12 comments

[ 0.20 ms ] story [ 4.7 ms ] thread
Will they address bot spam and astroturfing? If not then this is useless. Might as well ask ChatGPT directly what it thinks about a product.
It's worse that worthless, it's going to increase the pressure to astroturf and spam.
Behold, ye mighty, and despair.
But LLMs will be including that same worthless content and you'll lose transparency and the agency of choosing sources above a credibility threshold.
> Keeping Reddit real

> What appears in Reddit Reviews is shaped by Reddit communities, not paid placement. Businesses can’t pay to have products featured. Volunteer moderators enforce community rules, Reddit’s Safety team enforces sitewide rules, and users vote on posts they find valuable or that don’t add to the conversation. Together, these safeguards help limit spam and inauthentic activity.

Needs that XKCD of piled up blocks with volunteer mods and volunteer communities as the base.

Thank god reddit is well known to cater to and foster both of these groups with only positive things to be said about reddit leadership.

Reddit users are the last ones I'd turn to for reviews.
Seriously, the entire site has been astroturfed to oblivion these days. Subreddit hive minds and mods with agendas have removed the nuance from many discussions. Nowadays I find it more useful to put an LLM to bear and trawl for actual info.
(comment deleted)
- stop allowing hidden accounts to post political propaganda. so many of them in the name of privacy are just posting absolute propaganda about one country or the other

- make moderators fire-able (some of them indiscriminately ban people for no reason at all)

make moderation transparent, at least for non spam related content removal.

I want to see mod logs and why people are getting banned or comments deleted, as I myself was banned from many subs for the most absurd reasons... a simple example, on a "local" sub, I was banned because I had the audacity to tell someone who was using racial slurs to knock it off, on an alleged left-leaning sub?!? like what the f? So, what I think happened is that the commenter I rebuked publicly was banned by reddit itself for their comment and the sub moderation thought it was me who reported that comment, which I did not, so it was in retaliation, as I suspect the commenter was friend with the mods, that's the only explanation I can come up with...

Surely the volunteer moderators would never take any consideration from any company ever for favorable moderation, right?
Google play has done the same thing, reduced visibility on user reviews and replaced it with their crappy paragraph-long summary (1) review of the thousands sent in by people.

I just can't..