HN Explorer

7 comments

[ 0.28 ms ] story [ 9.0 ms ] thread
anovikov
Somehow timeshares are criticised as scams but the same exact thing about planes - fractional ownership - isn't. Apparently people just have no compassion for rich people.
benrothke
With fractional ownership, it is not a lifetime commitment. Also, purchasers are not making their decisions under high-pressure deadlines. It doesn’t have anything to do with rich people.
silverFork
Well stocks are fractional ownership too. They don't have upkeep costs and someone doesnt get a better seat in the plane. But some stocks and plane fractional ownership could also be a scam when the debt exceeds the gains to be made by investment. The zillionaires may be sharing the plane and upkeep costs but what if one guy gets the priority to use it before anybody else or that shares were sold to other buyers at higher prices.
benrothke
To a degree. But look at the S&P over time; it is profitable. Look at timeshares, where perhaps 95% of purchasers regret their purchase.
silverFork
Obviously it has been always a scam. At best, timeshares take the best period of the year that has monetary value for themselves and sell the rest of year which is hard to monetize to simple folks and they get to pay for utilities, taxes and renovation and upkeep... And they can never sell it because a the real estate business that profits from this type of operation will build newer ones and the old ones become undesirable.
benrothke
Good points. The timeshare companies tout them as great investments. But if that was the case, people wouldn’t be selling them for $1.
silverFork
Can they even donate them I wonder. It has a cost.