
https://www.countymaterials.com/pipe-and-underground-infrast...
Yes, I have spent way too much time on this.
> When asked why he had lifted a section of a former plane into the ground in his back garden, Dave Billings shrugged his shoulders and said: "Why not?"
https://www.reddit.com/r/abandoned/comments/1x4yw6y/inside_t...
Quite literally the opposite of flying environment... in the ground.
So if the objective is a pure folly for youtube channel. Grand success. Any real utility as a useful structure? Just no.