It's really lack of creativity on the part of poltiicians and also the public. While the article is talking about a mathematical shape of voting, it also has the shape of a sports tournament. We certainly don't have problems picking winners for the NBA or World Cup. Voting is just too low resolution and there's so much more on the line. Why aren't there elections every year that have multiple levels of "primaries", showing brackets for candidates as they each go head to head with each other?
This is where I put on my metaphorical tin foil hat and think there is a lot of corruption that takes place to prevent fair elections that could let anybody win. The truth is those in power have every incentive to pull every lever they have to remain in power, and to gatekeep aggressively to make sure only those who think the same way even have a chance.
Isn't that what politicians in municipalities are? You only get to vote for nation-wide politicians after they already competed against other politicians by successfully ruling municipalities and countries.
You mean a political career? As in they get elected at the local level and then make their way up? That would be different, because every time they get elected is with the current limited form of voting for a bunch of candidates in one day. I'm saying voting itself could be spread out in multiple stages. But it's just one example of how it can be changed things instead of thinking we're stuck with one person one vote forever.
But doesn't that voting already happen, just inside a specific party? And your chances to get voted for in the party correlate to getting votes from the public. No party wants to elect people for their list, who then don't get votes from the public.
That's probably not the case. Parties operate like corporations, so there is probably a ton of bias, gatekeeping etc. when it comes to choosing candidates and that is often not in the public's best interests. An easy example is populists, who have public support but go against the party. Usually the party will not treat them as well as establishment candidates.
Sure, I didn't claim party rankings are made up by transparent voting alone.
> An easy example is populists, who have public support but go against the party. Usually the party will not treat them as well as establishment candidates.
That's kinda what I was referring to. Party support is supposed to favor people who actually have already governed or actually represent the ideals of the party over those who just talk big.
Everyone talks big. What are parties even for? Shouldn't holding office be completely separate like an isolated job? The fact they are held to party lines is somewhat of a failure of a democratic system or republic. The people should be choosing every step of the way and then once elected it should be like any other job. I don't know, just thoughts.
Placing power into the hands of a single person is a bad idea, because that reduces the chance errors are caught by multiple people needing to agree and a it's too much work for a single person.
If you are in the parliament, you can't potentially read into every topic and bill in deep. That's why you partner with other member of parliaments, who have the same ideals as you, and split the topics between you. That's a parliamentary group. Wouldn't it be great if you could know who is going to partner before the election, so you could vote based on that? Also if they are gonna partner after the election anyway, they can already do it before, so that they are able to fund an election campaign and talk to people, because a single person could not afford to do that, because of both money and time. Voila, you have a party.
If you only want rich people to become members of parliament, you can get of course rid of parties, because they can afford all of the above on their own.
Funding elections is broken. You're just outlining how you need to be a career politician to even have a shot. That's part of the problem in my opinion. What exactly are politicians/representatives supposed to do? That's a question that hasn't been asked in a long time.
I don't have all the details, and I'm sure it's pretty complicated. The point is that there is no way this is the only way to run a democracy. It shouldn't be a career, because a career is a self-interested, long-term endeavor. Holding public office is a public service and people who do it should only think about the wellbeing of their constituents and the rest of the country as a close second.
10 comments
[ 0.33 ms ] story [ 20.8 ms ] threadWhich condition is loosened or eliminated by which voting systems, and what are the consequences?
This is where I put on my metaphorical tin foil hat and think there is a lot of corruption that takes place to prevent fair elections that could let anybody win. The truth is those in power have every incentive to pull every lever they have to remain in power, and to gatekeep aggressively to make sure only those who think the same way even have a chance.
> An easy example is populists, who have public support but go against the party. Usually the party will not treat them as well as establishment candidates.
That's kinda what I was referring to. Party support is supposed to favor people who actually have already governed or actually represent the ideals of the party over those who just talk big.
If you are in the parliament, you can't potentially read into every topic and bill in deep. That's why you partner with other member of parliaments, who have the same ideals as you, and split the topics between you. That's a parliamentary group. Wouldn't it be great if you could know who is going to partner before the election, so you could vote based on that? Also if they are gonna partner after the election anyway, they can already do it before, so that they are able to fund an election campaign and talk to people, because a single person could not afford to do that, because of both money and time. Voila, you have a party.
If you only want rich people to become members of parliament, you can get of course rid of parties, because they can afford all of the above on their own.
I don't have all the details, and I'm sure it's pretty complicated. The point is that there is no way this is the only way to run a democracy. It shouldn't be a career, because a career is a self-interested, long-term endeavor. Holding public office is a public service and people who do it should only think about the wellbeing of their constituents and the rest of the country as a close second.