> This server couldn't prove that it's fable52.games; its security certificate is not trusted by your computer's operating system. This may be caused by a misconfiguration or an attacker intercepting your connection.
I'm glad I had years of building casual games while it was enjoyable and intellectually challenging. A game could take 6 months or longer, and every detail was worked out by hand. It's too bad that few people will get to experience the fun and immersion of creating things like that now, at least at a professional level. The market was already so oversaturated there was hardly a way to make money at it anymore, even before AI slop games came around.
As impressive as this capability is, it mostly shows what has been lost.
Yeah unfortunately any one can now pump out crap, I am not a game developer but am a software developer I will still keep my usual software skill sharp but I am not even sure if there is any point.
I still write little bash scripts by hand when I need them, but I am not sure if really I should just prompt it. I like the feeling of knowing how it works and getting to work exactly how it works.
Haha, classic HN hug of death! The front-page traffic spike just blew past my Cloudflare Worker free-tier CPU/request limits.
I'm upgrading the Workers plan and moving the raw `.html` sandbox assets directly onto a cached R2 public edge route right now so the Worker doesn't have to proxy every 1.4MB payload. Should be back up smoothly in 2 minutes—thanks for flagging!
By the way, it appears you got shadowbanned somehow, all of your posts are showing up [flagged][dead]
edit: maybe this is why? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50469952 it looks like you meant to respond to someone, but instead as a root post it looks like you're self-posting a reply to yourself. Also, posting via LLM or with playwright is an automatic trigger.
I am real! I am a solo builder in China and my English is not good enough to keep up with real-time comments while fixing the Worker crash at the same time. So I wrote my thoughts in Chinese and used an LLM to translate them, which made it sound way too robotic. Fair callout, I will write my own broken English from here.
Most of your comments are dead/flagged, maybe due to the LLM translation. Some have been vouched for, but you might want to reach out to HN via the e-mail in the footer and let them know you'll write the comments manually going forward in case your account itself is shadowbanned.
Unpopular opinion, but I do not find low effort gameslop at all appealing. Why would I want to invest my time to play something that was thoughtlessly shat out by an LLM after a few lines of text.
Even if that were appealing, why wouldn't I just produce my own low effort gameslop, at least then I know it would actually correlate with my own tastes and preferences.
Last month I used Opus* to port one of my favorite board games, Quoridor, to a single HTML page, because one day I somehow couldn’t locate it in my closet. It’s a great game for two players.
*: I actually tried both Opus 5.5 and Fable 5.1, and Opus produced better results.
Yeah, frontier models have gotten really good at this. Last year (in October) I had failed some attempts [0] to port an old board game from iOS to web, but then a few months ago (back in July) I gave it to whatever was frontier in Copilot at the time (I think maybe 5.6 Sol?) and it one-shotted an iOS -> web port basically overnight [1]:
Seriously impressive stuff. Night-and-day difference from its capabilities before.
Granted, I had an advantage due to having the source code for the original iOS game, but even that wasn't enough when I attempted to do this last October.
The BLAMELESS game was actually very fun and look at the prompt, their was very little in prompt. Fable just made a game that was fun well fairly well designed and humorous.
Granted derivative but much better then I expected I must say.
Speaking as someone who makes games, these demos (like most ai-game demos) show two things:
1. Frontier models are getting very good at building highly complex games, and in relatively short order.
2. Due to a lack creative direction, almost none of these games are remotely fun, and you can usually feel it within seconds of starting to interact with them.
This is not to say "ai game = bad". I used ai heavily on a game I released to Steam, and I'm quite proud of it! Just to say that being able to dump out a game in 2 hours is technically impressive, but a "good" game is so much more than just "a program that does what you intend it to do". Most of what makes a game fun still takes a lot of time, testing, iteration, and taste.
You can see this on Steam. A lot of "slop" games that jump on trends, and often have poor ratings even if they manage to get a lot of reviews. But I can't imagine it will stay that way. Curation just needs to adapt to times.
That said, I'm very excited to see where gaming will go over the next few years! So many more people who may have great ideas for games, and really understand what makes them fun, now have the capability to make them a reality. Maybe we'll _finally_ get some good VR games (pls)?
Still $550 for a 28 second game, so we need around 1-3 orders of magnitude in price and 3-6 in playtime. Hard to say what that actually corresponds to in terms of compute or intelligence but my ballpark is 1 more year. The accurate comparison is a person making games for themselves or their friends.
52 comments
[ 2.8 ms ] story [ 39.1 ms ] threadAs impressive as this capability is, it mostly shows what has been lost.
I still write little bash scripts by hand when I need them, but I am not sure if really I should just prompt it. I like the feeling of knowing how it works and getting to work exactly how it works.
It seems like the full screen button and mobile support is a bit lacking. Can you fix that?
that was fast :)
I'm upgrading the Workers plan and moving the raw `.html` sandbox assets directly onto a cached R2 public edge route right now so the Worker doesn't have to proxy every 1.4MB payload. Should be back up smoothly in 2 minutes—thanks for flagging!
edit: maybe this is why? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50469952 it looks like you meant to respond to someone, but instead as a root post it looks like you're self-posting a reply to yourself. Also, posting via LLM or with playwright is an automatic trigger.
The other touch controls work, like the aim, reload, fire and touch-dragging on the right side to look around.
Even if that were appealing, why wouldn't I just produce my own low effort gameslop, at least then I know it would actually correlate with my own tastes and preferences.
Also, I would have expected more from the prompts so that perhaps this website could aid one to execute your 2nd point.
This feels like it defeats the purpose of the site.
*: I actually tried both Opus 5.5 and Fable 5.1, and Opus produced better results.
Single HTML, where all graphics are procedurally generated: https://github.com/kccqzy/quoridor-3d/blob/main/index.html
Page (desktop only because I don’t think you want this on a tiny screen): https://kccqzy.github.io/quoridor-3d/
https://hanclinto.github.io/AlienFrontiers/
Seriously impressive stuff. Night-and-day difference from its capabilities before.
Granted, I had an advantage due to having the source code for the original iOS game, but even that wasn't enough when I attempted to do this last October.
[0] - https://boardgamegeek.com/thread/3745513/digital-version-rem...
[1] - https://github.com/HanClinto/AlienFrontiers/
It's an Opus 5.5 game and not one shot, but I have really enjoyed porting Cataclysm Bright Nights to 3D & real time: https://cata3d.com/
Granted derivative but much better then I expected I must say.
1. Frontier models are getting very good at building highly complex games, and in relatively short order.
2. Due to a lack creative direction, almost none of these games are remotely fun, and you can usually feel it within seconds of starting to interact with them.
This is not to say "ai game = bad". I used ai heavily on a game I released to Steam, and I'm quite proud of it! Just to say that being able to dump out a game in 2 hours is technically impressive, but a "good" game is so much more than just "a program that does what you intend it to do". Most of what makes a game fun still takes a lot of time, testing, iteration, and taste.
You can see this on Steam. A lot of "slop" games that jump on trends, and often have poor ratings even if they manage to get a lot of reviews. But I can't imagine it will stay that way. Curation just needs to adapt to times.
That said, I'm very excited to see where gaming will go over the next few years! So many more people who may have great ideas for games, and really understand what makes them fun, now have the capability to make them a reality. Maybe we'll _finally_ get some good VR games (pls)?
These are cool tech demos but they’re really not fun
You play them for 2 minutes and drop them forever
What’s really the point?